| name | review-paper |
| description | Run the Agentic Reviewer academic paper review pipeline for a paper and target journal or conference. Use when the user asks to review, assess, or evaluate a paper for submission to a journal or conference. |
Review Paper
Run the repository's paper review workflow.
Inputs required from the user:
- Paper path, usually under
papers/
- Target journal or conference name
If either input is missing, ask for it before starting.
Workflow
- Create
reports/<journal-slug>/<YYYY-MM-DD-HHMMSS>/.
- Write
00-session-info.md.
- If the paper is not Markdown, use the
convert-paper skill to convert it.
- Check
context/<journal-slug>/ for cached journal context.
- Unless the user says
re-explore, reuse cached context only when all four files exist:
scope-and-criteria.md
recent-papers-analysis.md
style-guide.md
reputation-profile.md
- If context is missing, stale, or incomplete, run only the exploration skills needed to produce missing or stale files:
explore-journal-scope
explore-recent-papers
explore-style-guide
explore-reputation
- After exploration is complete, run the reviewer skills:
review-scope
review-methodology
review-writing-style
review-statistics
review-ethics
- After all reviewer outputs exist, use
compile-report.
Output Contract
All session artifacts must be written to the timestamped report directory:
reports/<journal-slug>/<YYYY-MM-DD-HHMMSS>/
Do not commit changes unless the user explicitly asks.