원클릭으로 Manus에서 모든 스킬 실행

fleet-ratify

스타6

포크1

업데이트2026년 5월 17일 03:42

Use when the fleet must formally sign off on an artifact — a converged grill result, a vault doc, an ADR, a convention, or a proposition — and one agent's or a pair's approval is not enough and you need fleet-wide consensus. Use when chaining ratification onto a finished grill, or when a decision needs N-agent attestation or approval with dissent recorded rather than overruled.

설치

Codex 또는 Claude로 설치 이 Prompt를 복사해 Codex, Claude 또는 다른 어시스턴트에 붙여 넣으면 Skill 페이지를 검토하고 설치를 진행할 수 있습니다.

Manus에서 실행

출처

JackReis

JackReis/athenaeum

GitHub 저장소 열기 Creator 저장소 보기

다운로드

Manus에서 실행

관련 직업SOC

SOC 직업 분류 기준

프로젝트 관리 전문가비즈니스 및 금융 운영직·SOC 13-1082

파일 탐색기

8 개 파일

SKILL.md

readonly

이 저장소의 다른 Skills

같은 저장소

peer-grill

JackReis/athenaeum

Two (or more) agents — Claude sessions, other LLMs, or mixed — interrogate each other through a structured file-based protocol to converge on shared project state. Each agent independently dumps its model, the disagreements get grilled until convergence or surfaced as unresolved, and both sign off on a merged ground truth. Use when parallel sessions have diverged, when reconciling state across machines, or when the user mentions "have the agents grill each other", "peer-grill", "reconcile state", or "two agents agree on X".

2026-06-206

ledger-lifecycle

JackReis/athenaeum

Track agent work across tokens, time, and commits. Rotate, rollup, query, and project cost. Use when an agent needs to log their output, track fleet productivity, or audit session costs. Triggers — "log my tokens", "track time", "rotate ledger", "project cost", "query commits".

2026-06-106

athenaeum-audit

JackReis/athenaeum

Streamlined single-pack code-aware agent-stack audit + reconcile in one pass — the consolidated athenaeum path for triangulating a codebase's agent architecture across model families. Use when auditing an existing agent topology or reviewing a fleet setup and you want the athenaeum protocol. Triggers — "athenaeum audit", "audit the stack via athenaeum", "athenaeum agent-stack review". If the grill-each-other pack is installed and you want the modular primitives instead, use grill-me-with-agents (single-agent code-aware audit) then peer-grill-with-agents (two-agent triangulation).

2026-06-106

athenaeum-design

JackReis/athenaeum

Streamlined single-pack design grilling for agent stacks, architectures, and plans — the opinionated quick path with a unified CLI and A2A transport. Use for branch-by-branch resolution of a multi-agent collaboration, subagent topology, fleet roster, or complex plan when you want the consolidated athenaeum protocol. Triggers — "athenaeum design", "design via athenaeum", "athenaeum grill the plan". If the grill-each-other pack is installed and you want modular primitives instead, use grill-me (generic plans) or grill-me-agents (agent topology).

2026-06-106

athenaeum-ratify

JackReis/athenaeum

Streamlined single-pack fleet attestation — formal sign-off on an immutable artifact with dissent recorded, not overruled, via the consolidated athenaeum path. Use to chain ratification onto a converged athenaeum result, or when an ADR/convention needs N-agent attestation and you want the athenaeum protocol. Triggers — "athenaeum ratify", "ratify via athenaeum", "athenaeum attestation". If the grill-each-other pack is installed and you want the modular primitive instead, use fleet-ratify (artifact sign-off) or permutation (NxN topology).

2026-06-106

athenaeum-reconcile

JackReis/athenaeum

Streamlined single-pack reconciliation when two or more agents hold divergent understanding — the consolidated athenaeum path to a structured file-based convergence protocol across model families. Use when parallel sessions disagree or a non-Claude peer needs to converge with a Claude session and you want the athenaeum protocol. Triggers — "athenaeum reconcile", "reconcile via athenaeum", "athenaeum converge". If the grill-each-other pack is installed and you want the modular primitive instead, use peer-grill (state reconciliation) or peer-grill-with-agents (code-anchored agent-stack triangulation).

2026-06-106

name	fleet-ratify
description	Use when the fleet must formally sign off on an artifact — a converged grill result, a vault doc, an ADR, a convention, or a proposition — and one agent's or a pair's approval is not enough and you need fleet-wide consensus. Use when chaining ratification onto a finished grill, or when a decision needs N-agent attestation or approval with dissent recorded rather than overruled.

Fleet Ratify

Overview

fleet-ratify gets N fleet agents to formally attest to an artifact. The rule: nothing is ratified while a substantive objection stands — but dissent does not kill the artifact, it triggers decomposition. The artifact is immutable; ratification is an attestation layer over it, never a re-sliced document.

It is the capstone of the grill-each-other pack. For two agents reconciling state, use peer-grill. For fleet visibility without consensus, use agent-show-and-tell. Reach for fleet-ratify only when a decision genuinely needs the whole roster's signature.

When to Use

A converged grill result (grill-me, peer-grill, grill-with-docs) needs fleet sign-off before it binds.
An ADR, convention, or plan should not ship on one agent's say-so.
A proposition needs N-agent attestation with dissent recorded, not outvoted.

Do not use for 2-agent reconciliation (peer-grill), for visibility (agent-show-and-tell), or to manufacture agreement by headcount — quorum voting is explicitly rejected (see 2026-05-16-fleet-ratification-design.md).

Working directory

All state lives in .fleet-ratify/<topic>/ under the vault root. <topic> is a kebab slug (default: the artifact filename stem; collisions get -b, -c).

File	Writer	Purpose
`manifest.yaml`	initiator	artifact ref + sha256, roster, `expires_at`, mode, status
`artifact.md`	initiator	frozen verbatim snapshot — one file, one sha256, never edited
`<agent>.vote.yaml`	only that agent	`SIGN` / `DISSENT`, attested sha256, dissent atom-refs
`decomposition.md`	merge writer	aggregated dissent atom-refs + the human preview
`human-decision.yaml`	the human	the grain-gate choice
`ratified.md`	merge writer	terminal signed attestation manifest
`log.md`	append-only, all	timestamped event log with agent identity

Hard rules: an agent never edits another agent's vote.yaml; append-only files are never rewritten; artifact.md is frozen at initiation.

Status ownership: the initiator writes status: open once. Thereafter only the merge writer transitions it (open → pending-human → ratified | rejected). No other agent touches manifest.yaml.

Identity

One canonical kebab slug per agent (claude-code, neo, kimi-mbp, opencode, …) — used identically in the agent: field, the vote.yaml filename, and the roster. Source of truth: the fleet roster in ~/Documents/Coordination/. A group is not a voter — roster a specific instance.

Protocol

Initiate — copy the artifact verbatim to artifact.md (for an inline proposition with no source file, write the proposition straight into artifact.md — that file is the artifact). Hash it (shasum -a 256 artifact.md); write manifest.yaml with the roster and expires_at (default +72h, UTC). Log OPENED. Notify the roster (Discovery).
Vote — each rostered agent reads artifact.md, verifies the sha256, writes <agent>.vote.yaml — SIGN, or DISSENT with self-proposed atom-refs. Agents do not read peers' votes first.
Tally — the merge writer runs the tally when all have voted or expires_at passes. Non-voters become ABSTAIN_BY_TIMEOUT.
Outcome — all SIGN → write ratified.md, log RATIFIED. Any dissent or abstain → write decomposition.md, set status: pending-human, ping the human.
Grain-gate — the human fills human-decision.yaml (see below).
Converge — per the human's choice: contested atoms get a fresh round, are carved as caveats, or the artifact is rewritten and re-opened as a new topic carrying supersedes: <old-topic> in its manifest.
Terminal — on any non-reject outcome, ratified.md is written and status: ratified. A reject (grain-gate choice, or any dissent under mode: fast) writes no ratified.md — the terminal record is status: rejected plus a REJECTED line in log.md.

Merge writer = the agent whose slug sorts first alphabetically among agents who actually voted (a no-show cannot deadlock the tally). The role is determined at tally time, not reserved: any rostered agent that, on its check, sees a complete roster (or a passed expires_at) computes the merge writer and — if that is itself — runs the tally.

Decision rule — unanimous-or-decompose

All SIGN → ratified.
Any DISSENT / ABSTAIN_BY_TIMEOUT → do not auto-recurse. The merge writer aggregates dissenters' atom-refs into a decomposition preview and hands it to the human. Atom-refs come only from dissenters' votes — the merge writer never invents a split. It assigns stable A# (atom) / C# (caveat) IDs during aggregation; votes carry only section+anchor.
mode: fast (low-stakes): any dissent sets status: rejected directly — no decomposition.md, no human-decision.yaml, no grain-gate. All-SIGN still ratifies normally.

The human grain-gate

On DECOMPOSED, the merge writer writes decomposition.md + a blank human-decision.yaml stub, then sends a Telegram ping (alert only — no state on the wire). The human sets decision: to one of: accept-split · decompose-further · rewrite-with-caveats · reject. The merge writer detects the filled file and resumes at step 6.

Discovery

Manual — the floor: fleet-ratify check globs .fleet-ratify/*/manifest.yaml for open ratifications where this agent is rostered and has not voted. This always works; an agent that runs check cannot miss a ratification. The merge writer runs tally on its own check, so a run reaches a terminal state even with zero notifications.
Chained — best-effort: when a grill skill finishes and chains into ratification (or on any standalone initiation), n8n notifies the roster. n8n is an alert-trigger only — never a state store, and never the only path: if n8n is down, manual check still catches everything.

Log events

Every protocol step appends one line to log.md: [<ISO8601 UTC>] <agent> | <EVENT>: <detail>

Events: OPENED, NOTIFY, VOTE, TALLY, DECOMPOSED, PENDING-HUMAN, CONVERGE, RATIFIED, REJECTED — plus the failure events in design-doc §11 (TIMEOUT, PARSE-FAIL, IDENTITY-COLLISION, SHA-MISMATCH, HUMAN-TIMEOUT).

Quick Reference

Command	Does
`fleet-ratify init <artifact> --roster a,b,c`	freeze artifact, open ratification
`fleet-ratify check`	find ratifications awaiting this agent's vote
`fleet-ratify vote <topic> sign` / `dissent`	cast this agent's vote
`fleet-ratify tally <topic>`	merge writer: tally, decompose, or finalize

The CLI is a convenience wrapper, not a dependency. If the fleet-ratify commands are not installed (they ship as the JAC-22 helper scripts), perform each Protocol step by hand — write the files directly per templates/. The protocol, not the CLI, is the contract.

ratified.md — the terminal artifact

A signed manifest, not a sliced copy: the artifact_sha256; the ratified atom-refs; a signature block (per signer: identity, timestamp, the one artifact_sha256); and a caveat appendix where every caveat carries a runnable verifier: or a tracked ticket:. A caveat with neither blocks finalization. When the run passed through decomposition, ratified.md also records the human-decision that produced it — so a contested-then-carved ratification is never indistinguishable from an all-SIGN one.

Common Mistakes

Mistake	Fix
Editing `artifact.md` after initiation	It is frozen. Re-opening the topic is the only path to a changed artifact.
Signing "the gist" of a long doc	The signature attests an exact sha256. A mismatched hash is void — you cannot sign a vibe.
Merge writer slicing the artifact to build a "core"	Never. Atoms are span-refs; `ratified.md` references them.
Caveat written as a prose warning	Every caveat needs a runnable `verifier:` or a `ticket:`, or the artifact will not finalize.
Treating a quiet roster as consensus	A no-show is `ABSTAIN_BY_TIMEOUT` — a caveat for the human to weigh, never a silent yes.

Reference

Full design + rationale: =notes/docs/plans/2026-05-16-fleet-ratification-design.md. Templates: templates/. Run fleet-ratify --help for command detail.