assess-adoption

name	assess-adoption
description	Assess the Agent Adoption level of the current project across all 8 criteria (A1–A8) and produce a structured report with the achieved level, per-criterion scores, gaps, and recommendations.
allowed-tools	Bash Read

Agent Adoption Assessment

This skill runs all 8 criterion checks and produces a structured adoption report.

---

Instructions

Step 1 — Score each criterion

For each criterion, read the corresponding skill file and follow its evidence-gathering and scoring instructions. Record the score before moving to the next criterion.

• A1 Agent Context Availability — follow the /verify-a1 skill
• A2 Agent-Authored Contributions — follow the /verify-a2 skill
• A3 Feedback Loop Closure — follow the /verify-a3 skill
• A4 Task Scope — follow the /verify-a4 skill
• A5 Workflow Integration — follow the /verify-a5 skill
• A6 Autonomous Operation — follow the /verify-a6 skill
• A7 Proactive Quality Management — follow the /verify-a7 skill
• A8 Planning Integration — follow the /verify-a8 skill

---

Step 2 — Determine the adoption level

After scoring all criteria, determine the highest adoption level where all thresholds are met:

Criterion	Level 1	Level 2	Level 3	Level 4
A1	≥ 1	≥ 2	≥ 3	≥ 3
A2	≥ 1	≥ 2	≥ 3	≥ 3
A3	—	≥ 2	≥ 2	≥ 3
A4	≥ 1	≥ 2	≥ 3	≥ 3
A5	—	≥ 1	≥ 3	≥ 3
A6	—	—	≥ 3	≥ 3
A7	—	—	—	≥ 3
A8	—	—	—	≥ 2

Check Level 1 first. If all Level 1 thresholds are met, check Level 2, and so on. The achieved level is the highest where all thresholds pass.

---

Step 3 — Produce the report

Produce a report in exactly this structure:

---

Agent Adoption Assessment Report

Project: [name from README or directory name] Date: [today's date]

Result: Level [0/1/2/3/4] — [Level Name]

Level names: 0 = Unassisted, 1 = Vibe Coding, 2 = Agentic Engineering, 3 = Software Factory, 4 = Sustainable Autonomy

Criterion Scores

Criterion	Name	Score	Max
A1	Agent Context Availability	[score]	3
A2	Agent-Authored Contributions	[score]	3
A3	Feedback Loop Closure	[score]	3
A4	Task Scope	[score]	3
A5	Workflow Integration	[score]	3
A6	Autonomous Operation	[score]	3
A7	Proactive Quality Management	[score]	3
A8	Planning Integration	[score]	3

Gaps Blocking the Next Level

[If the project is at Level 4, write "Maximum level reached."]

[Otherwise, list each criterion below threshold for Level N+1:]

To reach Level [N+1] ([Name]), improve:

• A_ [Name]: currently [score], need [required] — [one sentence on what to improve]

Readiness–Adoption Compatibility

[State the minimum recommended readiness level for the current adoption level:

• Adoption 0–1: Readiness 1+ recommended
• Adoption 2: Readiness 2+ recommended
• Adoption 3–4: Readiness 3 required

If the project's readiness level is known, note whether it supports the adoption level. If readiness is unknown, recommend running /assess-readiness.]

Recommendations

[3–5 prioritised, actionable recommendations based on the gaps. Order by impact: criteria blocking a level increase first, then easiest wins.]

---