ralplan

name	ralplan
description	Iterative planning with Planner, Architect, and Critic until consensus
user-invocable	true

Ralplan Skill

Overview

Ralplan orchestrates three specialized agents—Planner, Architect, and Critic—in an iterative loop until consensus is reached on a comprehensive work plan. This skill ensures plans are strategically sound, architecturally valid, and thoroughly reviewed before execution.

The Planning Triad

Three agents collaborate in structured phases to validate and refine work plans:

Agent	Role	Output
Planner	Strategic Planner	Creates/refines the work plan
Architect	Strategic Advisor	Answers questions, validates architecture
Critic	Ruthless Reviewer	Critiques and identifies gaps

The Iteration Loop

┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                       RALPLAN LOOP                              │
│                                                                 │
│    ┌──────────────┐                                             │
│    │   PLANNER    │◄────────────────────────────────┐           │
│    │   (Plans)    │                                 │           │
│    └──────┬───────┘                                 │           │
│           │                                         │           │
│           ▼                                         │           │
│    ┌──────────────┐     Questions?    ┌───────────┐ │           │
│    │   Has open   │─────────────────► │ ARCHITECT │ │           │
│    │  questions?  │                   │ (Advises) │ │           │
│    └──────┬───────┘                   └─────┬─────┘ │           │
│           │                                 │       │           │
│           │ No questions                    │       │           │
│           ▼                                 ▼       │           │
│    ┌──────────────┐                  ┌──────────┐   │           │
│    │    CRITIC    │◄─────────────────│ Answers  │   │           │
│    │  (Reviews)   │                  └──────────┘   │           │
│    └──────┬───────┘                                 │           │
│           │                                         │           │
│           ▼                                         │           │
│    ┌──────────────┐     REJECT      ┌──────────────┐│           │
│    │   Verdict?   │─────────────────►│  Feedback   ││           │
│    └──────┬───────┘                  │ to Planner  │┘           │
│           │                          └─────────────┘            │
│           │ OKAY                                                │
│           ▼                                                     │
│    ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │
│    │                  PLAN APPROVED                           │ │
│    │           Ready for /ralph execution                     │ │
│    └──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

State Management

Ralplan maintains persistent state in .omc/ralplan-state.json to track progress and enable recovery across interruptions:

{
  "active": true,
  "mode": "ralplan",
  "iteration": 1,
  "max_iterations": 5,
  "plan_path": ".omc/plans/[feature].md",
  "current_phase": "planner_planning",
  "started_at": "ISO-timestamp",
  "task_description": "[original task]"
}

Phases: planner_planning → architect_consultation → critic_review → handling_verdict → complete

Execution Protocol

Initialization

The skill begins by establishing the planning environment:

1. Create .omc/plans/ directory if it doesn't exist
2. Read task description from user input
3. Create ralplan-state.json with initial values:
   • active: true
   • iteration: 0
   • max_iterations: 5
   • current_phase: "planner_planning"
   • started_at: Current ISO timestamp
   • task_description: User's task description

Planner Planning Phase

The Planner creates an initial plan based on task context:

• Invoke Planner in direct planning mode (bypassing interview since task context is pre-gathered)
• Planner receives task context directly without preliminary questioning
• Planner mandatorily consults with Metis for gap detection
• Planner generates plan directly to .omc/plans/[feature-name].md
• Plan includes: requirements summary, concrete acceptance criteria, specific implementation steps with file references, risk identification with mitigations, and verification steps
• Signal completion with PLAN_READY: .omc/plans/[filename].md
• Extract plan path from completion signal and update state

Architect Consultation (Conditional)

The Architect provides strategic guidance in two scenarios:

1. After Planner: If Planner raises architectural questions needing strategic input
2. After Critic rejection: If Critic identifies questions requiring expert guidance

When invoked, the Architect receives file paths to read for analysis, not summaries. This enables thorough examination of the existing codebase context before providing recommendations.

Critic Review

The Critic examines the plan against quality standards:

• Critic receives the plan file path (per its design)
• Critic conducts thorough review of plan completeness and feasibility
• Critic emits verdict: either OKAY (approval) or REJECT with specific issues

Verdict Handling and Iteration

Based on Critic's verdict, the skill either approves the plan or continues iteration:

If verdict is OKAY:

• Mark plan as approved
• Log approval with iteration count
• Prepare plan for execution with /ralph or manual orchestration
• Set state active: false, current_phase: "complete"

If verdict is REJECT:

• Extract Critic feedback with specific issues
• Increment iteration counter
• If iteration >= max_iterations (5):
  • Force approval with warning about unresolved concerns
  • Recommend manual review before execution
• Otherwise:
  • Feed Critic feedback back to Planner
  • Return to Planner Planning phase for refinement

Iteration Rules

Rule	Description
Max 5 iterations	Safety limit prevents infinite loops
Planner owns plan	Only Planner writes to plan file
Architect provides wisdom	Architect reads and advises, never modifies
Critic has final say	Plan approved only when Critic signals OKAY
Feedback is specific	Each rejection includes actionable improvements
State persists	Progress survives session interruptions

Quality Gates

The orchestrator must verify these gates before invoking Critic for each review:

1. Plan file exists at the path specified in state
2. File references are valid - Verify all mentioned files exist in codebase
3. Acceptance criteria are concrete - No vague "improve" or "optimize" without measurable metrics
4. No ambiguous language - Each task clearly specifies what to do

If any gate fails, return to Planner with specific failure feedback for remediation.

Agent Communication Protocol

Planner to Architect Questions

ARCHITECT_QUESTION:
- Topic: [Architecture/Performance/Security/Pattern]
- Context: [What we're planning]
- Files to examine: [specific paths]
- Specific Question: [What we need answered]

Architect to Planner Answers

ARCHITECT_ANSWER:
- Topic: [Matching topic]
- Analysis: [What Architect found after reading files]
- Recommendation: [Specific guidance]
- Trade-offs: [What to consider]
- References: [file:line citations from codebase]

Critic to Planner Feedback

CRITIC_FEEDBACK:
- Verdict: REJECT
- Critical Issues:
  1. [Issue with specific fix required]
  2. [Issue with specific fix required]
- Minor Issues:
  1. [Nice to fix]
- Questions for Architect (if any):
  1. [Architectural question needing expert input]

Cancellation

To stop an active ralplan session:

• Use /cancel-ralph (automatically detects ralplan via state file)
• Or manually delete .omc/ralplan-state.json

Skill Workflow

1. Initialize state and log: [RALPLAN Iteration 0/5] Initializing...
2. Parse task from user input
3. Spawn Planner in direct planning mode
4. Iterate through planning loop with observability logging at each phase
5. Complete when Critic approves or max iterations reached with warnings

The iterative loop refines the plan until it meets the rigorous standards of all three agents, ensuring comprehensive, architecturally sound work plans ready for execution.