conformance-walk

---

name: conformance-walk description: Conformance Walk — freeze-then-judge on the source→delivered→live axis: one cw_core + Source/Delivered/Live adapter families, coverage vs pass-rate, discrete verdicts. Use for any testable surface.

Conformance Walk (CW)

One-liner. ONE surface-agnostic core (cw_core) + a registry of per-surface adapters grouped into THREE oracle families on ONE delivery axis — source → shipped artifact → live behavior: SOURCE (SCM = Source Conformance Matrix — symbol holds its contract in source, judged without running), DELIVERED (DCM/FCM — the capability is reachable + non-stub in the SHIPPED artifact: wheel × binding × resolved feature set), LIVE (API / CLI / MCP / FE — a real invocation matches the frozen post-state). ONE discipline across all three: enumerate every actionable unit → attach a FROZEN expectation → judge observed state with a DETERMINISTIC oracle → report coverage HONESTLY (separate from pass-rate, machine-derived denominator) → RATCHET so a new unit without an expectation fails → TIER severity by surface-role. cw_core is built once; each surface supplies a small adapter. Users never choose "which family" — the matching adapter activates by the surface touched.

The delivery gap is the thesis. The dominant real-world failure is not "source lacks the feature" and not "the running service misbehaves" — it is source HAS the feature, tests PASS against source, yet the published artifact the user installs does NOT contain it (a capability gated off the default cargo feature set compiles out of the wheel; a binding wrapper is never generated). DELIVERED is the middle node nobody instruments. cw_core's record schema IS the interop boundary that lets a non-core-importing adapter conform (§6), and one capability record spans symbol (SCM) → delivered-node (DCM) → endpoint/tool/route (LIVE): a red delivered-node lights the WHOLE capability.

The four always-on MUST clauses are in rules/conformance-walk.md. This skill is the HOW: the methodology, cw_core + its JSON-schema interop boundary, the normative adapter-registry interface, the per-consumer adapter obligation, the three-family adapter table, the phase-action triggers, and the CW-vs-/redteam role split. Depth beyond the 80% here lives in three sub-files (loaded on demand): adapter-registry-interface.md, coverage-honesty-contract.md, reference-adapters.md.

1. The freeze-then-judge model (the heart)

• Freeze BEFORE observe. The expectation — the contract or transition a unit should hold — is pinned into a committed baseline BEFORE the unit is observed. An expectation back-fitted to whatever the code did is not an expectation.
• Floor ≠ expectation. "compiled / rendered / 200 / didn't crash" is the FLOOR. A different-than-expected effect is not a pass. (rule MUST-1.)
• Two expectation tiers. STRUCTURAL — machine-derived for every unit, zero hand-authoring cost, the mandatory floor of every unit. SEMANTIC — hand-authored or capture-then-human-freeze, only for the high-value units. Exact expected bytes (a toast string, an error message) are CAPTURED on first run and HUMAN-FROZEN before they assert — never invented from memory.

2. The expectation schema (the record every adapter emits)

One record per unit, four columns (surface-neutral):

• ACTUAL — what the surface exposes (signature/route/endpoint/flag/tool; observed state).
• INTENDED — the frozen expectation (contract / transition / status+schema+read-back).
• CONFORMANCE — the observed-vs-expected verdict + evidence.
• LINKAGE — edges to other units, keyed to a shared unit_id: a symbol delivered in a shipped wheel and exposed as an MCP tool surfaced in a FE route is ONE capability-record spanning symbol (SOURCE) → delivered-node (DELIVERED) → endpoint/tool/route (LIVE); a Fail on ANY node — especially the DELIVERED middle the neighbors cannot reach — lights the WHOLE capability. The integrated-linkage capture is the argument FOR unification.

3. Coverage vs pass-rate (the honesty contract)

• Denominator is machine-derived — enumerated from source/runtime, never hand-listed.
• Coverage (nothing unmeasured) is reported SEPARATELY from pass-rate (verdict outcomes). Two numbers, always. Coverage can be 100% while pass-rate is 80% — that is the honest state; the fails are the fix-list.
• No-vacuous-eval guard — a verdict counts toward coverage only if it carries ≥1 real assertion. Closes the assert(true) / expect(true) hole.
• No fabricated 100% by dropping non-pass rows or shrinking the denominator to the passing set.

Full machine-derived-denominator patterns per surface, the no-vacuous guard, the freshness+collision ratchet mechanics, and fail-closed integrity (empty-generation / mass-removal tripwires) are in coverage-honesty-contract.md.

4. The verdict taxonomy (discrete, closed)

Pass | Fail | Blocked | Retest | Skipped | Not-Run. Blocked (precondition down) ≠ Pass ≠ Fail. Retest (non-deterministic) ≠ Fail. Skipped (deliberately out of denominator). Not-Run (in denominator, never reached — a coverage gap, NOT a pass). (rule MUST-4.)

5. pass^k reliability

For a non-deterministic surface, a single Pass is weak evidence. Run the unit k times; report pass^k (k, passed, mean, std). A unit that passes 3/5 is Retest, not Pass. Reliability is a property of the verdict, not a separate gate.

6. The adapter-registry interface (NORMATIVE — design "A")

Each per-surface adapter supplies exactly three REQUIRED methods; the core (cw_core) owns everything else. This is the ratified freeze-line: the required interface is the INTERSECTION both shipped instances (SCM static-symbol, TOW route/interaction) already satisfy.

cw_core's record schema IS the cross-runtime interop boundary. The core is a surface-agnostic package named cw_core, built once; its per-unit record is pinned as a frozen JSON-Schema data contract (record.schema.json v1.0.0, Draft 2020-12). An adapter conforms in ONE of two modes: Mode A (observer) — the adapter IMPORTS cw_core and calls its coverage / ratchet / verdict machinery directly (a same-runtime SOURCE or DELIVERED adapter); Mode B (standalone) — an adapter in a DIFFERENT runtime that CANNOT import the core (a LIVE Playwright/FE adapter, a non-Python surface) conforms by EMITTING JSON that validates against the frozen contract, with ZERO shared code. The schema — not the code — is what a new-language adapter binds to, so a LIVE adapter running in another runtime is a first-class member without ever linking cw_core.

enumerate_units()            -> Iterable[Unit]     # machine-derived denominator; NEVER hand-listed
freeze_expectation(unit)     -> Expectation        # the frozen contract, pinned to the baseline BEFORE observation
oracle(unit, expectation)    -> Verdict            # deterministic; judges observed-vs-expected; from the discrete taxonomy

# Core-owned (surface-neutral): the {ACTUAL,INTENDED,CONFORMANCE,LINKAGE} record schema,
# coverage math (denominator + separate-from-pass-rate + no-vacuous guard), the freshness+
# collision ratchet over the committed baseline, the discrete verdict taxonomy, the two-tier
# oracle split (deterministic load-bearing / semantic advisory), the role-severity tier.

Capture-then-human-freeze is an OPTIONAL core-owned lifecycle (design "A"). The three methods above are the REQUIRED interface. For an adapter whose exact expected bytes are only knowable at runtime (a live surface: a toast string, an error message, a rendered post-state), the core ALSO offers an OPTIONAL capture-then-human-freeze lifecycle: on first run the semantic expectation is CAPTUREd, a human FREEZES it, and only then does it assert. A static adapter (SCM) whose expectations are statically knowable simply does not use it; a live adapter (TOW) does. Keeping it OPTIONAL and core-owned holds the required surface at three methods so a third adapter is never blocked by a two-instance-specific choice.

Adapter obligations the core validates: emits the core record schema; derives its coverage denominator machine-side; freezes before it observes; its deterministic oracle is the gate and any semantic output is advisory. Full method contracts, the Unit/Expectation/Verdict types, the capture-then-human-freeze lifecycle, and a worked adapter skeleton per surface are in adapter-registry-interface.md.

7. Per-consumer adapter obligation

For EACH surface your repo exposes, supply an adapter implementing the three methods, emitting the cw_core record schema, deriving its coverage denominator machine-side. A source-only repo supplies only the static-symbol (SOURCE) adapter (no FE/browser cost); a repo that ships a wheel/binding adds the DELIVERED adapter; a repo with a live surface adds a LIVE adapter. An integrated repo supplies adapters across all three families and the CORE captures the LINKAGE across them. This is the TOW (#1137) "per-template instantiation" generalized across the three oracle families (source / delivered / live). The adapter is NOT a cascaded loom file — the skill specifies the obligation; each repo authors its own adapters for the surfaces it exposes.

8. The adapter families (Source · Delivered · Live)

Adapters group into THREE oracle families on the delivery axis source → shipped artifact → live behavior. Every adapter implements the same three methods (§6) over cw_core; families differ ONLY on the UNIT enumerated and whether the oracle judges STATIC source, the BUILT artifact, or a LIVE post-state. LIVE contains four surface adapters (API / CLI / MCP / FE).

Family	Adapter(s)	UNIT	Oracle (freeze → judge)
SOURCE	static-symbol (BE) = SCM	public fn / struct / enum	signature + spec-conformance + test-tier + AST-tamper, judged WITHOUT running
DELIVERED	shipped-artifact = DCM/FCM	the SAME capability, in the shipped artifact	reachable + non-stub in the built wheel × binding × resolved feature set, judged WITHOUT running behavior (5 lenses below)
LIVE	route/interaction (FE) = TOW (#1137)	route + interactive element	endpoint-fired + DOM/a11y read-back + record read-back, judged AFTER freezing the expected transition
LIVE	endpoint (API)	endpoint	status + response-schema + persisted-effect read-back
LIVE	flag (CLI)	subcommand / flag	exit code + output-shape + state-effect read-back
LIVE	tool (MCP)	tool call	result-schema + side-effect read-back

DELIVERED's five lenses (the middle family the flat model lacked): L1 reachability (feature-resolved against the published artifact) · L2 semantic-stub · L3 orphan-primitive (no-caller / not wired to an entrypoint) · L4 binding-delivery (binding-parity, authority derived from the ecosystem lead) · L5 naive-fallback. The STRUCTURAL lenses (L1 / L3 / L4) are irrefutable facts and MAY BLOCK the gate; L2 semantic-stub + L5 naive-fallback are SEMANTIC → ADVISORY-only worklist rows, NEVER a structural BLOCK (a semantic BLOCK ships false positives at scale — rules/conformance-walk.md MUST-2).

Auto-activation by touched surface; keyed to the SAME unit_id, a capability's SOURCE symbol, DELIVERED node, and LIVE endpoint/tool/route join into ONE linkage record. The reference adapters are SCM (SOURCE) and TOW (LIVE-FE) — the two running instances the core was extracted from — plus the DELIVERED middle family; the LIVE API/CLI/MCP adapters are thin unit-enumerator + oracle over the proven core. The SCM / DELIVERED / TOW reference-adapter worked examples are in reference-adapters.md; the API / CLI / MCP surface skeletons are in adapter-registry-interface.md.

9. Phase-action triggers

CW is a STANDING capability (record + CI gate always-on) with phase-specific ACTIONS. Freeze-then-judge requires the expectation to precede the observation, so declaration is upstream:

• analyze: enumerator runs → surface INVENTORY + baseline coverage (the un-expectationed frontier).
• todos: each todo adding a unit DECLARES its frozen expectation — the freeze, BEFORE code.
• implement: records populate incrementally; the FRESHNESS GATE fires — no new unit without a declared expectation.
• redteam: THE PRIMARY GATE — judge every unit, structural-BLOCK failures, hand the human the semantic-ADVISORY worklist.
• codify: absorb this round's findings into the role-severity tier prior (self-recalibration); record the frontier debt.
• deploy (+ every CI run): the freshness gate + collision ratchet stand as the structural merge gate — no ship with a coverage regression or a new-unit-without-expectation.

One line: freeze @ todos → generate + freshness-gate @ implement → PRIMARY adversarial walk @ redteam → absorb + recalibrate @ codify → ratchet merge-gate @ deploy/CI.

10. CW vs /redteam (role split — not a replacement)

CW is the STANDING, mechanical, PRE-/redteam gate: it front-loads the deterministic half (structural BLOCK on irrefutable facts) and hands the human a PRE-COMPUTED per-unit semantic-ADVISORY worklist — the exact unit + the exact question — instead of making the human rediscover it. /redteam remains the ADVERSARIAL human/agent judgment layer that adjudicates the advisory worklist and hunts for what no oracle can enumerate. CW makes /redteam's budget go to ADJUDICATION, not discovery; it does NOT replace the adversarial round.

11. The role-severity tier (self-recalibrating)

Severity = f(verdict-status, surface-role), NEVER unit count. The role/value prior is evidence-driven and self-recalibrating (a defect-history-hot surface promotes ITSELF toward a blocking tier; a value-ranked journey carries a user-anchored value-anchor) — never a frozen hand-ranking, never a hardcoded denylist. Only irrefutable structural facts on a role-relevant unit BLOCK; semantic statuses are the advisory worklist.