testing-guide

name	testing-guide
scope	uds-specific
description	Testing pyramid and test writing standards for UT/IT/ST/E2E. Supports ISTQB and Industry Pyramid frameworks. Use when: writing tests, discussing test coverage, test strategy, or test naming. Keywords: test, unit, integration, e2e, coverage, mock, ISTQB, SIT, 測試, 單元, 整合, 端對端.

Testing Guide

Language: English | 繁體中文

Version: 1.2.0 Last Updated: 2026-04-18 Applicability: Claude Code Skills

---

Purpose

This skill provides testing pyramid standards and best practices for systematic testing, supporting both ISTQB and Industry Pyramid frameworks.

Testing Skills Navigator | 測試技能導航

UDS provides 6 testing-related skills. Use this decision tree to find the right one:

What do you want to do? | 你想做什麼？
├── Measure code coverage (lines/branches/functions)    → /coverage
├── Track which requirements have tests (AC traceability) → /ac-coverage
├── Develop with Test-Driven Development (Red-Green-Refactor) → /tdd
├── Write BDD scenarios (Given-When-Then)               → /bdd
├── Define acceptance tests with stakeholders            → /atdd
└── Learn testing standards and best practices           → /testing (this skill)

Skill	Focus	焦點
/testing	Standards and best practices reference	測試標準與最佳實踐參考
/coverage	Code-level coverage analysis	程式碼層級覆蓋率分析
/ac-coverage	Requirement-level AC traceability	需求層級 AC 可追蹤性
/tdd	Red-Green-Refactor development cycle	紅-綠-重構開發循環
/bdd	Behavior scenarios with Given-When-Then	Given-When-Then 行為場景
/atdd	Acceptance criteria with stakeholders	與利害關係人定義驗收條件

Framework Selection

Framework	Levels	Best For
ISTQB	UT → IT/SIT → ST → AT/UAT	Enterprise, compliance, formal QA
Industry Pyramid	UT (70%) → IT (20%) → E2E (10%)	Agile, DevOps, CI/CD

Note on Integration Testing abbreviation:

• IT (Integration Testing): Agile/DevOps communities
• SIT (System Integration Testing): Enterprise/ISTQB contexts
• Both refer to the same testing level

Quick Reference

Testing Pyramid (Industry Standard)

              ┌─────────┐
              │   E2E   │  ← 10% (Fewer, slower)
             ─┴─────────┴─
            ┌─────────────┐
            │   IT/SIT    │  ← 20% (Integration)
           ─┴─────────────┴─
          ┌─────────────────┐
          │       UT        │  ← 70% (Unit)
          └─────────────────┘

Test Levels Overview

Level	Scope	Speed	Dependencies
UT	Single function/class	< 100ms	Mocked
IT/SIT	Component interaction	1-10s	Real DB (containerized)
ST	Full system (ISTQB)	Minutes	Production-like
E2E	User journeys	30s+	Everything real
AT/UAT	Business validation (ISTQB)	Varies	Everything real

Coverage Targets

Metric	Minimum	Recommended
Line	70%	85%
Branch	60%	80%
Function	80%	90%

Detailed Guidelines

For complete standards, see:

• Testing Theory - Educational knowledge base
• Testing Pyramid - Detailed pyramid ratios
• Test Skeleton Templates - Multi-language skeletons for UT/IT/ST/Perf/Contract

AI-Optimized Format (Token-Efficient)

For AI assistants, use the YAML format files for reduced token usage:

• Base standard: ai/standards/testing.ai.yaml
• Framework options:
  • ISTQB Framework: ai/options/testing/istqb-framework.ai.yaml
  • Industry Pyramid: ai/options/testing/industry-pyramid.ai.yaml
• Test level options:
  • Unit Testing: ai/options/testing/unit-testing.ai.yaml
  • Integration Testing: ai/options/testing/integration-testing.ai.yaml
  • System Testing: ai/options/testing/system-testing.ai.yaml
  • E2E Testing: ai/options/testing/e2e-testing.ai.yaml
  • Security Testing: ai/options/testing/security-testing.ai.yaml
  • Performance Testing: ai/options/testing/performance-testing.ai.yaml
  • Contract Testing: ai/options/testing/contract-testing.ai.yaml
• Skeleton templates (all levels, multi-language): test-skeleton-templates.md

Naming Conventions

File Naming

[ClassName]Tests.cs       # C#
[ClassName].test.ts       # TypeScript
[class_name]_test.py      # Python
[class_name]_test.go      # Go

Method Naming

[MethodName]_[Scenario]_[ExpectedResult]()
should_[behavior]_when_[condition]()
test_[method]_[scenario]_[expected]()

Test Doubles

Type	Purpose	When to Use
Stub	Returns predefined values	Fixed API responses
Mock	Verifies interactions	Check method called
Fake	Simplified implementation	In-memory database
Spy	Records calls, delegates	Partial mocking

When to Use What

• UT: Use mocks/stubs for all external deps
• IT: Use fakes for DB, stubs for external APIs
• ST: Real components, fake only external services
• E2E: Real everything

AAA Pattern

test('method_scenario_expected', () => {
    // Arrange - Setup test data
    const input = createTestInput();
    const sut = new SystemUnderTest();

    // Act - Execute behavior
    const result = sut.execute(input);

    // Assert - Verify result
    expect(result).toBe(expected);
});

FIRST Principles

• Fast - Tests run quickly
• Independent - Tests don't affect each other
• Repeatable - Same result every time
• Self-validating - Clear pass/fail
• Timely - Written with production code

Anti-Patterns to Avoid

• ❌ Test Interdependence (tests must run in order)
• ❌ Flaky Tests (sometimes pass, sometimes fail)
• ❌ Testing Implementation Details
• ❌ Over-Mocking
• ❌ Missing Assertions
• ❌ Magic Numbers/Strings

---

Testing Theory Essentials (YAML Compressed)

# === ISTQB FUNDAMENTALS ===
terminology:
  error: "Human mistake in thinking"
  defect: "Bug in code (caused by error)"
  failure: "System behaves incorrectly (caused by defect)"
  chain: "Error → Defect → Failure"

oracle_problem:
  definition: "How do we know the expected result is correct?"
  approaches:
    - specification_oracle: "Compare against spec"
    - reference_oracle: "Compare against reference impl"
    - consistency_oracle: "Same input → same output"
    - heuristic_oracle: "Reasonable approximation"

# === STATIC vs DYNAMIC ===
static_testing:
  definition: "Examine without executing"
  techniques: [reviews, walkthroughs, inspections, static_analysis]
  finds: "Defects before runtime"
  examples: [ESLint, SonarQube, code_review]

dynamic_testing:
  definition: "Execute and observe behavior"
  techniques: [unit, integration, system, acceptance]
  finds: 



  
     
     
  
     
     
  
     
     
  
     
     


   
   
   
   



   
   
   


   
   
   
   



   [, , , , , ]
   


   
   
   



   
   
   
   


   
   
   
   

---

Configuration Detection

This skill supports project-specific configuration.

Detection Order

1. Check CONTRIBUTING.md for "Disabled Skills" section
   • If this skill is listed, it is disabled for this project
2. Check CONTRIBUTING.md for "Testing Standards" section
3. If not found, default to standard coverage targets

First-Time Setup

If no configuration found and context is unclear:

1. Ask the user: "This project hasn't configured testing standards. Would you like to customize coverage targets?"
2. After user selection, suggest documenting in CONTRIBUTING.md:

## Testing Standards

### Coverage Targets
| Metric | Target |
|--------|--------|
| Line | 80% |
| Branch | 70% |
| Function | 85% |

Configuration Example

In project's CONTRIBUTING.md:

## Testing Standards

### Coverage Targets
| Metric | Target |
|--------|--------|
| Line | 80% |
| Branch | 70% |
| Function | 85% |

### Testing Framework
- Unit Tests: Jest
- Integration Tests: Supertest
- E2E Tests: Playwright

---

Next Steps Guidance | 下一步引導

After /testing completes, the AI assistant should suggest:

測試標準與最佳實踐已掌握。建議下一步 / Testing standards and best practices understood. Suggested next steps:

• 執行 /tdd 開始測試驅動開發（紅-綠-重構循環） ⭐ Recommended / 推薦 — 將測試知識立即轉化為實踐 / Turn testing knowledge into practice immediately
• 執行 /coverage 分析目前程式碼覆蓋率 — 找出測試缺口 / Identify testing gaps
• 執行 /bdd 撰寫行為驅動的 Given-When-Then 場景 — 從使用者角度定義測試 / Define tests from user perspective

---

Related Standards

• Testing Standards - Actionable rules
• Testing Theory - Educational knowledge base
• Code Review Checklist

---

Version History

Version	Date	Changes
1.2.0	2026-04-18	Added: Testing Skills Navigator, testing-theory.md, test-skeleton-templates.md, additional AI YAML options, Next Steps Guidance
1.1.1	2026-01-30	Patch updates
1.1.0	2025-12-29	Added: Testing Theory Essentials YAML section
1.0.0	2025-12-24	Initial: Standard sections (Purpose, Related Standards, Version History, License)

---

License

This skill is released under CC BY 4.0.

Source: universal-dev-standards