메뉴
Use after docs-reviewer has completed compliance review, to perform adversarial/critical review of design or plan documents. Focuses on questioning decisions, finding blind spots, and checking edge cases that compliance review misses.
Codex 또는 Claude로 설치 이 Prompt를 복사해 Codex, Claude 또는 다른 어시스턴트에 붙여 넣으면 Skill 페이지를 검토하고 설치를 진행할 수 있습니다.
SOC 직업 분류 기준
Use when the user submits a new feature request or complex change that needs structured clarification before design. Not for simple bug fixes, config changes, or minor edits that can go directly to implementation.
Use after requirement clarification is complete, to produce a technical design document before any code is written. Not for simple tasks that don't need architecture planning.
Use when technical design is complete and approved, to produce a bite-sized implementation plan with exact file paths, code, and commands.
Use when worker has completed implementation and code needs systematic review before proceeding. Works for both same-model and cross-model review.
Use when a design document or implementation plan has been produced and needs compliance review before adversarial review. Checks coverage, consistency, feasibility against upstream documents.
| name | review-docs-adversarial |
| description | Use after docs-reviewer has completed compliance review, to perform adversarial/critical review of design or plan documents. Focuses on questioning decisions, finding blind spots, and checking edge cases that compliance review misses. |
从"找茬"视角审查设计和计划文档。假设文档有错，然后去找错。
| 维度 | 检查什么 |
|---|---|
| 设计决策质疑 | 为什么选这个方案？被否方案真的不可行？有没有更好的第三种？ |
| 盲区搜索 | 并发？大数据量？服务降级？上下游变更？ |
| 边界条件 | 空值、零值、超大值、并发竞争、幂等性 |
| 隐性假设 | 文档中没说出口的假设是什么？成立吗？ |
| 过度/不足 | 做了不需要的？漏了必须做的？ |
| 计划可行性 | (仅审计划时) 任务粒度？依赖顺序？遗漏的验证步骤？ |
报告保存为独立文件：
docs/feature/YYYY-MM-DD-<feature-slug>/02.5-review-adversarial.mddocs/feature/YYYY-MM-DD-<feature-slug>/03.5-review-adversarial.md格式：复用 review-docs 的 ./review-template.md，标题注明"批判性审查"。
报告开头必须有裁决字段：
Verdict: PASS | PASS_WITH_NOTES | BLOCKED
Critical: N
Important: N
Minor: N
每个问题标注 Critical / Important / Minor。