modularize-chrome-browser

name	modularize-chrome-browser
description	Modularize a chrome/browser/ subfolder by splitting its sources out of the monolithic //chrome/browser:browser target into dedicated source_set targets in the subfolder's own BUILD.gn. Use when the user asks to modularize, extract, or create BUILD targets for a chrome/browser/ subfolder, or mentions "Project Bedrock", "//chrome/browser modularization", or wants to split a subfolder into header/impl/test targets. Also use when the user says "modularize chrome/browser/X" for any X.
allowed-tools	Read

Modularize chrome/browser/ Subfolder

Extract sources for a chrome/browser/<subfolder>/ from the monolithic //chrome/browser:browser target into well-defined source_set targets in the subfolder's own BUILD.gn. Changes must conform to //docs/chrome_browser_design_principles.md.

Goal

The end state is: - chrome/browser/<subfolder>/BUILD.gn defines ::<subfolder> (headers), ::impl (.cc files), ::unit_tests, and ::browser_tests as needed. - chrome/browser/BUILD.gn no longer lists the subfolder's .cc/.h files directly; instead it deps on ::impl. - chrome/test/BUILD.gn no longer lists the subfolder's test files directly; instead it deps on ::unit_tests / ::browser_tests. - Build verification passes.

Important: Do not make any changes unless explicitly instructed by the user. When asked to plan, produce a numbered list of steps only.

Phase 1: Inventory

Check if modularization is actually needed

An existing BUILD.gn in the subfolder does not mean the subfolder is already modularized. Verify by checking whether the files are still listed in chrome/browser/BUILD.gn:

grep -n "<subfolder>/" chrome/browser/BUILD.gn | head -60
grep -n "<subfolder>/" chrome/test/BUILD.gn | head -60

If files appear there, modularization is needed regardless of whether a BUILD.gn already exists.

Determine if the subfolder is platform-specific or hybrid

ls chrome/browser/<subfolder>/

| Subfolder layout | Classification | Action | | ------------------------ | ----------------- | ---------------------------- | | Only an android/ (or | Platform-specific | Skip — nothing to modularize | | : other platform) : : at the root level : | : sub-subfolder, no : : : | : .cc/.h at root : : : | Has .cc/.h files at | Hybrid | Modularize the root | | : root AND a platform : : .cc/.h files; leave the : | : sub-subfolder : : platform subfolder alone : | Has .cc/.h files, no | Standard | Modularize normally | | : platform subfolder : : :

Categorize every file

| Category | Files | | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | | Public headers (.h that form the | → ::<subfolder> target | | : API surface) : : | Implementation (.cc + paired .h) | → ::impl target | | *_unittest.cc | → ::unit_tests target | | *_browsertest.cc or | → ::browser_tests target | | : *_browser_test.cc : : | Fuzzer (*_fuzzer.cc) | → separate fuzzer_test() (leave in | | : : place) :

Also read each header to understand which deps are actually required at the header level vs. only in .cc files.

Phase 2: Choose a target pattern

Pattern A: Two-source-set (header + impl) — preferred for most cases

Use when there are meaningful .h files that consumers depend on independently of the .cc files, or when circular dependencies need to be broken.

source_set("<subfolder>") {
  sources = [
    "foo.h",
    "foo_factory.h",
  ]
  public_deps = [
    # Only deps whose types appear in the public header signatures.
    "//base",
    "//chrome/browser/profiles:profile",
    "//components/keyed_service/core",
  ]
  # Deps used only by .cc files belong in ::impl, not here.
  # Keep public_deps minimal — they are transitive and leak to all consumers.
}

source_set("impl") {
  sources = [
    "foo.cc",
    "foo_factory.cc",
  ]
  public_deps = [ "//chrome/browser:browser_public_dependencies" ]
  deps = [
    ":<subfolder>",
    "//base",
    # Deps only needed in .cc files go here as private deps.
    "//content/public/browser",
  ]
}

Pattern B: Single target with public + sources split

Use for smaller or simpler components where the header/impl split doesn't add meaningful value. Declare public headers explicitly using the public variable:

source_set("<subfolder>") {
  public = [
    "foo.h",
  ]
  sources = [
    "foo.cc",
    "foo_factory.cc",
    "foo_factory.h",  # internal header, not part of public API
  ]
  public_deps = [
    "//base",
  ]
  deps = [
    "//content/public/browser",
  ]
}

Choosing between patterns

• Prefer Pattern A when the component has a significant public API surface or when there are downstream circular-dependency constraints.
• Prefer Pattern B for simple, self-contained components with few consumers.
• In either case, keep public_deps to the strict minimum — they are transitive and increase the risk of circular dependencies for all downstream consumers. Move implementation-only deps to private deps.

Phase 3: Write the new BUILD.gn

# Copyright 20XX The Chromium Authors
# Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
# found in the LICENSE file.

# (import any needed buildflags, e.g.)
# import("//extensions/buildflags/buildflags.gni")

source_set("<subfolder>") {
  # ... (Pattern A or B from above)
}

source_set("impl") {
  # ... (Pattern A only)
}

source_set("unit_tests") {
  testonly = true
  sources = [ "foo_unittest.cc" ]
  deps = [
    ":<subfolder>",
    ":impl",
    "//base/test:test_support",
    "//chrome/test:test_support",
    "//testing/gtest",
  ]
}

source_set("browser_tests") {
  testonly = true
  defines = [ "HAS_OUT_OF_PROC_TEST_RUNNER" ]
  sources = [ "foo_browsertest.cc" ]
  deps = [
    ":<subfolder>",
    ":impl",
    "//base/test:test_support",
    "//chrome/test:test_support",
    "//content/test:test_support",
    "//testing/gtest",
  ]
}

Key rules: - Omit targets that have no files (e.g., skip ::browser_tests if there are no browser test files). - ::browser_tests always sets defines = ["HAS_OUT_OF_PROC_TEST_RUNNER"]. - Preserve all platform-specific if (is_android), if (is_chromeos), if (enable_extensions) guards exactly as they appear in the original chrome/browser/BUILD.gn. - Factory .h files belong in the interface/public target even when the .cc is in ::impl.

Platform-agnostic interface design

If a class uses an interface pattern (e.g., a delegate or checker injected via constructor), do not add BUILDFLAG(IS_ANDROID) build guards around the code just to skip it on desktop. Instead, pass nullptr on platforms that don't have an implementation and add a null-check in the method body. This keeps the code testable on all platforms and avoids ifdef fragmentation.

// Good: platform-agnostic, null-safe
bool Foo::IsInteractable() {
  if (!interactability_checker_) return true;
  return interactability_checker_->Check();
}

Phase 4: Update parent BUILD files

chrome/browser/BUILD.gn

1. Remove each .h and .cc file from the monolithic sources list.
2. Add a dep on the new impl target: gn "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>:impl", (For Pattern B, dep on "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>" instead.)
3. If there was already a dep on "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>", keep or replace it with :impl as appropriate.

chrome/test/BUILD.gn

Remove *_unittest.cc files from chrome_unit_tests sources and add: gn "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>:unit_tests",

Remove *_browsertest.cc files from browser test sources and add: gn "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>:browser_tests",

Phase 5: Fix GN include errors

Run build verification first (Phase 6), then resolve any errors.

Error type 1: "Include not allowed" — header not reachable at all

Add an explicit dep to the failing target: gn deps += [ "//chrome/browser/<subfolder>" ]

Or, if //chrome/browser:browser already depends on ::impl and the cycle is intentional, use allow_circular_includes_from on ::impl: gn allow_circular_includes_from = [ "//chrome/browser:browser_public_dependencies" ]

Error type 2: "Can't include this header from here" — reachable only via private dep

Add the dep directly to the failing target, or promote it to public_deps on the target that owns the header.

allow_circular_includes_from rules

• Set it on the target that owns the headers you want to expose through the cycle.
• The dep cycle must already exist in the dep graph.
• It only covers headers in that target's own sources, not headers from its transitive deps.
• Standard pattern: ::impl sets allow_circular_includes_from = ["//chrome/browser:browser_public_dependencies"].

Phase 6: Format, verify, and commit

Format

Always run after every edit: bash git cl format

Verify the build

# Desktop Linux (primary — always run this):
python3 tools/mb/mb.py gen -m tryserver.chromium.linux -b linux-rel \
  --config-file tools/mb/mb_config.pyl out/Default

# Android arm64 (run if the subfolder has Android-specific code):
python3 tools/mb/mb.py gen -m tryserver.chromium.android -b android-arm64-rel \
  --config-file tools/mb/mb_config.pyl out/Default

Fix any include errors and re-run until clean.

Commit

Wrap the commit message at 72 characters:

Modularize chrome/browser/<subfolder>/BUILD.gn targets

The monolithic `chrome/browser` target leads to long compilation
times and potential circular dependencies. This change extracts
the C++ and header files from `chrome/browser/<subfolder>/` into
dedicated `source_set` targets:

- `:<subfolder>` — header-only interface target
- `:impl` — implementation (.cc files)
- `:unit_tests` — unit tests (moved from chrome/test:unit_tests)
- `:browser_tests` — browser tests (moved from
  chrome/test:browser_tests)

Platform-specific conditions and dependencies were preserved
identically to the original `chrome/browser` configuration.
Missing dependencies implicit to the monolithic target were
explicitly declared.

Bug: <bug-id>

Common pitfalls

• Existing BUILD.gn ≠ modularized: Always grep chrome/browser/BUILD.gn to confirm files have actually been moved out.

• Over-broad public_deps: Every entry in public_deps is transitive — all downstream consumers pull it in. Audit each one; if a type is only used in .cc files, move it to private deps.

• Missing allow_circular_includes_from: If a .h in ::impl is still

• Missing platform guards: Copy if (is_android), if (is_chromeos), if (enable_extensions) verbatim from the original.

• Unnecessary BUILDFLAG guards: If a class uses a platform-specific delegate, prefer passing nullptr on other platforms and null-checking at runtime instead of build-guarding the whole file.

• scoped_mock_* headers: Keep in the interface target if used by tests outside the folder; move .cc to ::impl or a test-only target.

• Forgetting git cl format: Always format after changes before verifying or committing.