Complete plan execution with git workflow and PR management
npx skills add https://github.com/cuioss/plan-marshall --skill phase-6-finalize이 명령을 Claude Code에 복사하여 붙여넣어 스킬을 설치하세요
| name | phase-6-finalize |
| description | Complete plan execution with git workflow and PR management |
| user-invocable | false |
Role: Finalize phase skill. Handles shipping workflow (commit, push, PR) and plan completion. Verification tasks have already been executed within phase-5-execute.
Key Pattern: Shipping-focused execution. No verification steps—all quality checks run as verification tasks within phase-5-execute before reaching this phase.
Required steps declaration: This skill opts in to the phase_steps_complete handshake invariant. The canonical list of steps that MUST be marked done on status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"] before the phase transitions is maintained in standards/required-steps.md. Each built-in step's standards document terminates with a manage-status mark-step-done call whose --step value matches an entry in that file.
Shared lifecycle patterns: See phase-lifecycle.md for entry protocol, completion protocol, and error handling convention.
Execution mode: Follow workflow steps sequentially, respecting config gates. Each config-gated step dispatches to a standards/ document.
Required skill load (before any operation):
Skill: plan-marshall:dev-agent-behavior-rules
Skill: plan-marshall:workflow-integration-git
Skill: plan-marshall:tools-integration-ci
Prohibited actions:
.plan/ files directly — all access must go through python3 .plan/execute-script.py manage-* scriptsmanifest.phase_6.steps. The manifest is the single authority — there is no fallback to a default step set, no inference from marshal.json config booleans, no per-step skip logic.manage-status transition, never set status directlydone from a previous invocation). Standards documents handle their own runtime state decisions inside their dispatched bodies.git Bash call without git -C {worktree_path} (pre-worktree-removal) or git -C {main_checkout} (post-worktree-removal). No cd chaining, no implicit cwd. {worktree_path} and {main_checkout} MUST be resolved by the Step 0 entry step before any standards document runs.ci, pyproject_build, sonar, workflow-integration-*) without an explicit routing flag. Forward --plan-id {plan_id} (preferred — auto-resolves the worktree via manage-status get-worktree-path) or --project-dir {worktree_path} / --project-dir {main_checkout} (escape hatch / explicit override after worktree removal). The two flags are mutually exclusive. The executor is cwd-pass-through; routing must be explicit at every call site.Constraints:
manage-* script callsEvery manage-* script call in this document carries the following exit-code contract unless a step explicitly states otherwise:
exit_code == 0: parse the returned TOON and use the value as the step describes.exit_code != 0: STOP and return an error TOON to the orchestrator carrying the script's stderr verbatim. Non-zero exits include argparse_rejection (exit 2) — silent swallowing of wrong_parameters rejections is the prohibited anti-pattern; "log and continue" is equally forbidden.Step-level exceptions — calls whose non-zero exit is itself the signal (e.g., manage-files exists returning exists: false, manage-status get-worktree-path returning an empty worktree_path) — are documented inline in the step that issues them.
Activate when:
6-finalize phaseSee references/workflow-overview.md for the visual phase flow diagram.
Iteration limit: 3 cycles max for PR issue resolution.
| Parameter | Type | Required | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
plan_id | string | Yes | Plan identifier |
session_id | string | Yes | Current host-platform session id — forwarded to default:record-metrics for manage-metrics enrich, which reads the matching transcript JSONL to capture main-context token usage. Without it, enrich cannot locate the transcript and session tokens are lost from the final report. |
session_id: the platform-runtime session capture operation stores the session id in the plan's status.json at plan-init time. Read it back via:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status metadata \
--plan-id {plan_id} --get --field session_id
Parse value from the TOON output. On status: error or empty value, the orchestrator's session_id resolver (in plan-marshall/workflow/execution.md) does NOT abort immediately — it first attempts exactly one platform-runtime session capture --plan-id {plan_id} retry and re-reads the metadata field. An absent session_id at finalize entry is therefore recoverable as long as the platform session is still live. Only when that single late capture also fails (status: error or value still empty) does the resolver abort finalize with a clear message — do not invent a filler value.
transcript_path: when a step needs the absolute path of the session transcript JSONL, the path follows the pattern ~/.claude/projects/{cwd-slug}/{session_id}.jsonl where {cwd-slug} is the absolute project cwd with each / replaced by -. The manage-metrics enrich command resolves this internally given the session_id. On transcript_not_found, degrade gracefully (skip enrich).
The Phase Entry Protocol's phase_handshake verify --phase 5-execute --strict call (see ref-workflow-architecture/standards/phase-lifecycle.md) asserts the worktree-resolution contract before any phase-6-finalize work begins: when metadata.use_worktree==true, metadata.worktree_path MUST be non-empty AND filesystem-resolvable (the directory exists AND git -C {path} rev-parse --show-toplevel returns the same canonical path). When the assertion fails, the script returns status: error, error: worktree_unresolved and (under --strict) exits 1 — phase entry refuses to advance until the persisted metadata is repaired. Plans with metadata.use_worktree==false skip the assertion (main-checkout flow). The assertion is particularly load-bearing here: phase-6-finalize's branch-cleanup step removes the worktree, so a stale worktree_path at entry would point at a directory cleanup is about to delete or has already deleted on a re-entry. The assertion fires uniformly at every phase boundary; see deliverable 8 in the originating lesson plan for the full contract.
The phase-6-finalize step list lives in the per-plan execution manifest, not in marshal.json. The manifest is composed at outline time by plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:compose and is the single source of truth for which steps fire on this plan.
Manifest (read in Step 2):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:manage-execution-manifest \
read --plan-id {plan_id}
| Field | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
phase_6.steps | list | Ordered list of bare step IDs to execute (e.g., commit-push, create-pr, …). Authoritative. |
Cross-phase config from marshal.json (read in Step 2 alongside the manifest):
| Field | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
phase-6-finalize.review_bot_buffer_seconds | integer | Max seconds to wait after CI for new review-bot comments (used as --timeout for pr wait-for-comments; ceiling, not fixed delay; default: 180) |
phase-6-finalize.max_iterations | integer | Maximum finalize-verify loops (default: 3) |
phase-6-finalize.loop_back_without_asking | bool | Symmetric counterpart to phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking. When true, a loop_back outcome from any phase-6-finalize step (FIX disposition, pr-comment-overflow, sonar-roundtrip FIX) auto-dispatches the execute pipeline inline and re-enters the finalize loop, capped by max_iterations. When false (default), the dispatcher halts and returns control to the user. See Step 3 § "Loop-back continuation" for the dispatch shape. |
phase-5-execute.commit_strategy | string | per_deliverable / per_plan / none |
phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking | bool | Forward-direction auto-continuation: when true, after 5-execute → 6-finalize transition the orchestrator dispatches phase-6-finalize inline rather than halting and prompting the user. The reverse-direction symmetric counterpart is phase-6-finalize.loop_back_without_asking. |
phase-1-init.branch_strategy | string | feature / direct |
A step is active if and only if it appears in manifest.phase_6.steps. Absent steps are NEVER executed. The order of steps in the manifest list is the execution order. The plan.phase-6-finalize.steps field in marshal.json is the candidate set — the input list phase-4-plan Step 8b passes to manage-execution-manifest compose --phase-6-steps. The manifest's phase_6.steps is the resolved per-plan instance of that candidate set and is the only authority this skill consults at dispatch time. The candidate set drives dispatch transitively; this skill itself never reads marshal.json for step selection.
Of the 15 default + project finalize steps, 6 dispatch and 9 run inline. Every dispatched step resolves under the phase-scoped registry — manage-config effort resolve-target --phase phase-6-finalize [--role <subkey>]. Step → resolved role: pre-submission-self-review → phase-6-finalize (no --role; tracks phase-6-finalize.default); create-pr → phase-6-finalize (no --role); lessons-capture → phase-6-finalize --role post-run-review; automated-review + sonar-roundtrip → phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (producer=pr-comment / sonar runtime input); architecture-refresh is hybrid (Tier 0 inline scripts; Tier 1 fans out under phase-6-finalize per affected module — the only per-iteration parallel dispatch in the contract); project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor (meta-project only) → phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (producer=plugin-doctor runtime input). Two opt-in dispatched steps exist outside the default set: retrospective → phase-6-finalize --role post-run-review (8 LLM aspects iterate inside one envelope); /workflow-pr-doctor (slash-command surface) → phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (producer=pr-state runtime input). The 9 inline steps (commit-push, branch-cleanup, pre-push-quality-gate, record-metrics, archive-plan, finalize-step-print-phase-breakdown, architecture-refresh Tier 0, project:finalize-step-deploy-target, project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache) are pure scripts or trivial orchestration that earn no envelope. CI completion is no longer a sibling step in this roster — it is a dispatcher-resolved precondition (requires: [ci-complete]) checked inline before any consumer step runs; see Step 3 § "Precondition resolution" below. For the rationale see dispatch-granularity.md § 5 (find the LLM core, not the wrapping step).
Three step types are supported, distinguished by prefix notation:
| Type | Notation | Resolution |
|---|---|---|
| built-in | default: prefix (e.g., default:commit-push) | Strip prefix, read standards/{name}.md and follow all steps |
| project (dispatched) | project: prefix classified DISPATCHED (e.g., project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor) | Task: execution-context-{level} with workflow: {step's own SKILL.md notation} — see Step 3 item 5 DISPATCHED branch |
| project (inline) | project: prefix classified INLINE (e.g., project:finalize-step-deploy-target) | Skill: {notation} with interface contract parameters |
| skill | fully-qualified bundle:skill (e.g., pm-dev-java:java-post-pr) | DISPATCHED → Task: execution-context-{level}; INLINE → Skill: {notation} with interface contract parameters, per the same classification |
Type detection logic:
default: -> built-in type (strip prefix, validate against dispatch table)project: -> project type; further classified DISPATCHED vs INLINE per the "Dispatched workflows vs inline steps" section: (other) -> fully-qualified skill type; classified DISPATCHED vs INLINE the same wayThe dispatched-vs-inline classification (which project/skill steps dispatch under Task: execution-context-{level} vs load inline via Skill:) is owned by the "Dispatched workflows vs inline steps" section above — it is the single source of truth, and the "Interface Contract for External Steps" section's Skill: template applies only to INLINE external steps.
Each step declares an order: <int> value in its authoritative source — frontmatter on built-in standards docs (standards/{name}.md), frontmatter on project-local SKILL.md for project: steps, and the return-dict order field for extension-contributed skills. marshall-steward sorts the steps list by this value when writing it to marshal.json. This skill iterates the list as written and does NOT re-sort or validate order at runtime — the persisted order is the runtime order.
| Step Name | Standards Document | Description |
|---|---|---|
default:pre-submission-self-review | workflow/pre-submission-self-review.md | Pre-submission structural self-review (symmetric pairs, regex, wording, duplication, contract drift) |
default:finalize-step-simplify | standards/finalize-step-simplify.md | Holistic post-implementation simplification sweep — collapse accidental complexity introduced across the plan's diff (dispatches under --phase phase-6-finalize, no --role) |
default:commit-push | standards/commit-push.md | Commit and push changes |
default:create-pr | standards/create-pr.md | Create pull request |
default:ci-verify | workflow/ci-verify.md | Classify CI run failures into the multi-failure-mode taxonomy and emit one structured triage finding per failing check (requires: [ci-complete] in consume-failures mode) |
default:architecture-refresh | standards/architecture-refresh.md | Refresh architecture descriptors (tier-0 deterministic discover + diff, tier-1 LLM re-enrichment) |
default:automated-review | standards/automated-review.md | CI automated review — orchestration prose; the per-finding LLM core dispatches workflow/triage.md with finding_type=pr-comment (see findings-pipeline.md for the architectural flow) |
default:sonar-roundtrip | standards/sonar-roundtrip.md | Sonar analysis roundtrip — orchestration prose; the per-finding LLM core dispatches workflow/triage.md with finding_type=sonar-issue |
default:lessons-capture | standards/lessons-capture.md | Record lessons learned |
default:branch-cleanup | standards/branch-cleanup.md | Branch cleanup — adapts to PR mode or local-only based on create-pr step presence |
default:record-metrics | standards/record-metrics.md | Record final plan metrics before archive |
default:finalize-step-print-phase-breakdown | standards/finalize-step-print-phase-breakdown.md | Optional override mode: capture the Phase Breakdown table from metrics.md so the renderer emits it in place of the per-step [OK] block |
default:archive-plan | standards/archive-plan.md | Archive the completed plan |
External steps split by the dispatched-vs-inline classification in the "Dispatched workflows vs inline steps" section.
INLINE external steps (e.g., project:finalize-step-deploy-target,
project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache) load in the main context and receive
these parameters:
Skill: {step_reference}
Arguments: --plan-id {plan_id} --iteration {iteration} [--session-id {session_id}]
DISPATCHED external steps (e.g., project:finalize-step-pre-submission-self-review,
project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor) do NOT use the Skill: template above —
they dispatch under Task: execution-context-{level} with the step's own SKILL.md
as the workflow prompt-body field. Their input contract is the 5-field
prompt-body shape (name, plan_id, skills[], workflow, WORKTREE) plus any
workflow-specific runtime inputs (--iteration, producer, whitelisted
--session-id). See Step 3 item 5 § "DISPATCHED project/skill step" for the
dispatch shape.
In both cases the step body can access the plan's context via manage-* scripts (references, status, config).
--session-id {session_id} is forwarded ONLY to external steps on the per-step opt-in whitelist below. The forwarding is opt-in (rather than universal) because some external steps may reject unknown flags; opting in keeps the contract additive for new dependencies without breaking existing steps.
| Whitelisted external step | Why it needs --session-id |
|---|---|
plan-marshall:plan-retrospective | Aspect 12 (chat-history-analysis) is conditional on --session-id. Without it, the aspect is silently skipped and the retrospective report omits the chat-history section. See plan-retrospective/SKILL.md → "Input Contract" for the consumer-side declaration. |
default:record-metrics is intentionally NOT on this whitelist: it is a built-in step, dispatched via standards/record-metrics.md, which already consumes --session-id inline. The whitelist scope is project- and skill-type external steps only.
How to apply — when defining a new external step that consumes session-scoped state:
--session-id as an input in the step's authoritative document (project step SKILL.md or fully-qualified skill SKILL.md/standards).The orchestrator is responsible for resolving session_id (see "How to obtain session_id" earlier in this file). This skill receives the resolved value via its Input Parameters and forwards it verbatim to whitelisted steps; it does not re-resolve.
Required termination: Every external step (project and fully-qualified skill) MUST terminate with a manage-status mark-step-done call that carries --display-detail "{one-line summary}". This is REQUIRED, not optional — a missing or empty display_detail causes renderer failure in Step 4 (the literal placeholder <missing display_detail> will surface to the user and contribute to a [FAILED] headline). The detail string is authored by the step itself; the renderer NEVER invents content on the step's behalf.
The full command template (use verbatim, substituting the placeholders):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status mark-step-done \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize --step {step_name} --outcome {done|skipped|failed} \
--display-detail "{one-line summary}"
MANDATORY annotations for every argument:
--phase — MANDATORY. Always the literal string 6-finalize for steps dispatched under this operation. This anchors the step record to the finalize phase; any other value routes the record into the wrong phase bucket and breaks the Step 4 renderer grouping.--outcome — MANDATORY. Must be exactly one of done, skipped, or failed. Any other value (including misspellings or capitalized variants) is rejected by manage-status. The choice determines the headline classification and CANNOT be inferred from display_detail alone.--step — MANDATORY. Must match the fully-qualified step name as listed in marshal.json (e.g. default:commit-push, project:foo, or plan-marshall:some-skill:some-script). Mismatches here create orphan status records that the renderer cannot pair with the dispatched step.--display-detail — MANDATORY. Single-line summary of what the step actually did, authored by the step itself. Subject to the constraints listed below. A missing, empty, or whitespace-only value triggers the <missing display_detail> placeholder and contributes a [FAILED] headline regardless of the --outcome value.Notation: the canonical 3-part notation is plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status — every segment is kebab-case.
display_detail constraints:
See standards/output-template.md for the full detail-string convention, ASCII icon rules, and concrete examples per built-in step.
Input: plan_id
This step runs before any other finalize step and makes {worktree_path} and {main_checkout} available to every subsequent step and standards document. All git Bash calls and all build/CI/sonar/github/gitlab script invocations in the finalize workflow depend on these two values — no standards document may resolve them independently.
Read the plan status and extract the worktree path from metadata:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status read \
--plan-id {plan_id}
Extract metadata.worktree_path:
{worktree_path}. The main checkout is the parent of .plan/local/worktrees/{plan_id}/ — derive {main_checkout} by stripping the trailing /.plan/local/worktrees/{plan_id} segment from {worktree_path}, or resolve it explicitly:git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse --path-format=absolute --git-common-dir
The git-common-dir output ends with /.git inside the main checkout — {main_checkout} is its parent directory.
use_worktree == false): there is no worktree. Set {worktree_path} equal to {main_checkout}, where {main_checkout} is the repository root resolved via:git rev-parse --show-toplevel
Log the resolved paths so they remain visible in model context for every subsequent Edit/Write/Read/Bash call:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Finalize cwd context: worktree_path={worktree_path} main_checkout={main_checkout} — all git calls MUST use 'git -C' with one of these paths, all Bucket B script calls MUST pass '--plan-id {plan_id}' or '--project-dir <path>' (mutually exclusive)"
From this point on, every standards document loaded by the finalize pipeline inherits {worktree_path} and {main_checkout} from this step. Standards documents MUST NOT re-resolve these values.
Per ADR-002, the orchestrator enters finalize still cwd-pinned to the worktree (the pin established at phase-5 entry by prepare_execute.py — see plan-marshall/workflow/execution.md § "Orchestrator cwd-pinning (phase-5+)"). The finalize phase ends that pin, but the move-back and the worktree removal are SEQUENCED, not simultaneous:
Move-back while the worktree is still present. The atomic move-back script (deliverable 5) folds the plan's own global logs into the plan directory, moves the plan directory back to main, and runs under the merge lock — all while the worktree still exists:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:workflow-integration-git:integrate_into_main integrate \
--plan-id {plan_id}
integrate_into_main.py resolves its SOURCE (the worktree-resident plan dir, via manage-status get-worktree-path) and its DESTINATION (main's plan dir, via the sanctioned main-anchored resolver) cwd-independently, so it is correct whether invoked before or after the cwd return — it does NOT require any particular working directory. It also does NOT change the caller's working directory, does NOT remove the worktree, and does NOT regenerate the executor. On-main executor regeneration is performed later by the project-level project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache step (meta-project-only) after the cache sync — the executor stays a per-tree derived artifact (ADR-002), never file-moved onto main.
Return cwd to main. After the move-back returns, the orchestrator returns its own working directory to {main_checkout}. The plan directory and executor now live on main again, so the uniform cwd rule resolves them on main from this point. Because integrate_into_main is cwd-independent, the cwd return is not a precondition of the move-back — the only hard ordering constraint is the worktree-removal sequencing in step 3.
Resume the remaining finalize steps, then remove the worktree. With cwd back on main, the orchestrator resumes the remaining finalize pipeline; the worktree is removed last, by the branch-cleanup step. Removing the worktree before the move-back completes would strand the authoritative plan-state copy, so the move-back MUST precede worktree removal. That sequencing — move-back → resume → worktree removal — is the load-bearing constraint; the cwd return is independent of it.
The worktree-lifecycle and dispatch contract is the central standard at marketplace/bundles/plan-marshall/skills/workflow-integration-git/standards/worktree-handling.md; this section documents only the finalize-side return-to-main ordering and does not re-inline that contract.
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Starting finalize phase"
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize --resolution pending
If unresolved findings exist from a previous iteration (filtered_count > 0):
For each pending finding:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate resolve --plan-id {plan_id} --hash-id {hash_id} --resolution fixed --phase 6-finalize \
--detail "{fix task reference or description}"
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
decision --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "(plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize:qgate) Finding {hash_id} [qgate]: fixed — {resolution_detail}"
The phase-6-finalize step list is read from the per-plan execution manifest (execution.toon), not from marshal.json. The manifest is composed at outline time by plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:compose and is the single source of truth for which Phase 6 steps fire for this plan. This skill reads the manifest verbatim and dispatches — it carries NO per-step skip logic of its own.
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:manage-execution-manifest \
read --plan-id {plan_id}
Extract phase_6.steps — the ordered list of step IDs (e.g., commit-push, create-pr, automated-review, …) to execute. Step IDs in the manifest are bare names (no default: prefix). The dispatcher in Step 3 prepends default: when looking up built-in steps, but otherwise iterates the list verbatim.
If the manifest is missing (status: error, error: file_not_found): abort finalize with an explicit error — the manifest is REQUIRED. Re-run plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:compose from outline phase to repair.
After reading phase_6.steps from the manifest but BEFORE dispatching any step in Step 3, walk the list once and verify each step's standards file is loadable. This is the manifest fail-fast guard: it converts a confusing mid-dispatch failure (a built-in step pointing at a deleted standards file) into an immediate, actionable error at phase entry.
For each step_id in manifest.phase_6.steps:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:manage-execution-manifest \
validate-loadable --plan-id {plan_id} --step-id {step_id}
The script returns a structured TOON payload of the form {status, step_id, standards_path, loadable, message?}. Aggregate the per-step results across the loop. The caller MAY use the bulk form --all instead to validate every step in manifest.phase_6.steps in one invocation:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-execution-manifest:manage-execution-manifest \
validate-loadable --plan-id {plan_id} --all
The bulk form returns {status, results[N]{step_id, standards_path, loadable, message?}, unloadable_count} and is the preferred shape when validating a non-trivial step list.
On any unloadable step (loadable: false for at least one entry): abort finalize with the canonical actionable message. Log the error and return a status: error payload — do NOT enter Step 3:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level ERROR --message "[ERROR] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Manifest loadability check failed — step `{step_id}` referenced by `marshal.json` is missing standards file `{standards_path}` — the plan likely deleted the file without sweeping `marshal.json`"
The actionable message is fixed by standards/required-steps.md § "Loadability Contract" — the wording above is the canonical phrasing the contract guarantees. Self-modifying plans that delete a phase-6-finalize/standards/{name}.md without also pruning marshal.json::plan.phase-6-finalize.steps are the motivating failure mode.
Scope: the loadability check applies to built-in steps only (bare names that resolve to marketplace/bundles/plan-marshall/skills/phase-6-finalize/standards/{name}.md). External steps (project: / bundle:skill) are not validated here — their loadability is the responsibility of the host plugin cache, and a missing project/skill step surfaces as a Skill: {ref} resolution error during dispatch, not as a missing standards file. The validate-loadable subcommand returns loadable: true with no further check for external step IDs so the bulk-form caller does not have to filter.
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
plan phase-6-finalize get --audit-plan-id {plan_id}
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
plan phase-5-execute get --audit-plan-id {plan_id}
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
plan phase-1-init get --audit-plan-id {plan_id}
Read the config blocks for review_bot_buffer_seconds, max_iterations, commit_strategy, and branch_strategy. Do not read the steps field from marshal.json here — that field is the candidate set consumed by phase-4-plan Step 8b, not by this skill. The manifest's phase_6.steps list is the only valid source for runtime dispatch.
Also read references context for branch and issue information:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-references:manage-references get-context \
--plan-id {plan_id}
After reading configuration, log the finalize strategy decision:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
decision --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "(plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Finalize strategy: commit={commit_strategy}, manifest_steps={steps_count}, branch={branch_strategy}"
Iterate over manifest.phase_6.steps (read in Step 2). The list is the manifest's authoritative ordering — neither this skill nor any standards document re-orders, filters, or skip-conditional any step.
In meta-projects that own marketplace bundles (notably the
plan-marshall repo itself), the project-local Phase 6 ordering pairs
project:finalize-step-deploy-target (order 80) with
project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache (order 85), placing both
after default:branch-cleanup, against the main checkout
post-merge. The cache mirrors the target/claude/ content from the
merged source tree, so the next session-boot re-derivation reads the
same authoritative tree the dispatcher just wrote to. On-main executor
regeneration is performed by the project-level
project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache step (order 85) immediately
after the cache sync, in both worktree and no-worktree finalize flows;
integrate_into_main performs the move-back only and does NOT regenerate
the executor.
Meta-project finalize agents dispatched between create-pr and
branch-cleanup see pre-plan skill bodies in the host cache (the cache
sync now runs later, post-merge). This is acceptable — see the
what_this_gives_up analysis in the originating lesson for the
deliberate-trade-off rationale: tool calls resolve against worktree
absolute paths and the executor reads notation paths fresh per
subprocess, so only Skill: dispatches consume the in-process
registry, and the meta-project case is explicitly accepted.
Consumer projects do not own bundle sources, so they do not register either step. Their finalize dispatches load whatever the host plugin cache holds, which is exactly the published bundle definitions.
Resumable re-entry semantics: Before dispatching each step, read the current step record from status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"]. If the step is already marked done, skip dispatch entirely (no re-run, no log noise — the previous run completed it). If the step is marked failed, retry it from scratch. If the step has no record (or any other outcome), dispatch it as a fresh run. This makes finalize safe to re-enter after a partial run, a crash, or an explicit retry — completed steps stay completed, failed steps get exactly one retry per invocation.
Precondition resolution: before dispatching any step in the FOR loop, parse the step's frontmatter requires: list (if present) and resolve each entry against its mapped resolver. The only precondition currently defined is ci-complete, mapped to the dispatcher-internal helper scripts/ci_complete_precondition.py (notation plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize:ci_complete_precondition). The resolver is invoked inline through the executor proxy (no Task agent dispatch — the helper itself is bounded by ci wait --timeout 600, matching the host platform's per-call ceiling).
The resolver accepts a --mode flag (strict | consume-failures) selecting how wait_failed is mapped to the consumer step's outcome. The dispatcher MUST pass --mode per consumer step using the table below — the value depends on which consumer the precondition is being resolved for, NOT on the resolver itself:
| Consumer step | --mode value | Why |
|---|---|---|
default:ci-verify | consume-failures | The step's whole purpose is to classify CI failures into the multi-failure-mode taxonomy and emit one structured finding per failing check. strict would skip the body on wait_failed and make the classify → file-findings → verification-feedback → loop_back machinery unreachable on red CI. |
default:automated-review | strict (default) | A red CI invalidates the PR-review snapshot the reviewer would consume; short-circuit to failed and let the operator address the CI failure first. |
default:sonar-roundtrip | strict (default) | A red CI means Sonar's analysis has not yet completed against the latest tree; short-circuit and let CI recover first. |
| Future consumers | Default to strict unless the consumer's body explicitly handles wait_failed envelopes. Add a row above when a new consumer joins the consume-failures set. |
The dispatcher resolves the value by mapping the consumer step id (step.name from frontmatter) to the table above. When a step declares requires: [ci-complete] but does not appear in the table, the default is strict.
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize:ci_complete_precondition \
resolve --plan-id {plan_id} --worktree-path {worktree_path} --pr-number {pr_number} \
--mode {strict|consume-failures} [--timeout 600]
The helper returns a TOON envelope with status, head_sha, ci_final_status, and (on wait_failed) failing_checks, wait_outcome, and mode (the value passed in). The underlying ci wait envelope partitions GitHub check conclusions per the canonical table (success | skipped | neutral → non-failing; failure | timed_out | cancelled | action_required | stale → failing; null | in_progress | queued → wait); the previous mixed outcome is no longer returned by any github_ops function. Outcome mapping:
Resolver status | ci_final_status | --mode | Dispatcher action |
|---|---|---|---|
satisfied | success | any | Cache hit — proceed to dispatch the consumer step normally. |
wait_succeeded | success | any | Cache miss → fresh ci wait returned success — proceed to dispatch. |
wait_failed | failure | strict | CI ran to completion and at least one check is in the failing partition. SKIP the consumer step's body and mark the step's outcome failed via manage-status mark-step-done … --outcome failed --display-detail "ci_failure (precondition): {failing_check_names}". The failing_checks[] list is forwarded into the display_detail so the work-log line names the specific checks that drove the verdict rather than the opaque "mixed" phrasing the pre-fix code emitted. |
wait_failed | timeout | strict | ci wait exhausted its --timeout budget; wait_outcome: deadline_exceeded and failing_checks[] enumerates the still-running checks at the deadline. Same skip-and-mark action as failure; downstream consumers route this to ci-verify-timeout. |
wait_failed | no_checks | strict | CI never produced any checks (final_status: none from ci wait). Distinct from real failure so the dispatcher can surface "no CI configured for this branch" rather than "CI ran red". Same skip-and-mark action; downstream consumers route this to ci-verify-missing. |
wait_failed | failure | timeout | no_checks | consume-failures | Do NOT skip the consumer body. Thread failing_checks[], wait_outcome, and ci_final_status into the consumer step's runtime inputs and dispatch the body normally; the consumer (currently only default:ci-verify) is responsible for classifying the failures into structured findings. The structured-finding emission below STILL fires so the precondition decision remains audit-traceable; the difference vs strict is purely "skip body" → "run body with envelope". |
Structured finding emission on wait_failed: in addition to the mark-step-done … --outcome failed --display-detail "ci_failure (precondition): {failing_check_names}" call above, the dispatcher MUST also persist a structured triage finding so the precondition decision survives outside the work-log. Emit exactly one finding per wait_failed resolution (NOT one per failing check — the failing-check enumeration lives in the message body). Invoke immediately after the mark-step-done … --outcome failed call:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings add \
--plan-id {plan_id} --type triage --severity warning \
--title "CI failure (precondition) at HEAD {head_sha}" \
--component "plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize" \
--detail "ci_failure (precondition) at HEAD {head_sha}: failing=[{comma-joined failing check names}] / reason={failure|timeout|no_checks}" \
--file-path "marketplace/bundles/plan-marshall/skills/workflow-integration-{github|gitlab}/scripts/{github|gitlab}_ops.py"
Field-by-field:
--type triage — the precondition decision is a triage event (the operator decides between retry / suppress / accept / taken_into_account between finalize boundaries). Re-using the existing triage finding-type keeps the 12-type taxonomy stable; no new type is introduced.--title "..." — a one-line summary anchored to the failing HEAD; add requires it. Substitute {head_sha} from the resolver's return envelope.--severity warning — a CI failure that blocks the dispatcher is not itself a code defect; the underlying failing checks are the defect. warning matches the [WARNING] work-log convention this finding complements.--component "plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize" — the precondition resolver belongs to phase-6-finalize even though it consults workflow-integration-{github,gitlab}.--detail "..." — substitute {head_sha} from the resolver's return envelope, {comma-joined failing check names} from failing_checks[].name (use the empty string when failing_checks is empty; this occurs, for example, when ci_final_status is no_checks), and {failure|timeout|no_checks} from the ci_final_status value. The detail body carries enough context for manage-findings list --type triage to reproduce the verdict without re-fetching CI.--file-path — resolve to the provider script that produced the verdict: github_ops.py when the active CI integration is GitHub, gitlab_ops.py when GitLab. The dispatcher already knows the active provider via the tools-integration-ci abstraction.The finding is NOT added to plan.phase-6-finalize.blocking_finding_types. The ci_failure precondition already blocks the consumer step (the step records failed outcome and the dispatcher honours failed_outcome_strategy); adding it to the blocking list would double-block the phase transition and prevent the operator from explicitly resolving the finding as accepted between runs. The finding surfaces in retrospectives via manage-findings list --type triage; existing blocking infrastructure does not need to know about it.
This step fires ONLY on wait_failed. satisfied and wait_succeeded resolutions emit no finding (CI passed — nothing to triage).
Cache lifecycle: The helper persists successful outcomes to .plan/local/plans/{plan_id}/work/ci-precondition-cache.toon, keyed by the current git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse HEAD SHA. The cache is alive for one dispatcher iteration; a loop-back commit that advances HEAD invalidates the entry implicitly (the next resolve sees a fresh SHA, the stored SHA no longer matches, and the resolver re-polls CI against the new tree). Failed outcomes are NOT cached — re-entry always re-polls so a transient CI failure resolves on the next attempt. Multiple consumer steps in the same dispatcher pass share the cache: the first requires: [ci-complete] lookup runs the wait, and subsequent lookups at the same HEAD return satisfied without re-polling.
The precondition resolver is dispatcher-internal — it produces no phase_steps["6-finalize"] record of its own (the precondition is not itself a finalize step). The dispatcher bears responsibility for the wait_failed → ci_failure (precondition) outcome mapping on the consumer step. Consumer step bodies (under workflow/) MUST declare requires: [ci-complete] in their YAML frontmatter to opt into the precondition; absent the declaration, the dispatcher proceeds directly to the step body and does not invoke the resolver.
Special case — HEAD-dependent steps: four steps (pre-push-quality-gate, automated-review, sonar-roundtrip, commit-push) are HEAD-dependent. The first three validate the live worktree tree via local quality-gate, PR-comment, and Sonar infrastructure respectively; commit-push materializes the worktree's commit/push contract and MUST re-fire when a loop-back fix task produces a fresh commit after a prior commit-push recorded outcome=done against the now-stale HEAD. The general rule above is augmented for step_id IN HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS (defined below) with a worktree-HEAD comparison so a loop-back commit (typically produced by automated-review or sonar-roundtrip opening a fix task that produces a new commit) re-fires each gate against the newer code instead of skipping it on a stale done record:
| Persisted state | Live worktree HEAD | Action |
|---|---|---|
outcome == done AND head_at_completion == HEAD | matches | SKIP (steady-state — gate already validated this exact tree) |
outcome == done AND head_at_completion == HEAD | dirty (porcelain non-empty) | RE-FIRE (worktree has uncommitted changes — commit-push must re-run) |
outcome == done AND head_at_completion != HEAD | differs | RE-FIRE (treat as no record — HEAD has advanced past the validated SHA) |
outcome == done AND head_at_completion absent | n/a | RE-FIRE (record is incomplete without a SHA; safe default is to re-run) |
outcome == failed | n/a | RETRY (unchanged — same as the general rule) |
outcome == loop_back | n/a | RE-FIRE (treat as no record — same as the general rule for loop_back) |
| no record OR any other value | n/a | DISPATCH (unchanged — same as the general rule) |
The comparison consults both HEAD-advance AND git status --porcelain non-emptiness; the dirty-tree branch is scoped narrowly. commit-push is the only step in HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS for which dirty-tree re-fire is meaningful — the other four members (pre-push-quality-gate, automated-review, sonar-roundtrip, ci-verify) are read-only validators that do not produce commits, so a dirty tree at their re-entry indicates an upstream contract violation (a loop-back fix task mutated the worktree without invoking commit-push) rather than a re-fire trigger; those four continue to follow the HEAD-only table. The dispatcher block resolves the git status --porcelain call only when step_id == "commit-push" AND the persisted record matches HEAD (outcome == done AND head_at_completion == HEAD); the porcelain check is skipped entirely for the other four steps.
HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS = {"pre-push-quality-gate", "automated-review", "sonar-roundtrip", "commit-push", "ci-verify", "finalize-step-simplify"}. Each step MUST persist head_at_completion on its terminal --outcome done mark-step-done call so the comparison above is meaningful. The standards docs for each step (pre-push-quality-gate.md, automated-review.md, sonar-roundtrip.md, commit-push.md, finalize-step-simplify.md) carry the per-step instructions for capturing git rev-parse HEAD immediately before the mark-step-done invocation and forwarding it via --head-at-completion {sha}. finalize-step-simplify is HEAD-dependent because it applies simplification edits directly to the worktree; a loop-back fix task that advances HEAD must re-fire it so the simplification pass runs against the newer tree instead of skipping on a stale done record. Branches that mark loop_back or failed do not need to persist the SHA — the dispatcher's general resumability handling for those outcomes does not consult it. CI completion is a separate dispatcher-resolved precondition (requires: [ci-complete]) — its cache key is the same git rev-parse HEAD SHA, so the same HEAD-advance signal that invalidates a stale done record also invalidates the precondition cache.
Worktree-freshness precondition for commit-push: commit-push additionally requires that the worktree state itself has been observed by a fresh verify run — pre-push-quality-gate validates what the code is, while pre-commit-verify-freshness (see manage-tasks/SKILL.md § "Pre-Commit Verify Freshness") validates that a verify was actually performed against this version of the code. The two checks are complementary, not redundant: a worktree mutated after the most recent pyproject_build run log line passes neither — pre-push-quality-gate may pass against the new tree if the orchestrator re-runs it, but pre-commit-verify-freshness fails because no verify log line post-dates the mutation. The freshness gate is fail-closed: commit-push MUST refuse to proceed when pre-commit-verify-freshness returns status: stale or status: undecidable, recording outcome=failed with a structured display_detail. See standards/commit-push.md § "Freshness precondition" for the canonical call shape and the full status-to-action table.
Resolve the comparison HEAD inside the dispatcher block at the moment of the per-step check:
git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse HEAD
When step_id == "commit-push" AND the persisted record matches HEAD (outcome == done AND head_at_completion == HEAD), the dispatcher MUST additionally consult the worktree's porcelain status before deciding SKIP vs RE-FIRE:
git -C {worktree_path} status --porcelain
A non-empty result selects the dirty-tree row in the table above (RE-FIRE); an empty result selects the steady-state row (SKIP). The porcelain call is gated on step_id == "commit-push" — the other four HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS members do not invoke it, so a dirty worktree does NOT re-fire them.
Do NOT cache the live HEAD across loop iterations — read it fresh per step so a step that advances HEAD mid-loop (e.g., an inline commit produced by a loop-back fix task) is observed correctly by every later step's check. All other finalize steps keep the general rule above verbatim; this special case applies only to the four steps named in HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS.
Per-agent timeout wrapper: Every Task agent dispatch in this loop runs under a per-agent timeout budget. If the dispatch does not return inside the budget, the wrapper logs an ERROR, marks the step failed via manage-status mark-step-done, and continues with the next step in the list (no abort, no re-throw). Inline-only steps are not timeout-wrapped because they execute in the main context where the host platform already manages call timeouts. Budgets:
| Step | Budget | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
default:sonar-roundtrip | 15 min (900s) | Full Sonar gate roundtrip plus optional fix-task creation |
default:automated-review | 15 min (900s) | CI wait + review-bot buffer + comment triage |
default:lessons-capture | 5 min (300s) | Bounded manage-lessons add + Write workflow |
| All other steps | no explicit budget | Fall under the host platform's default per-call ceiling |
For each step reference:
Agent-suitable built-in steps (self-contained, no user interaction) — each dispatches to plan-marshall:execution-context-{level} with the role-resolved workflow doc:
| Step reference | Resolver lookup | Workflow doc |
|---|---|---|
default:create-pr | --phase phase-6-finalize (no --role; tracks phase-6-finalize.default) | plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/create-pr.md |
default:ci-verify | --phase phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (LLM core classifies failing checks into the multi-failure-mode taxonomy) | plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/ci-verify.md |
default:lessons-capture | --phase phase-6-finalize --role post-run-review | plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/lessons-capture.md |
default:automated-review | --phase phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (LLM core; outer wrapper tracks phase-6-finalize.default) | plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/automated-review.md |
default:sonar-roundtrip | --phase phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback (LLM core; outer wrapper tracks phase-6-finalize.default) | plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/sonar-roundtrip.md |
automated-review and sonar-roundtrip are orchestrator workflows — their LLM-judgement core is a single internal verification-feedback dispatch (with producer=pr-comment / producer=sonar runtime input). The outer wrapper resolves under phase-6-finalize.default since the body is mostly script execution and one sub-dispatch.
Dispatch pattern — resolve the target via the role resolver. Pass --phase phase-6-finalize for every dispatched step; add --role <subkey> only when the step has its own sub-key in the table above:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
effort resolve-target --phase phase-6-finalize [--role <subkey>]
Extract the target field from the TOON output. Use that value as {target} in the dispatch and the post-resolve log line below.
Emit the standardized post-resolve dispatch log line — see ../ref-workflow-architecture/standards/dispatch-logging.md § Emission contract. Substitute {role} with default when no --role flag was passed, otherwise the explicit sub-key value:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO \
--message "[DISPATCH] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) target={target} level={level} role={role} workflow={workflow-doc-from-table} plan_id={plan_id}"
Dispatch:
Task: plan-marshall:{target}
prompt: |
name: <step-name>
plan_id: {plan_id}
skills[N]:
- <step-specific skills>
workflow: <workflow-doc-from-table>
WORKTREE: {worktree_path}
The 5-field prompt-body contract (name, plan_id, skills[], workflow, WORKTREE) is documented in plan-marshall:extension-api/standards/ext-point-execution-context-workflow. The variant resolution (canonical no-suffix for inherit/empty level; execution-context-{level} otherwise) lives in plan-marshall:plan-marshall/standards/effort-variants.md.
Inline-only built-in steps (require user interaction, sequential dependency, or are bounded polling primitives that fit comfortably under the host platform's per-call Bash ceiling):
architecture-refresh (AskUserQuestion for Tier-1 prompt mode; consumes architecture-pre/ snapshot from phase-1-init Step 5d), branch-cleanup (AskUserQuestion), record-metrics (must run immediately before archive-plan on the still-live plan directory), archive-plan (must be last, moves plan files). Note: commit-push is also inline-only but is HEAD-dependent (see § HEAD-dependent steps below), so it appears in HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS rather than here.Per-step agent <usage> totals are persisted on disk by manage-metrics accumulate-agent-usage (called from step 5b below). The on-disk file .plan/plans/{plan_id}/work/metrics-accumulator-6-finalize.toon survives context compaction and is read by default:record-metrics at end-phase time. Do NOT maintain a parallel tally in model context — the on-disk file is authoritative.
Initialise the loop_back_iteration counter to 0 BEFORE entering the FOR loop (i.e., here, at the start of Step 3 — outside the loop body). The counter persists across FOR-loop re-entries triggered by the loop-back continuation hook (step 7b below), so that the max_iterations ceiling is enforced across the entire dispatch. Initialising the counter inside the FOR loop body (e.g., on each entry into the loop) would reset it on every loop-back BREAK + RE-ENTER, defeating the ceiling. The counter is held in model context for the duration of the dispatch — it is NOT persisted to status.json; a fresh phase-6-finalize entry (e.g., after a session restart) starts the counter back at 0.
loop_back_iteration = 0 # initialised once, before the FOR loop; persists across FOR-loop re-entries from the loop-back hook (step 7b)
FOR each step_id in manifest.phase_6.steps:
# Resolve full step reference. Manifest entries may be:
# - bare names (e.g. `commit-push`) — built-in, prepend `default:`
# - already-prefixed (`default:foo`, `project:bar`, `bundle:skill`) — use verbatim
# The composer preserves `project:` / `bundle:skill` prefixes from marshal.json;
# only `default:` may be stripped. So presence of `:` in step_id => external step.
IF step_id contains ':':
step_ref = step_id # external step (`project:` / `bundle:skill`) — preserve verbatim
ELSE:
step_ref = "default:" + step_id # built-in step — prepend `default:` prefix
1. Resumable re-entry check:
Read status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"][step_id]:
- IF step_id IN HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS (the HEAD-dependent special-case set; see "HEAD-dependent step set" note below):
Resolve the live worktree HEAD via `git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse HEAD`.
Read this fresh per iteration; do NOT cache across the loop.
- IF outcome == "done" AND head_at_completion == live HEAD: SKIP this step
- IF outcome == "done" AND head_at_completion != live HEAD: RE-FIRE (treat as no record — dispatch as fresh run)
- IF outcome == "done" AND head_at_completion is absent: RE-FIRE (record is incomplete without a SHA; dispatch as fresh run)
- IF outcome == "failed": RETRY (proceed to dispatch as fresh run)
- IF outcome == "loop_back": RE-FIRE (treat as no record — dispatch as fresh run)
- IF no record OR any other value: dispatch normally
- ELSE (every other step keeps the general rule):
- IF outcome == "done": SKIP this step (continue to next iteration)
- IF outcome == "failed": RETRY (proceed to dispatch as fresh run)
- IF outcome == "loop_back": RE-FIRE (treat as no record — dispatch as fresh run)
- IF no record OR any other value: dispatch normally
Log skip/retry/re-fire decisions at INFO level so the work.log reflects the re-entry path.
**HEAD-dependent step set**: `HEAD_DEPENDENT_STEPS = {"pre-push-quality-gate", "automated-review", "sonar-roundtrip", "commit-push", "ci-verify", "finalize-step-simplify"}`. The first three validate the live worktree tree via local quality-gate, PR-comment, and Sonar infrastructure respectively. `finalize-step-simplify` applies simplification edits directly to the worktree, so it re-fires when a loop-back commit advances HEAD past its previously-recorded `head_at_completion` — the same HEAD-comparison contract as the validators. A loop-back commit (typically produced by `automated-review` or `sonar-roundtrip` opening a fix task that produces a new commit) advances HEAD past the previously-validated SHA, and a stale `done` record on any of these three steps would produce a false-clean result on re-entry. `commit-push` enters the HEAD-dependent set because a loop-back fix task may produce a fresh commit *after* `commit-push` recorded `outcome=done` against the prior HEAD; without HEAD-comparison the dispatcher would skip `commit-push` on re-entry and leave the fix-task changes staged-but-uncommitted. The same `head_at_completion` comparison applies to all four. Other inline-only steps (`architecture-refresh`, `branch-cleanup`, `record-metrics`, `archive-plan`, `project:finalize-step-deploy-target`, `project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache`) and pure-administrative agent steps (`create-pr`, `lessons-capture`) are NOT HEAD-dependent — their effect is captured by side-effect (a created PR, recorded lessons, regenerated `target/claude/` from the post-merge source tree) and is idempotent against HEAD advances; the general rule above applies to them. CI completion is resolved as a separate dispatcher-side precondition (`requires: [ci-complete]`) — its cache key is the same `git rev-parse HEAD` SHA, so a HEAD advance also invalidates the precondition cache.
> **Script-layer dirty-worktree invariant**: the three may-mutate steps (`automated-review`, `sonar-roundtrip`, `finalize-step-simplify`) are also enforced at the script layer by `manage-status mark-step-done`, which refuses `--outcome done` for any step in `MAY_MUTATE_WORKTREE_STEPS` while the resolved worktree is dirty (`git status --porcelain` non-empty), returning `error: dirty_worktree_done_refused`. This complements the HEAD-comparison contract above: HEAD-comparison re-fires a step when a loop-back commit advances the tree past a stale `done` record; the dirty-worktree refusal prevents the inverse failure — recording `done` while an *uncommitted* inline edit still sits in the tree, which would let the dispatcher advance past `commit-push` and silently drop the mutation. The refusal's two escape paths map directly onto the Loop-back Target Contract below: re-issue as `--outcome loop_back --loop-back-target 6-finalize` (inline replay so `commit-push` re-fires) or `--loop-back-target 5-execute` (fix-task rollback). See `manage-status/SKILL.md` § mark-step-done → "Dirty-worktree invariant on `done`".
2. Log step start:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "[STEP] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Executing step: {step_ref}"
3. Determine step type:
- IF step_ref starts with "default:" -> BUILT-IN type (use step_id for dispatch table lookup)
- ELSE IF step_ref starts with "project:" -> PROJECT type (manifest may someday include extension steps)
- ELSE IF step_ref contains ":" -> SKILL type
4. Pre-archive snapshot hook (run BEFORE dispatching the step if step_id == "archive-plan"):
See "Pre-Archive Snapshot Hook" subsection below. Capture the snapshot into model context, then proceed to step 5 to dispatch archive-plan normally.
4b. Lessons-capture Signal Gate (B4 — run BEFORE dispatching the step if step_id == "lessons-capture"):
The deterministic three-signal Signal Gate is evaluated at dispatcher level so the envelope spawn cost is avoided when all three signals are zero. The dispatcher computes the precondition; the LLM workflow body is the recording loop only. When all three signals are zero, short-circuit and record `outcome=skipped`.
a. Compute three signal counts:
**Signal 1 — Q-Gate findings, pending OR resolved-in-run (sum across five phases)**:
For each phase in `{2-refine, 3-outline, 4-plan, 5-execute, 6-finalize}`, invoke the pending query:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase {phase} --resolution pending
Parse `filtered_count` from each TOON output — this is the per-phase pending count. (`total_count` is the unfiltered cardinality of the entire findings store and MUST NOT be used as the pending-count signal — the call filters by `--resolution pending`, so the matching count lives in `filtered_count`.) Sum the five `filtered_count` values into `pending_subtotal`.
Then, for each of the same five phases, count the Q-Gate findings the run RESOLVED. The Q-Gate facet shares the same resolved-in-run blind spot as Signals 2 and 3: a finding that was raised AND resolved (`fixed` / `suppressed` / `accepted` / `taken_into_account`) within the run is a slipped-then-caught defect — the highest-value lesson class — yet a pending-only count contributes zero for it. For each phase, invoke the four non-pending resolution filters and sum their `filtered_count` values:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase {phase} --resolution fixed
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase {phase} --resolution suppressed
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase {phase} --resolution accepted
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
qgate list --plan-id {plan_id} --phase {phase} --resolution taken_into_account
Parse `filtered_count` from each (NOT `total_count`) and sum all twenty values (five phases × four non-pending resolutions) into `resolved_subtotal`. `signal_1_count = pending_subtotal + resolved_subtotal`, so Signal 1 fires on EITHER pending OR resolved-in-run Q-Gate findings — symmetric with the remediated-in-run triggers added to Signals 2 and 3.
**Signal 2 — automated-review outcome (outstanding OR remediated-in-run)**:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status \
read --plan-id {plan_id}
Locate the `automated-review` step under `metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"]`. Then query the count of review-bot findings the run REMEDIATED:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-findings:manage-findings \
list --plan-id {plan_id} --type pr-comment --resolution fixed
Parse `filtered_count` from that TOON output (the `--resolution fixed` filter narrows the `artifacts/findings/pr-comment.jsonl` store to the in-run-fixed entries). `signal_2_count = 1` when ANY of the following holds; `0` otherwise: (a) `outcome` is anything other than `done`, (b) `display_detail` reports a non-zero promoted-comment count (e.g. `"3 comments promoted"`), (c) the `manage-findings list --type pr-comment --resolution fixed` query returns one or more findings (`filtered_count >= 1`). Trigger (c) is the remediated-in-run facet: a review-bot finding caught-and-fixed within the same run resolves to zero outstanding comments and leaves the step `outcome=done`, so triggers (a) and (b) both report zero — yet the run carried a lesson-bearing slipped-then-caught defect (the originating `hash_id=d9c3c7` case). Counting `resolution=fixed` pr-comment findings fires the signal for exactly that class. Triggers (a) and (b) are preserved unchanged.
**Signal 3 — script-failure clusters (three marker classes)**:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
read --plan-id {plan_id} --type work
Scan the returned log lines for THREE marker classes and bucket each by the distinct failing script notation (the `bundle:skill:script` token in the line):
- **`[FAILED]`** lines — explicit failure markers.
- **`[ERROR] ... script_failure`** lines — the canonical per-call non-zero-exit marker emitted by the phase Error Handling sections (argparse rejections, internal errors, "Unknown notation" failures). These never carry a `[FAILED]` token.
- **`voluntary_checkpoint → error`** reclassifications — the dispatch-boundary no-progress reclassification (B7); the failing notation is the dispatched workflow/agent whose dispatch was reclassified.
`signal_3_count` is the number of distinct notations across the UNION of all three marker classes (a notation that fails under more than one class counts once). The motivating case is `2026-05-29-21-001` — long builds lost across the dispatch boundary, logged as `[ERROR] script_failure` plus a `voluntary_checkpoint → error` reclassification but never a `[FAILED]` line. This marker set is kept consistent with the retrospective analyzer's failure-marker set (lesson `2026-05-29-12-001`) so the Signal-Gate count and the retrospective's script-failure cluster count stay aligned.
b. Three-zero short-circuit:
When `signal_1_count == 0 AND signal_2_count == 0 AND signal_3_count == 0`:
- Mark the step done with `outcome=skipped` directly from the dispatcher (do NOT dispatch the envelope):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status mark-step-done \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize --step lessons-capture --outcome skipped \
--display-detail "no lesson-bearing signals"
- Log the skip decision:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
decision --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO \
--message "(plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize:lessons-capture) Signal Gate skip — all three signals zero (qgate=0, automated-review=0, script-failures=0)"
- CONTINUE the FOR loop (skip item 5 dispatch entirely for this step).
c. Forward gate counts on dispatch (when at least one signal is non-zero):
The envelope no longer re-computes the three signals — the dispatcher forwards them as runtime inputs so the body skips its (now-removed) Signal Gate step. Add the three count fields verbatim into the prompt body's runtime-inputs block alongside `plan_id` (see item 5 below):
signal_qgate_pending_count: {signal_1_count}
signal_automated_review_count: {signal_2_count}
signal_script_failure_clusters_count: {signal_3_count}
Continue to item 5 (Dispatch with timeout wrapper).
5. Dispatch with timeout wrapper:
Resolve the per-agent timeout budget from the table above (15 min for sonar/automated-review, 5 min for knowledge/lessons; no explicit budget for other steps).
- BUILT-IN (agent-suitable) — route each step_ref to the generic `execution-context-{level}` dispatcher via the Task tool, passing the step's workflow doc and role key through the prompt body, wrapped with the resolved timeout. The workflow-doc-bearing dispatch carries the step's enforcement envelope (input contract, required skill loads, prohibited actions) inside the subagent context via the loaded skills + workflow; a generic unscoped dispatch with no workflow doc is NOT valid.
**Role-aware dispatch** (applies to all four built-in agent-suitable steps):
(1) Resolve the level-bound target via the resolver:
```
target = python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
effort resolve-target --phase phase-6-finalize [--role <subkey>]
```
Returns `execution-context-{level}` (variant), or canonical `execution-context` for `inherit`/empty.
(2) Dispatch via `Task(subagent_type: plan-marshall:<target>, …)` with prompt body `name`, `plan_id`, `skills[]`, `workflow: plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize/workflow/{name}.md`, `WORKTREE`.
Per-step workflow docs and resolver lookups:
* default:create-pr -> workflow: workflow/create-pr.md | --phase phase-6-finalize (no --role)
* default:ci-verify -> workflow: workflow/ci-verify.md | --phase phase-6-finalize --role verification-feedback
* default:automated-review -> workflow: workflow/automated-review.md | --phase phase-6-finalize (outer wrapper; inner verification-feedback dispatch uses --role verification-feedback) | timeout: 900s
* default:sonar-roundtrip -> workflow: workflow/sonar-roundtrip.md | --phase phase-6-finalize (outer wrapper; inner verification-feedback dispatch uses --role verification-feedback) | timeout: 900s
* default:lessons-capture -> workflow: workflow/lessons-capture.md | --phase phase-6-finalize --role post-run-review | timeout: 300s
The subagent's body loads `dev-agent-behavior-rules` + the prompt's `skills[]`, then `Read`s the workflow doc and executes its steps inside the dispatch envelope. Pass `--plan-id {plan_id}` and, when an `{iteration}` counter applies, `--iteration {iteration}` as workflow-specific runtime inputs in the prompt body. The Worktree Header is conveyed via the always-required `WORKTREE` prompt-body field; the subagent resolves the worktree path internally and propagates it into any further dispatches it issues.
**On timeout** (the dispatch does not return within the budget):
a. Log ERROR:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level ERROR --message "[ERROR] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Step {step_ref} timed out after {budget}s — marking failed and continuing"
b. Mark step failed:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status mark-step-done \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize --step {step_id} --outcome failed \
--display-detail "timed out after {budget}s"
c. Continue to the next step in the loop — DO NOT abort the pipeline.
- BUILT-IN (inline-only: commit-push, architecture-refresh, branch-cleanup, record-metrics, archive-plan):
Read the standards document from dispatch table and follow all steps in main context. Inline steps are not wrapped by the per-agent timeout block above — they execute under the host platform's standard per-call ceiling.
- PROJECT/SKILL: Branch on the dispatched-vs-inline classification from the
"Dispatched workflows vs inline steps" section. A `project:` / `bundle:skill`
step is DISPATCHED when that section lists it as dispatched
(`project:finalize-step-pre-submission-self-review`,
`project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor`, and any external step that section
marks dispatched); every other external step is INLINE.
**DISPATCHED project/skill step** — route through the generic
`execution-context-{level}` dispatcher exactly like an agent-suitable
built-in, wrapped with the resolved per-agent timeout:
(1) Resolve the level-bound target via the resolver:
```
target = python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
effort resolve-target --phase phase-6-finalize [--role <subkey>]
```
Use the step's resolved role from the "Dispatched workflows vs inline steps"
section (`project:finalize-step-pre-submission-self-review` → `phase-6-finalize`,
no `--role`; `project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor` → `phase-6-finalize --role
verification-feedback` with `producer=plugin-doctor` runtime input).
(2) Emit the standardized `[DISPATCH]` work-log line (see
[`../ref-workflow-architecture/standards/dispatch-logging.md`](../ref-workflow-architecture/standards/dispatch-logging.md)
§ Emission contract). Substitute `{role}` with `default` when no `--role`
flag was passed, otherwise the explicit sub-key value:
```bash
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO \
--message "[DISPATCH] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) target={target} level={level} role={role} workflow={step's own SKILL.md notation} plan_id={plan_id}"
```
(3) Dispatch via the Task tool. The workflow doc for a dispatched project/skill
step is the project skill's own SKILL.md (e.g.
`project:finalize-step-plugin-doctor/SKILL.md`):
```
Task: plan-marshall:{target}
prompt: |
name: {step_name}
plan_id: {plan_id}
skills[N]:
- <step-specific skills>
workflow: {step's own SKILL.md notation}
WORKTREE: {worktree_path}
```
Forward `--plan-id {plan_id}`, `--iteration {iteration}`, and any
`producer` runtime input as workflow-specific prompt-body inputs. The
`[--session-id {session_id}]` runtime input follows the same whitelist
rule documented under "Interface Contract for External Steps".
The DISPATCHED branch obeys the same "On timeout" handling as the
agent-suitable built-in branch (item 5 above): log ERROR, mark the step
`failed`, continue to the next step.
- INLINE project/skill step — load the skill with interface contract in the
main context:
Skill: {step_ref}
Arguments: --plan-id {plan_id} --iteration {iteration} [--session-id {session_id}]
The INLINE branch is reserved for genuinely-inline external steps
(`project:finalize-step-deploy-target`, `project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache`).
Append `--session-id {session_id}` ONLY when `step_ref` is on the
Session-id forwarding whitelist documented under "Interface Contract
for External Steps" above (the table at that section is the single
source of truth — do not re-list its entries here). Off-whitelist
external steps receive `--plan-id` and `--iteration` only —
appending `--session-id` to a step that does not declare it risks a
"rejected unknown flag" failure.
5b. Accumulate agent usage (only when the dispatched step ran as a Task agent and did NOT time out):
Extract total_tokens, tool_uses, duration_ms from the agent's <usage> tag, then persist them on disk via:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-metrics:manage-metrics accumulate-agent-usage \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize \
--total-tokens {total_tokens} --tool-uses {tool_uses} --duration-ms {duration_ms}
The script reads `.plan/plans/{plan_id}/work/metrics-accumulator-6-finalize.toon` (initialising it on first call), sums in the supplied values, increments the `samples` counter, and writes the file back. Inline steps and timed-out steps skip this call — the timeout path's cost is captured by the `manage-metrics enrich` transcript sweep inside `default:record-metrics`. Step 5b runs at most once per dispatched agent return; do NOT also append the totals to a model-context variable.
5c. Record dispatch-boundary row for the just-returned step (per-step, only when 5b also ran):
Apply the SAME gate as 5b — fire only when the step ran as a Task agent and did NOT time out. Inline-only steps (commit-push, architecture-refresh, branch-cleanup, record-metrics, archive-plan, project:finalize-step-deploy-target, project:finalize-step-sync-plugin-cache) skip this call uniformly, mirroring the 5b gate. The call fires per-step — once for each dispatched finalize step return — NOT once per phase entry.
Classify the step's return into exactly one of the four phase-6-finalize termination causes:
| Cause | Detection rule |
|-------|----------------|
| `step_complete` | The dispatched step returned cleanly (its `mark-step-done` call recorded `outcome: done`). |
| `blocked_user_review` | The dispatched step raised an `AskUserQuestion` review gate that halted dispatch (e.g., branch-cleanup confirmation, sonar-roundtrip `loop_back` prompt under `loop_back_without_asking=false`). |
| `blocked_session_restart` | The dispatch was cut short by a session restart, harness cancellation, or the per-agent timeout budget firing (timeout block at item 5 above). |
| `error` | The dispatched step's `mark-step-done` call recorded `outcome: failed`. |
Forward the `<usage>` totals captured by 5b (total_tokens, tool_uses, duration_ms):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-metrics:manage-metrics record-dispatch-boundary \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 6-finalize --termination-cause {step_complete|blocked_user_review|blocked_session_restart|error} \
--total-tokens {total_tokens} --tool-uses {tool_uses} --duration-ms {duration_ms}
The accumulating artifact at `work/metrics-dispatch-boundaries-6-finalize.toon` is the per-step audit trail that `plan-retrospective` correlates with finalize-step `[STEP]` log coverage; the same shape as the phase-5-execute boundary artifact, generalised to per-phase keying.
6. Capture archive result (only when step_id == "archive-plan"):
Record the returned `archive_path` into model context alongside the pre-archive snapshot — it is consumed by Step 4 (Render Final Output Template).
7. Log step completion:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "[STEP] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Completed step: {step_ref}"
### Loop-back Target Contract
Two invariants govern every loop-back outcome emitted by a phase-6-finalize step. Both are structural: a violation is a contract bug, not a degraded run.
- **Target phase invariant**: every loop-back-emitting finalize step MUST persist a `loop_back_target` value on its `mark-step-done --outcome loop_back` call. The persisted target MUST be one of `5-execute` or `6-finalize` — no other phases (notably `2-refine`, `3-outline`, or `4-plan`) are legal targets. The two-value enumeration is structural: `5-execute` denotes a full-phase rollback for fix-task-required dispositions (FIX with `fix_tasks_created > 0`, `overflow_deferred > 0`); `6-finalize` denotes inline replay of the same finalize step for inline-fixable dispositions (SUPPRESS, narrow-rationale ACCEPT, single-annotation FIX). The continuation hook (§ 7b below) routes deterministically on the field value — when target is `5-execute`, the loop-back-emitting step also persists `current_phase: 5-execute` via `manage-status set-phase --phase 5-execute` BEFORE its terminal `mark-step-done` call; when target is `6-finalize`, the persisted `current_phase` stays at `6-finalize` (no `set-phase` call) and the continuation hook replays the loop-back-marked step via the resumable re-entry check. Authoritative call sites: `workflow/automated-review.md` and `workflow/sonar-roundtrip.md` — each carries an inline "Loopback target invariant" marker above its `set-phase` block (or, when target is `6-finalize`, above the conditional that suppresses the `set-phase` call) as the structural guard against silent drift. The dispatcher-level enforcement of this invariant lives in `plan-marshall/workflow/execution.md` § "Loop-back continuation" → ELSE branch (the persisted-phase assertion that fires before any user-facing prompt).
- **Granularity invariant**: loopback granularity is the **triage workflow's responsibility**, encoded in the `loop_back_target` field on the `mark-step-done --outcome loop_back` call. Two granularity tiers govern every loop-back iteration: `5-execute` denotes a **full-phase rollback** for fix-task-required dispositions (FIX with `fix_tasks_created > 0`, `overflow_deferred > 0`) — the continuation hook (§ 7b) re-enters `phase-5-execute` from the top of its `manage-tasks next` loop, the execute pipeline drives the freshly-allocated fix tasks to done, then transitions `5-execute → 6-finalize` via the standard `phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking` gate. `6-finalize` denotes an **inline replay** of the same finalize step for inline-fixable dispositions (SUPPRESS, narrow-rationale ACCEPT, single-annotation FIX with no fix-task allocation) — the continuation hook stays in `6-finalize`, does NOT call `set-phase`, and re-fires the loop-back-marked step via the resumable re-entry check. **The dispatcher MUST honour the `loop_back_target` field; it MUST NOT decide granularity itself.** This replaces the prior "all loopbacks are full phase rollbacks" invariant: the answer to the canonical user question "are all loopback-triggered changes done as full phase changes, or are inline changes done as well?" is now **both, depending on the triage classification — fix-task-required dispositions roll back the phase; inline-fixable dispositions replay the same finalize step in place**.
Cross-references: `workflow/automated-review.md` § "Handle findings (loop-back)" and Branch D, `workflow/sonar-roundtrip.md` § "Handle findings (loop-back)" and Branch D — each carries the conditional `set-phase` / `mark-step-done --loop-back-target` shape described above. `plan-marshall/workflow/triage.md` § Step 7 owns the granularity classification rule (the table that maps disposition types to the two `loop_back_target` values). The dispatcher-level enforcement of the invariant lives in `plan-marshall/workflow/execution.md` § "Loop-back continuation" → ELSE branch (the persisted-phase assertion). The four-corner truth table for the `finalize_without_asking` × `loop_back_without_asking` flag combinations is documented in § 7b below.
7b. Loop-back continuation hook (consult the just-recorded outcome):
Read the step's recorded outcome from `status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"][step_id]` (the dispatched agent's `mark-step-done` call wrote it). When `outcome == "loop_back"`, also read the persisted `loop_back_target` field from the same record — it is structurally guaranteed to be present on every `loop_back` outcome (the manage-status `--loop-back-target` validation contract enforces this; absence is a dispatcher contract bug, not a routing case to handle). The two legal values are `5-execute` (full-phase rollback) and `6-finalize` (inline replay).
**Symmetric-knob and ceiling check (BEFORE the granularity branch)** — the `loop_back_without_asking` knob and the `max_iterations` ceiling apply uniformly to BOTH granularity tiers. They gate whether the chosen dispatch shape executes inline or halts and prompts. The `loop_back_target` value selects the dispatch shape AFTER these gates pass.
Consult the symmetric auto-continuation knob to decide whether to halt or re-enter inline:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-config:manage-config \
plan phase-6-finalize get --field loop_back_without_asking --audit-plan-id {plan_id}
Read the returned `value`:
- IF `value == false` (default): halt the FOR loop, mark the finalize phase as needing a re-entry, and emit the user-facing prompt (named for the persisted `loop_back_target`):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO \
--message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Loop-back signalled by {step_ref} (target={loop_back_target}): returning control to user (loop_back_without_asking=false)"
IF `loop_back_target == "5-execute"`:
Display: "Loop-back signalled. Run '/plan-marshall action=execute plan={plan_id}' when ready to dispatch the fix tasks."
IF `loop_back_target == "6-finalize"`:
Display: "Loop-back signalled (inline replay). Run '/plan-marshall action=finalize plan={plan_id}' to replay the finalize step."
STOP.
- IF `value == true`: increment the in-memory `loop_back_iteration` counter (initialised to 0 at the start of Step 3, BEFORE the FOR loop — see the `loop_back_iteration = 0` line above the `FOR each step_id` header. The counter persists across FOR-loop re-entries triggered by step 7b, so the `max_iterations` ceiling is enforced across the entire dispatch rather than reset per re-entry — counted across BOTH granularity tiers) and consult the ceiling:
(a) Compare against `phase-6-finalize.max_iterations` (default 3, read in Step 2). When `loop_back_iteration > max_iterations`, halt with a user-facing prompt — even with the flag set, the ceiling is the structural safety valve. This applies to BOTH granularity tiers:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level WARNING \
--message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Loop-back ceiling reached ({loop_back_iteration}/{max_iterations}) — halting and returning control to user"
Display: "Loop-back iteration ceiling reached. Inspect pending fix tasks via 'manage-tasks list --status pending --plan-id {plan_id}' and re-run when ready."
STOP.
(b) Otherwise, emit the canonical iteration log line:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO \
--message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Loop-back iteration {loop_back_iteration}/{max_iterations}"
**Granularity branch (AFTER the symmetric-knob and ceiling gates have passed)** — the `loop_back_target` value selects only the dispatch shape. Both branches share the same iteration counter and ceiling.
- IF `loop_back_target == "6-finalize"` (inline replay for inline-fixable dispositions): the calling step did NOT issue a `manage-status set-phase --phase 5-execute` call, so the persisted `current_phase` is still `6-finalize`. The continuation hook **skips the phase-5-execute re-dispatch entirely** — do NOT call `manage-status set-phase`, do NOT load `Skill: phase-5-execute`. Just BREAK out of the current FOR iteration and RE-ENTER the FOR loop from the start of `manifest.phase_6.steps`. The resumable re-entry check (item 1 above) sees the `loop_back`-marked step and re-fires it directly.
- IF `loop_back_target == "5-execute"` (full-phase rollback for fix-task-required dispositions): the calling step issued `manage-status set-phase --phase 5-execute` before its terminal `mark-step-done`, so the persisted `current_phase` is `5-execute`. Dispatch the inline execute pipeline. The inline re-entry mirrors the forward `phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking` path (`workflow/execution.md` § Execute Phase Completion) — it runs the execute pipeline against the freshly-allocated fix tasks, transitions back to `6-finalize`, and re-enters this FOR loop:
1. Set the plan back to phase-5-execute (the loop-back-emitting step typically did this already via `manage-status set-phase`; idempotent re-issue is safe):
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-status:manage-status set-phase \
--plan-id {plan_id} --phase 5-execute
2. Dispatch the execute pipeline inline by re-loading `phase-5-execute`:
Skill: plan-marshall:phase-5-execute
Arguments: --plan-id {plan_id}
The execute pipeline picks up the freshly-allocated fix tasks (created by the FIX disposition or by the overflow-handling path) via the standard `manage-tasks next` loop, drives them to done, then transitions `5-execute → 6-finalize` via the existing `phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking` gate. When `finalize_without_asking == false`, the inline re-entry halts at the standard prompt — symmetric loop-back is gated by both knobs in series, so a project can opt into automated forward continuation without also opting into automated loop-back continuation.
3. After phase-5-execute returns, BREAK out of the current FOR loop iteration position and RE-ENTER the FOR loop from the start of `manifest.phase_6.steps`. The resumable re-entry check (item 1 above) skips already-`done` steps, retries `failed` steps, and re-fires the `loop_back`-marked step now that its preconditions have been addressed.
Note: the BREAK + RE-ENTER above is a control-flow construct, not a per-step skip. The FOR loop re-iteration uses the same manifest list and the same per-step resumable check; the only state that changes is the `phase_steps["6-finalize"][step_id]` records (the dispatched agent will record a fresh outcome on its next run).
The `loop_back_iteration` counter is held in model context for the duration of the dispatch — it is NOT persisted to status.json. A fresh phase-6-finalize entry (e.g., after a session restart) starts the counter back at 0; the manifest's resumable re-entry check still skips already-`done` steps, so re-entering after a restart re-runs only the steps that recorded `loop_back` or `failed` on the previous invocation.
END FOR
Critical invariant: This loop iterates only the manifest list. A step that is NOT in manifest.phase_6.steps MUST NOT fire under any circumstance — there is no fallback to a "default" step set, no inference from config booleans, no per-step skip logic. The manifest is the contract. If a deployment requires a different step set, recompose the manifest at outline time.
Lessons-capture unconditionality: When lessons-capture IS in manifest.phase_6.steps (the composer includes it for every non-trivial change-type), this loop dispatches it on every Phase 6 entry. It is not gated on PR state, CI state, or earlier step outcomes — reaching Phase 6 is itself the trigger.
Symmetric auto-continuation invariant: The loop_back_without_asking flag is the structural counterpart to phase-5-execute.finalize_without_asking. The two knobs together define the four corners of the unattended-vs-interactive matrix:
finalize_without_asking | loop_back_without_asking | Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
false (default) | any | The forward 5-execute → 6-finalize transition halts and prompts the user. Loop-back never fires inline because finalize is not entered in the same orchestration cycle. |
true | false (default) | Forward auto-continuation; loop-back halts at the inline execute re-entry point and prompts the user. (This is the conservative shape: forward is automated, reverse is interactive.) |
true | true | Full unattended cycle. A loop_back outcome re-dispatches execute inline up to max_iterations times, then halts even with the flag set. |
false | true | Effectively false/false from the user's perspective: forward halts and prompts before phase-6-finalize ever runs, so the loop-back hook is unreachable in the same orchestration cycle. |
The conservative default (loop_back_without_asking=false) ships an interactive shape so existing plans behave the same as before this knob was added. Projects that want full unattended execution must opt into both knobs.
When the NEXT step to dispatch is default:archive-plan (always the last CONFIGURED step), capture a snapshot of plan state BEFORE dispatching archive-plan. The archive step moves .plan/plans/{plan_id}/ to .plan/archived-plans/{date}-{plan_id}/ and invalidates subsequent manage-status read calls against the live path, so the renderer (Step 4) would be unable to read state after archive returns.
The snapshot is held in model context (in-memory) — do NOT write a work file to disk. It flows directly from this hook into Step 4's render procedure.
Capture the following values:
status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"] — dict of {step_name: {outcome, display_detail}} from manage-status read --plan-id {plan_id}.manage-solution-outline read --plan-id {plan_id} (ordered list of titles and per-deliverable state).phase_6.steps list — from manage-execution-manifest read --plan-id {plan_id} (already fetched in Step 2; capture the bare-name list for renderer ordering).git -C {main_checkout} branch --show-current, porcelain via git -C {main_checkout} status --porcelain.ci pr view --plan-id {plan_id} (preferred) or ci pr view --project-dir {main_checkout} (escape hatch). Treat error (no PR for branch) as state=n/a, number=n/a.manage-solution-outline read --plan-id {plan_id} --section summary and extract the content field. On section_not_found or empty content, store the sentinel value None; the emission procedure substitutes the defensive placeholder (no summary recorded).
See standards/output-template.md#snapshot-procedure for exact commands and field extraction.After the snapshot is captured, dispatch default:archive-plan normally (step 5 in the FOR body above) and capture its returned archive_path (step 6). Both the snapshot and archive_path flow into Step 4 "Render Final Output Template".
Built-in step notes:
default:branch-cleanup: Do NOT preemptively skip based on PR state. The executor always runs to completion and records outcome=done — the dispatcher contract is unchanged. The standard's internal AskUserQuestion confirmation gate is now conditional on a conflict-severity classifier (baseline-reconcile --no-emit) per standards/branch-cleanup.md § "Conflict-Severity Classifier": clean / auto-resolvable rebases bypass the prompt under the default no_overlap_only threshold; genuine overlap_with_content_conflict cases still fire the prompt. Only the standard's internal user-interaction surface narrowed; the dispatcher continues to treat the step as a single inline run-to-completion.default:record-metrics: MUST immediately precede default:archive-plan. This step finalizes the 6-finalize phase with two manage-metrics writes (end-phase for the closing phase + generate for metrics.md) and a separate enrich for session token capture. Plan finalization has no "next phase" so the fused phase-boundary subcommand does not apply here — see standards/record-metrics.md for the authoritative sequence. All writes MUST land on the live plan directory; if archive runs first, the target directory no longer exists and each command would recreate a post-archive orphan under .plan/local/plans/{plan_id}/.default:archive-plan: This step MUST be last in the default order because it moves plan files (including status.json), which breaks manage-* scripts. All plan operations must complete before archive.Do NOT add any further manage-metrics invocations after default:archive-plan or after Skill: plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize returns to its caller. The plan-finalization bookkeeping (end-phase + enrich + generate) is fully contained by default:record-metrics.
default:archive-plan in Step 3 atomically marks the active phase done and sets current_phase: complete on the live status.json BEFORE moving the plan directory — see manage-status:_cmd_lifecycle.py cmd_archive. A separate manage-status transition --completed 6-finalize call MUST NOT be issued from this phase; it would fail with file_not_found because archive has already invalidated the live path.
This step ALWAYS runs — it is NOT configurable via the steps list. It is the terminal action of the phase, invoked after default:archive-plan returns in Step 3.
Load the renderer specification:
Skill: plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize
Standards: standards/output-template.md
Inputs (both already in model context from Step 3):
default:archive-plan dispatched. Contains phase_steps map, deliverables list, configured steps list, repository branch/porcelain, PR state/number, and the solution outline Summary text captured via manage-solution-outline read --section summary.archive_path — returned by default:archive-plan in Step 3.Procedure: Follow the emission procedure in standards/output-template.md#emission-procedure. The renderer is a pure assembler:
MERGED / OPEN / LOOP_BACK / SKIPPED / FAILED) via the precedence chain.Goal header, blank line, Summary text wrapped to ~78 chars with 2-space indent; defensive (no summary recorded) fallback when Summary is None or empty).display_detail). When the Phase Breakdown override is active (see standards/output-template.md § ## Phase Breakdown Override), the per-step iteration substitutes the record-metrics row with the literal Phase Breakdown header + blank line + verbatim phase_breakdown_override_content. Every other step row emits unchanged.No additional script calls are needed for this step — the renderer consumes only the in-memory snapshot plus archive_path. It performs no manage-status / manage-solution-outline / ci pr view reads of its own.
The emitted template is a user-facing text block printed to the model's output, not a log entry. It is the primary surface reported to the user at the end of the finalize phase.
Final metrics are already recorded inside the Step 3 pipeline by default:record-metrics (which runs immediately before default:archive-plan). This step only logs phase completion to work.log.
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level INFO --message "[STATUS] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) Plan completed: {steps_count} steps executed"
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
separator --plan-id {plan_id} --type work
Note: manage-logging operates on log files, not the plan directory, so these calls remain valid after default:archive-plan has moved the plan state.
Success (user-facing):
The primary output is the five-block template rendered by Step 4. It is a plain-text, user-facing block — not TOON — assembled from the pre-archive snapshot plus archive_path. See standards/output-template.md for the full renderer specification.
Example:
[MERGED] PR #212 -- 5 deliverable(s) shipped, all green
Goal
Enrich the phase-6-finalize output with a terminal-rendered three-block
template so the user sees a single at-a-glance summary of the plan's
outcome, deliverables, and finalize-step results.
Deliverables (5/5)
[OK] 1. Extend manage-status mark-step-done with --display-detail
[OK] 2. Create standards/output-template.md
[OK] 3. Wire renderer into phase-6-finalize/SKILL.md
[OK] 4. Simplify standards/record-metrics.md
[OK] 5. Add display_detail to 9 step standards docs
Finalize steps (10/10 done)
[OK] commit-push -> a1b2c3d
[OK] create-pr #212
[OK] automated-review 3 comment(s) resolved (no loop-back)
[OK] sonar-roundtrip quality gate passed
[OK] lessons-capture no lessons recorded
[OK] validation all required steps done
[OK] record-metrics 1591s / 209327 tokens
[OK] branch-cleanup main pulled, branch deleted (local+remote), worktree removed
[OK] archive-plan -> .plan/archived-plans/2026-04-17-lesson-2026-04-17-005
Repository: main up-to-date | worktree removed | working tree clean
Success (machine-facing minimal TOON — retained for callers that parse phase output):
status: success
plan_id: {plan_id}
archive_path: .plan/archived-plans/{date}-{plan_id}
next_state: complete
Loop Back (PR issues found, iteration < 3):
status: loop_back
plan_id: {plan_id}
iteration: {current_iteration}
reason: {ci_failure|review_comments|sonar_issues}
next_phase: 5-execute
fix_tasks_created: {count}
Error:
status: error
plan_id: {plan_id}
step: {commit|push|pr|automated_review|sonar}
message: {error_description}
recovery: {recovery_suggestion}
On any error, first log the error to work-log:
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:manage-logging:manage-logging \
work --plan-id {plan_id} --level ERROR --message "[ERROR] (plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize) {step} failed - {error_type}: {error_context}"
See standards/validation.md for specific error scenarios and recovery actions.
Step activation is determined by presence in manifest.phase_6.steps — absent steps are NEVER executed under any circumstance.
The Step 3 dispatch loop is fully resumable across re-entries: each step's status.metadata.phase_steps["6-finalize"][step_id].outcome drives the per-step decision on a fresh phase-6-finalize invocation:
| Outcome on re-entry | Action |
|---|---|
done | Skip dispatch entirely. The step ran successfully on a previous invocation; do not re-execute. |
failed | Retry from scratch. The previous run produced a failed record (typically a timeout or step-internal abort); the new invocation gets exactly one fresh attempt. |
loop_back | Re-fire (treat as no record — dispatch as fresh run). The previous run recorded a deliberate loop-back iteration and signalled that the dispatcher should re-execute the step on next phase entry. |
| (no record) | Dispatch as a first-time run. |
| any other value | Dispatch as a first-time run (treat as a degraded record). |
Special case — pre-push-quality-gate: this step's resumable check is augmented with a worktree-HEAD comparison so a loop-back commit re-fires the gate instead of skipping it on a stale done. The augmented rule applies ONLY when step_id == "pre-push-quality-gate"; every other step uses the general table above verbatim.
| Outcome on re-entry | head_at_completion vs live HEAD | Action |
|---|---|---|
done | matches live git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse HEAD | Skip dispatch entirely (steady-state — gate already validated this exact tree). |
done | differs from live HEAD | Re-fire (treat as no record — HEAD has advanced past the validated SHA, e.g., after a loop-back commit). |
done | head_at_completion field absent | Re-fire (record is incomplete without a SHA; safe default is to re-run). |
failed | n/a | Retry from scratch (unchanged). |
| (no record) | n/a | Dispatch as a first-time run (unchanged). |
| any other value | n/a | Dispatch as a first-time run (unchanged). |
The live HEAD MUST be resolved fresh per iteration via git -C {worktree_path} rev-parse HEAD — do NOT cache across the loop, so a step that advances HEAD mid-loop is observed correctly by every later check. Cross-reference: standards/pre-push-quality-gate.md "Mark Step Complete" Branch A, which persists head_at_completion on the success path.
This makes finalize safe to interrupt and re-enter — completed work is preserved, failed work gets a retry, never-run work runs for the first time, and the HEAD-dependent quality gate re-fires whenever the tree it validated has been superseded. There is no separate "resume" mode; every Phase 6 entry is implicitly resumable.
In-step state checks (consulted by individual standards docs after dispatch — these guard idempotent operations, not skip activation):
git status --porcelain — empty → commit-push records "no changes" and marks done.ci pr view — status: success → create-pr re-uses the existing PR.manage-status read — current_phase: complete → finalize has nothing to do; return immediately.| Standard | Step Name | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
workflow/pre-submission-self-review.md | default:pre-submission-self-review | Deterministic helper (resolved via ext-self-review-{domain} ext-point) + LLM cognitive review for symmetric-pair / regex-overfit / wording / duplication / contract-drift defects (hard-fail) |
standards/commit-push.md | default:commit-push | Commit strategy, git status, workflow-integration-git delegation |
standards/create-pr.md | default:create-pr | PR existence check, body generation, CI pr create |
workflow/ci-verify.md | default:ci-verify | Classify CI run failures into multi-failure-mode taxonomy and emit one triage finding per failing check |
standards/architecture-refresh.md | default:architecture-refresh | Tier-0 deterministic architecture discover --force + diff-modules --pre driven chore(architecture) commit; Tier-1 LLM re-enrichment with prompt/auto/disabled modes; respects architecture_refresh.tier_0 / tier_1 run-config knobs and change_type ∈ {bug_fix, verification} shortcut |
standards/automated-review.md | default:automated-review | Consume completed-CI signal, then consumer dispatch (FIX / SUPPRESS / ACCEPT / AskUserQuestion); loop-back on FIX or pr-comment-overflow. Architectural flow: findings-pipeline.md |
standards/sonar-roundtrip.md | default:sonar-roundtrip | Sonar consumer dispatch (FIX / SUPPRESS / ACCEPT / AskUserQuestion); loop-back on FIX. Architectural flow: findings-pipeline.md |
standards/lessons-capture.md | default:lessons-capture | manage-lesson add command |
standards/branch-cleanup.md | default:branch-cleanup | Branch cleanup with user confirmation — PR mode (merge + CI) or local-only (switch + pull) |
standards/record-metrics.md | default:record-metrics | Record final plan metrics before archive |
standards/finalize-step-print-phase-breakdown.md | default:finalize-step-print-phase-breakdown | Optional override mode: capture Phase Breakdown table for the renderer (replaces per-step [OK] block) |
standards/archive-plan.md | default:archive-plan | Archive the completed plan |
standards/output-template.md | — | Renderer specification for the five-block final output template (Step 4) |
standards/required-steps.md | — | Canonical list of steps enforced by the phase_steps_complete handshake invariant |
standards/validation.md | — | Configuration requirements, error scenarios |
standards/lessons-integration.md | — | Conceptual guidance on lesson capture |
| Template | Purpose |
|---|---|
templates/pr-template.md | PR body format |
The canonical argparse surface for ci_complete_precondition.py. The plugin-doctor analyzer (_analyze_manage_invocation.py) reads this section as source-of-truth for the manage-invocation-invalid and missing-canonical-block rules. Consuming docs xref this section by name instead of restating the command inline. See pm-plugin-development:plugin-script-architecture cross-skill-integration.md § "Script invocation in documentation".
python3 .plan/execute-script.py plan-marshall:phase-6-finalize:ci_complete_precondition resolve \
--plan-id PLAN_ID --worktree-path WORKTREE_PATH --pr-number PR_NUMBER \
[--timeout TIMEOUT] [--mode {strict,consume-failures}]
| Resource | Purpose |
|---|---|
| references/workflow-overview.md | Visual diagrams: 6-Phase Model and Shipping Pipeline |
plan-marshall:dev-agent-behavior-rules | Bash safety rules, tool usage patterns |
plan-marshall:workflow-integration-git | Commit, push workflow |
plan-marshall:tools-integration-ci | PR operations, CI status |
plan-marshall:workflow-integration-github | CI monitoring, review handling (GitHub) |
plan-marshall:workflow-integration-sonar | Sonar quality gate |
plan-marshall:phase-5-execute | Loop-back target for fix task execution |
plan-marshall:manage-lessons | Lessons capture |
Phase finalization has no "next phase" — it closes the plan. The fused
manage-metrics phase-boundary subcommand therefore does NOT apply at this
boundary. The closing sequence (end-phase 6-finalize → enrich →
generate) lives in standards/record-metrics.md and remains a three-call
sequence by design. The fused phase-boundary call is only used at
inter-phase transitions (1-init → 2-refine … 5-execute → 6-finalize),
recorded by the orchestrator workflows.
Unified plan lifecycle management - create, outline, execute, verify, and finalize plans
Opt-in plan quality audit — analyzes artifacts, logs, metrics, chat, and invariants; compiles report and seeds lessons
Compose, read, and validate the per-plan execution manifest that drives Phase 5 verification and Phase 6 finalize step selection
Domain-agnostic task planning from deliverables with skill resolution and optimization
Two-track solution outline creation - Simple Track for localized changes, Complex Track for codebase-wide discovery
Execute phase skill for plan management. DUMB TASK RUNNER that executes tasks from TASK-*.json files sequentially.