wdad-test-adversary-review

name	wdad-test-adversary-review
description	Use for a skeptical review of the tests after implementation. Looks for shallow coverage, over-mocking, and ways the implementation could still be wrong while tests pass.

Skill: Test-adversary review

Purpose

Find gaps between claimed behavior and actual test evidence.

Mode

Read-only/planning mode.

Required inputs

• wave acceptance checks
• changed tests
• relevant implementation files
• TESTING.md

Procedure

1. Map acceptance checks to concrete evidence.
2. Look for happy-path-only tests.
3. Look for tautological or over-mocked tests.
4. Identify missing regression, integration, or edge-case coverage.
5. Treat acceptance checks moved to follow-up, deferral, non-goal, or out-of-scope language without explicit user signoff as not covered.
6. Recommend the smallest meaningful additions.

Output

• acceptance coverage summary
• weak or shallow tests
• missing tests
• merge readiness from a testing perspective