deck-reviewer

name	deck-reviewer
description	Review image-only research/pitch deck slide images before final PowerPoint assembly.

Deck Reviewer

Use this skill to review generated or edited slide images before final deck assembly. Keep this role separate from infographic_powerpoint_designer so slide QA remains independent.

Expected Inputs

• article.md
• research-resource-index.md
• claim_evidence_ledger.md
• user-approved deck_storyboard.md
• slides_visual_plan.md
• prompts.md
• deck-source-index.md
• slide-generation-log.md
• candidate slide images under slides/

Produced Artifacts

• slide-review-report.md

Use slide-review-report-template.md.

Required Shared Reads

• Read deck-production-principles.md before review when it is present in this agent folder.

Workflow

Step 1 - Confirm the review package

Confirm that the package includes:

• research package
• user-approved deck storyboard
• visual plan
• prompt artifact
• deck source index
• slide generation log
• candidate slide image paths
• resource/input mapping from storyboard through visual plan to image output

If anything needed for review is missing, route Deck Fix to infographic_powerpoint_designer.

Step 2 - Review each slide image

For each slide, inspect the actual image and verify:

• the image is a generate_image or edit_image output
• any visible text, callout, arrow, highlight, crop/resize, overlay, redaction, cleanup, or polish was produced through generate_image or edit_image, not scripts or manual composition
• designer self-check decision exists and is not needs edit, rejected, or blocked
• 16:9 horizontal format
• all must-appear text is present and readable
• no extra words, watermark, random text, or wrong language
• claims match the article, claim evidence ledger, and user-approved deck storyboard
• prompt-grounding resources used for the slide match the storyboard, visual plan, prompt/edit instruction, and deck-source-index.md
• relevant text, file, URL, or source excerpt resources were read before prompt writing when the slide depends on them
• relevant user-provided product/source image assets were used as image inputs when the slide depends on them, or a clear no-image-input rationale is logged
• visual metaphor, chart, diagram, or illustration does not misrepresent the research
• style pack, motif, typography, margins, and visual density are consistent across slides
• slide is readable at presentation distance
• no sensitive or restricted source material is exposed

Treat missing self-check evidence, missing resource/input mapping, unread prompt-grounding resources, unreadable text, wrong text, unsupported claim, unindexed source image, ignored relevant source assets, raw non-generated final slide, script-composed image edits, wrong aspect ratio, or random generated text as blocking.

Step 3 - Write slide-review-report.md

For each slide, record:

• pass, fix required, or reject
• exact issue
• required correction
• whether the issue belongs to deck production or research

Step 4 - Route decision

If blocking issues remain, send Deck Fix to infographic_powerpoint_designer. If the issue is weak evidence or unsupported claims, route Research Gap to deep_researcher.

Repeat the fix/review loop until no blocking issues remain.

Internal review passes when the slide images match the research package and user-approved deck storyboard with no blocking findings.

If the user gives feedback after final deck delivery, classify it:

• slide wording, readability, style, layout, image quality, or deck flow -> Deck Fix to infographic_powerpoint_designer
• claim, evidence, argument, source, or research direction -> Research Gap to deep_researcher

After user-requested fixes change final slide images, review the revised slide package again before final assembly or redelivery.

Step 5 - Handoff reviewed slides

After internal review passes, send the reviewed slide package back to infographic_powerpoint_designer for final images-only PowerPoint assembly.

Include:

• absolute path to slide-review-report.md
• absolute paths to internally reviewed slide images
• review summary
• open non-blocking risks

Routing Rules

• Slide prompt, layout, style, readability, generated-image, or text-fidelity defects -> infographic_powerpoint_designer
• Unsupported claims, weak evidence, or missing source anchors -> deep_researcher