菜单
Apply an optional manual pressure-test outside the formal workflow to ideas, specs, plans, implementation summaries or diffs, architecture choices, product decisions, and workflow proposals. This is separate from the mandatory Skeptic reviewer used inside idea/spec/plan review.
用 Codex 或 Claude 帮你安装 复制这段 Prompt，粘贴到 Codex、Claude 或其他助手里，让它检查 Skill 页面并帮你完成安装。
基于 SOC 职业分类
| name | skeptical-review |
| description | Apply an optional manual pressure-test outside the formal workflow to ideas, specs, plans, implementation summaries or diffs, architecture choices, product decisions, and workflow proposals. This is separate from the mandatory Skeptic reviewer used inside idea/spec/plan review. |
Use this skill to pressure-test an artifact with an intentionally skeptical stance. This skill remains optional and manual; it does not replace the mandatory Skeptic reviewer in normal idea, spec, and plan review phases.
Use for idea artifacts, specs, plans, implementation summaries or diffs, product decisions, architecture choices, and workflow proposals.
Requirements:
Recommendation: kill this approachRecommendation: narrow and retryRecommendation: revise before advancingRecommendation: proceed only if the stated risks are acceptedDraft, revise, or refine the workflow idea artifact as the Product Strategist operator before idea-review. Use when shaping an early product opportunity, turning a rough prompt into `./docs/workflows/{slug}/idea.md`, or updating an existing idea artifact with accepted user or review feedback.
Review an idea artifact using two substantive reviewer subagents plus one skeptic before spec creation. Use when the workflow needs review output in ./docs/workflows/{slug}/reviews/idea/round-01.md.
Draft, revise, or update the implementation-ready engineering plan as the Software Architect operator before plan-review. Use when turning an approved spec into `./docs/workflows/{slug}/plan.md`, updating an existing plan, or incorporating accepted plan-review feedback before implementation.
Review `./docs/workflows/{slug}/plan.md` before implementation using two substantive reviewer subagents plus one skeptic. Use when validating implementation readiness, architecture simplicity, restartability, or whether the workflow can advance to `implement-plan`, and write output to `./docs/workflows/{slug}/reviews/plan/round-XX.md`.
Draft, revise, or update the functional product contract as the Product Manager operator before spec-review. Use when turning an approved idea into `./docs/workflows/{slug}/spec.md`, updating an existing spec, or incorporating accepted spec-review feedback before planning.
Review `./docs/workflows/{slug}/spec.md` using two substantive reviewer subagents plus one skeptic before plan creation. Use when validating the functional product contract, observable acceptance, readiness for `plan-create`, or whether the workflow can advance, and write output to `./docs/workflows/{slug}/reviews/spec/round-XX.md`.