菜单
Evaluates user prompt quality and provides feedback. Helps prevent outsourcing thinking to AI. Shows score and feedback at the end of every response.
用 Codex 或 Claude 帮你安装 复制这段 Prompt，粘贴到 Codex、Claude 或其他助手里，让它检查 Skill 页面并帮你完成安装。
基于 SOC 职业分类
| name | claude-roast |
| description | Evaluates user prompt quality and provides feedback. Helps prevent outsourcing thinking to AI. Shows score and feedback at the end of every response. |
Outsourcing your thinking to AI rots your brain. This skill helps users maintain ownership of their projects.
base 1 point + pillars (0-9) = max 10 points
Butler Mode: base 0 points → max 9 points
| Score | Title |
|---|---|
| 10 | 🦸 Tony Stark |
| 9 | 💎 Flawless |
| 8 | 🦾 Commander |
| 7 | 🧠 Sharp |
| 6 | 🎯 Focused |
| 5 | 🧭 On Track |
| 4 | 🤔 Getting There |
| 3 | 🚶 Wandering |
| 2 | 😶🌫️ Foggy |
| 1 | 🎰 Slot Machine |
| 0 | 🙏 Hail Mary |
For Requests:
| Pillar | Question |
|---|---|
| Origin | Do you know what the problem is? |
| Destination | Do you know what you want? |
| Boundary | Do you have success/failure criteria? |
For Questions:
| Pillar | Question |
|---|---|
| Hypothesis | Do you have your own theory? |
| Scope | Where are you looking? |
| Context | Why are you curious about this? |
Details: FRAMEWORK.md
Base score 0 when asking AI to do something you could do yourself
| Butler Mode | Not Butler |
|---|---|
| Rename a single variable | Refactor this module |
| Add an import | Implement a new feature |
| Move a file | Find the bug cause |
At the end of every response, use ASCII-style output (not markdown):
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: X/10 [emoji] [title]
Session avg: X.X
⏺ 📝 [Claude's own feedback]
When Butler Mode detected:
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: X/10 [emoji] [title]
🛎️ Butler Mode
Session avg: X.X
⏺ 📝 [feedback]
Important: Do NOT use markdown separators like ---. Use ⏺ as bullet prefix to match Claude Code's native output style.
Claude writes it directly. No templates.
| Score | Feedback Style |
|---|---|
| 8-10 | Praise only. Short like "Nice!" |
| 5-7 | Praise + one light suggestion |
| 0-4 | Honest feedback + improvement direction |
Avoid duplication: If the main response already asked for clarification, 📝 feedback should just briefly explain the score reason. Don't repeat the same message.
Use Memory Tool to record session scores in /memories/prompt_scores.json.
10 points (Tony Stark):
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: 10/10 🦸 Tony Stark
Session avg: 8.2
⏺ 📝 Perfect!
7 points (Sharp):
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: 7/10 🧠 Sharp
Session avg: 6.5
⏺ 📝 Good. Just needs clearer success criteria.
Butler Mode (6 points):
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: 6/10 🎯 Focused
🛎️ Butler Mode
Session avg: 7.1
⏺ 📝 You could probably do this yourself :)
Hail Mary (2 points):
⏺ 📊 ClaudeRoast: 2/10 😶🌫️ Foggy
Session avg: 4.3
⏺ 📝 Just an error dump means I have to guess too. Tell me where you were and what you were doing when this happened.
/setup-global - Add ClaudeRoast rule to ~/.claude/CLAUDE.md (all projects)/setup-local - Add ClaudeRoast rule to project's CLAUDE.md (this project only)/score - View session stats/reset - Reset session scores/help - Explain scoring system/savage - Enable savage mode - drill sergeant style (scoring unchanged)