revision-matrix-planning

name	revision-matrix-planning
description	Use to convert feedback into a revision matrix, response stance, and action plan.

Revision Matrix Planning

Use this skill when review comments, advisor feedback, or manuscript critique need to become an auditable revision plan.

Allowed Mutation Mode

Artifact mutation for revision matrices and response plans when authorized. Do not edit manuscript text directly; route approved text changes to LaTeX paper authoring.

Artifact Inputs

• Review package or feedback list
• Manuscript root or draft location references
• Claim register
• Source manifest
• Author decisions or constraints

Workflow

1. Normalize each feedback item into issue, location, severity, and requested change.
2. Assign response stance: accept, partially accept, reject with rationale, or needs human decision.
3. Identify affected claims, sources, figures, tables, and manuscript sections.
4. Produce a revision matrix with owner decision points and verification needs.
5. Route approved text edits to LaTeX authoring.

Artifact Outputs

• Revision matrix
• Response plan
• Change-risk notes
• Human decision list

Source Support

When a revision changes a factual claim, tie the planned change to source manifest entries or claim-register support. Flag unsupported new claims before they reach manuscript editing.

Human Checkpoints

The human researcher approves response stance, rejected-review rationale, and any manuscript mutation plan before edits are made.