prp-done

name	prp-done
description	Issue closure gate — verifies PR merged, review artifact exists, verify artifact exists, and Vera QA passed before closing a GitHub issue.
metadata	{"short-description":"Close issue after all gates pass"}

PRP Done — Issue Closure Gate

Input

Issue number and options: $ARGUMENTS

Format: <issue-number> [--repo <owner/repo>] [--skip-vera --reason="..."]

Mission

Verify that all completion gates have passed before closing a GitHub issue. Prevents premature issue closure when a PR was merged but QA or requirements verification was not completed.

The Gates (checked in order):

1. PR merged (linked via Fixes #N or Closes #N in PR body)
2. Multi-agent review artifact exists (.prp-output/reviews/pr-{PR}-agents-review*.md)
3. Verify artifact exists (.prp-output/reviews/pr-{PR}-verify.md)
4. Vera QA pass (comment on issue containing "QA PASSED" or "QA PASSED (with warnings)")

---

Phase 0: Parse Input

0.1 Resolve Issue Number

Extract issue number from $ARGUMENTS. If not provided: STOP — "Issue number required. Usage: /prp-done <issue-number>"

0.2 Parse Flags

SKIP_VERA = false
SKIP_REASON = ""
REPO = "{from --repo flag}"

Flag	Action
--repo <owner/repo>	Set REPO = value
--skip-vera	Set SKIP_VERA = true
--reason="..."	Set SKIP_REASON = value

Validation: If SKIP_VERA = true AND SKIP_REASON is empty → STOP: "--skip-vera requires --reason="""

0.3 Resolve Repo

# Auto-detect if not provided via --repo
REPO=$(gh repo view --json nameWithOwner -q '.nameWithOwner' 2>/dev/null)

If REPO is still empty: STOP — "Cannot determine repo. Use --repo <owner/repo>."

0.4 Fetch Issue

gh issue view {ISSUE_NUMBER} -R {REPO} --json title,body,state,comments

Result	Action
state=CLOSED	WARN: "Issue #{N} is already closed." → display gate status below, EXIT 0.
state=OPEN	Proceed to Phase 1.
Not found	STOP: "Issue #{N} not found in {REPO}."

---

Phase 1: Gate Checks

Gate 1: PR Merged

Find the merged PR linked to this issue:

# Search for merged PRs mentioning this issue number
gh pr list -R {REPO} --search "closes #{ISSUE_NUMBER}" --state merged --json number,title,mergedAt
gh pr list -R {REPO} --search "fixes #{ISSUE_NUMBER}" --state merged --json number,title,mergedAt

If multiple PRs found: use the most recently merged one.

Result	Gate 1
Merged PR found	✅ PASS — set PR_NUMBER
No merged PR	❌ FAIL — "No merged PR found for issue #{N}. Merge a PR with 'Fixes #{N}' in body first."

Set PR_NUMBER from the found PR for subsequent gates.

Gate 2: Review Artifact

Check for multi-agent review artifact in cwd:

ls .prp-output/reviews/pr-${PR_NUMBER}-agents-review*.md 2>/dev/null

Result	Gate 2
File found	✅ PASS
No file	❌ FAIL — "No review artifact for PR #${PR_NUMBER}. Run: /prp-review-agents ${PR_NUMBER}"

Gate 3: Verify Artifact

Check for requirements verification artifact in cwd:

ls .prp-output/reviews/pr-${PR_NUMBER}-verify.md 2>/dev/null

Result	Gate 3
File found	✅ PASS
No file	❌ FAIL — "No verify artifact for PR #${PR_NUMBER}. Run: /prp-verify ${PR_NUMBER} --issue ${ISSUE_NUMBER}"

Gate 4: Vera QA

Skip if SKIP_VERA = true (proceed to 1.5 audit log).

Search issue comments for Vera QA verdict (most recent comment wins):

gh issue view {ISSUE_NUMBER} -R {REPO} --json comments -q '.comments[].body'

Search for QA verdict patterns (case-insensitive):

• Contains QA PASSED (with warnings) → PASS
• Contains QA PASSED → PASS
• Contains QA FAILED → FAIL
• No matching comment → PENDING

Result	Gate 4
"QA PASSED" or "QA PASSED (with warnings)" found (last match)	✅ PASS
"QA FAILED" found (last match)	❌ FAIL — "Vera QA failed. Fix and re-delegate: /prp-qa --delegate=vera --issue #{N}"
No QA comment	⏳ PENDING — "Vera QA not completed. Delegate: /prp-qa --delegate=vera --issue #{N}"

1.5 Skip-Vera Audit Log

If SKIP_VERA = true:

logger -t prp-done "SKIP_VERA issue=\"${ISSUE_NUMBER}\" pr=\"${PR_NUMBER}\" repo=\"${REPO}\" reason=\"${SKIP_REASON}\"" 2>/dev/null || true

Gate 4 status: ⏭️ SKIPPED (audit-logged)

---

Phase 2: Report & Close

2.1 Compile Gate Results

## Done Gate Report: Issue #{N}

| Gate | Check | Status | Detail |
|------|-------|--------|--------|
| Gate 1 | PR merged | {✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL} | PR #{PR_NUMBER} merged on {date} |
| Gate 2 | Review artifact | {✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL} | {filename or "not found"} |
| Gate 3 | Verify artifact | {✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL} | {filename or "not found"} |
| Gate 4 | Vera QA | {✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL / ⏳ PENDING / ⏭️ SKIPPED} | {detail} |

2.2 Evaluate All Gates

Condition	Action
All gates PASS	Close issue → Phase 2.3
Gate 4 SKIPPED + gates 1–3 PASS	Close issue → Phase 2.3 (with skip note)
Any gate FAIL	STOP — report failed gates, do NOT close
Gate 4 PENDING	STOP — "Vera QA not completed. Cannot close until QA passes or use --skip-vera."

2.3 Close Issue (if all gates pass)

Post summary comment then close:

gh issue comment {ISSUE_NUMBER} -R {REPO} --body "## All Gates Passed ✅

{gate table from 2.1}

Closing issue — all completion criteria verified.
{If SKIP_VERA: \"\\n⚠️ Gate 4 (Vera QA) skipped — reason: {SKIP_REASON}\"}

Closed by: /prp-done"

gh issue close {ISSUE_NUMBER} -R {REPO}

---

Output

On success:

DONE GATE REPORT: Issue #{N}

Gate 1 (PR merged):        ✅ PASS — PR #M merged
Gate 2 (Review artifact):  ✅ PASS — pr-M-agents-review.md found
Gate 3 (Verify artifact):  ✅ PASS — pr-M-verify.md found
Gate 4 (Vera QA):          ✅ PASS — QA PASSED comment found

Issue #{N} CLOSED ✅

On failure:

DONE GATE REPORT: Issue #{N}

Gate 1 (PR merged):        ✅ PASS — PR #M merged
Gate 2 (Review artifact):  ✅ PASS
Gate 3 (Verify artifact):  ❌ FAIL — no verify artifact found
Gate 4 (Vera QA):          ⏳ PENDING

BLOCKED: 2 gates failed. Issue NOT closed.

To fix:
  /prp-verify M --issue N
  /prp-qa --delegate=vera --issue N

---

Usage Examples

/prp-done 166
/prp-done 166 --repo gobikom/agent-devops
/prp-done 166 --skip-vera --reason="no UI changes — API-only fix"

---

Edge Cases

Situation	Action
Multiple merged PRs for issue	Use most recently merged one
PR linked via comment (not body)	Still counts — search all PR references
Vera commented FAIL then PASS	Use latest verdict (last matching comment wins)
Verify artifact is PARTIAL verdict	Still passes Gate 3 — artifact existence is the gate, not verdict content
Issue already closed	WARN and exit 0 — display gate status for reference
--skip-vera without audit log available	logger fails silently (

---

Success Criteria

• ISSUE_FOUND: Issue resolved and state checked
• GATE1_CHECKED: Merged PR found or clear failure reported
• GATE2_CHECKED: Review artifact presence verified
• GATE3_CHECKED: Verify artifact presence verified
• GATE4_CHECKED: Vera QA comment searched (or SKIPPED with audit)
• ISSUE_CLOSED: Issue closed when all gates pass
• BYPASS_AUDITED: Any --skip-vera logged to syslog