bio-pathway-wikipathways

name	bio-pathway-wikipathways
description	Tests a gene list (ORA, enrichWP) or a ranked gene vector (GSEA, gseWP) against the WikiPathways community-curated pathway collection with clusterProfiler and rWikiPathways. Covers why a WikiPathways result is a snapshot of a live, monthly-updated database (enrichWP/gseWP/gson_WP silently pull data.wikipathways.org/current/), why reproducibility requires pinning a dated GMT via downloadPathwayArchive(date=, format='gmt'), why the WP GMT is Entrez-keyed so symbols and Ensembl silently overlap nothing, why universe=NULL gives a biased all-WP-genes background, how to split the name%version%wpid%org term, and why WikiPathways (CC0, no peer review) complements KEGG/Reactome. Use when running open community-pathway enrichment, covering a non-model WP species, catching disease/drug pathways missing from KEGG/Reactome, or needing a reproducible dated analysis. The gene list comes from differential-expression/de-results; visualize with enrichment-visualization.
tool_type	r
primary_tool	rWikiPathways

Version Compatibility

Reference examples tested with: clusterProfiler 4.18+, rWikiPathways 1.26+, org.Hs.eg.db 3.18+.

Before using code patterns, verify installed versions match. If versions differ:

• R: packageVersion('<pkg>') then ?function_name to verify parameters

If code throws ImportError, AttributeError, or TypeError, introspect the installed package and adapt the example to match the actual API rather than retrying.

WikiPathways is a LIVE, monthly-updated database. enrichWP, gseWP, and gson_WP all download data.wikipathways.org/current/gmt/ at run time, so the SAME code returns DIFFERENT pathways and p-values months apart with no error. current/ is not a version. For a reproducible analysis pin a dated release with downloadPathwayArchive(date='YYYYMMDD', organism=, format='gmt') and report the date. All enrichWP/gseWP/downloadPathwayArchive calls require internet at run time.

WikiPathways Enrichment

"Which community-curated WikiPathways are enriched in my genes?" -> Test WikiPathways gene sets against a gene list (ORA) or a ranked vector (GSEA), pinning a dated GMT for reproducibility - because the live monthly database changes under identical code, and the WP GMT is Entrez-keyed so any other ID type silently overlaps nothing.

• R (ORA): enrichWP(entrez, organism='Homo sapiens', universe=all_entrez)
• R (GSEA): gseWP(named_decreasing_entrez_vector, organism='Homo sapiens')
• R (reproducible): downloadPathwayArchive(date='YYYYMMDD', organism=, format='gmt') -> read.gmt -> split term -> enricher/GSEA

Scope: WikiPathways-specific enrichment - the data model, the current/-vs-dated GMT reproducibility pin, the Entrez-GMT requirement, the term-field split, PFOCR as a noisier complement, and the WP-vs-KEGG-vs-Reactome contrast. The ORA/GSEA method choice and hypergeometric/background theory -> the category README. The DE list and ranking statistic -> differential-expression/de-results. KEGG and Reactome -> kegg-pathways, reactome-pathways. Plot grammar -> enrichment-visualization.

The Single Most Important Modern Insight -- A WikiPathways Result Is a Snapshot of a Live, Community-Edited Database Taken on the Run Date

WikiPathways is a wiki: anyone can create or edit a pathway, content is CC0, and there is NO formal journal-style peer review gating a pathway's publication (Pico 2008 PLoS Biol 6:e184; Martens 2021 NAR 49:D613). The collection is republished as a dated GMT archive every MONTH. Three properties every misuse forgets:

1. current/ is not a version. enrichWP, gseWP, and gson_WP all silently download data.wikipathways.org/current/gmt/ - the latest monthly release. Identical code two months apart returns different pathways and different p-values, with no error and no warning. Reproducibility is NOT a code freeze; it is a dated GMT: downloadPathwayArchive(date='20240310', organism='Homo sapiens', format='gmt'), read it, run enricher/GSEA on the pinned sets, and report the date in methods. gson_WP() freezes only within a session (it snapshots current/), not across time.

2. The WP GMT speaks Entrez, and the wrong ID type fails silently. The GMT is Entrez-keyed via BridgeDb. Passing SYMBOL or ENSEMBL yields near-zero overlap and an empty or misleading result with NO error - convert to Entrez upstream (bitr/OrgDb) before enrichWP. Likewise universe=NULL makes the background "all genes that happen to be in WP" - a small, biased set that inflates significance; pass the assayed/tested Entrez vector as universe.

3. A community pathway is a hypothesis someone drew, not a reviewed fact. The two things that make WP valuable (open CC0 license, anyone-can-edit curation that captures disease/drug pathways KEGG and Reactome lack, e.g. the COVID-19 Disease Map) are the same two things that make its quality heterogeneous. Many WP pathways are also imported from KEGG/Reactome, so "three databases agree" can be circular rather than independent. Treat each hit as a community claim - check getPathwayInfo(WPID) last-edit/curation before leaning on a single WP pathway for a key conclusion - and run WP as a COMPLEMENT to KEGG/Reactome, never a sole peer-reviewed source.

Tool Taxonomy

Source / function	Citation	Mechanism / role	When
WikiPathways ORA (enrichWP)	Pico 2008 PLoS Biol 6:e184; Martens 2021 NAR 49:D613; Wu 2021 Innovation 2:100141	hypergeometric test vs the WP GMT (delegates to enricher); downloads current/	a thresholded gene LIST against community pathways
WikiPathways GSEA (gseWP)	Agrawal 2024 NAR 52:D679; Wu 2021 Innovation 2:100141	running-sum FCS over a ranked vector (delegates to GSEA); downloads current/	all genes ranked, no arbitrary cutoff
rWikiPathways (query/download)	Slenter/Hanspers/Pico, Bioconductor	API client: listOrganisms, listPathways, getPathwayInfo, getXrefList, findPathwaysByText, downloadPathwayArchive	inspect pathways, fetch genes, pin a dated GMT
Dated GMT + enricher/GSEA	Wu 2021 Innovation 2:100141	run enrichment on a pinned, parsed GMT, bypassing auto-download	the REPRODUCIBLE pattern; report the date
PFOCR (Pathway Figure OCR)	Hanspers 2020 Genome Biol 21:273; Shin 2023 BMC Genomics 24:713	machine-OCR'd gene sets from published figures; larger + noisier, no edges	high-recall disease/process coverage as a complement; NOT what enrichWP queries
KEGG / Reactome (siblings)	-> kegg-pathways, reactome-pathways	metabolic/signaling maps (live) / curated reactions (local)	the primary databases WP complements

Decision Tree by Scenario

Scenario	Recommended	Why
Quick exploratory ORA, reproducibility not yet needed	enrichWP(entrez, organism, universe=all_entrez)	fastest path; log that it used the current/ release
Publication / reproducible analysis	downloadPathwayArchive(date='YYYYMMDD', organism, format='gmt') -> read -> split -> enricher/GSEA	the dated GMT is the only cross-time pin; report the date
All genes carry a DE statistic, cutoff would be arbitrary	gseWP (see the category README for the ORA/GSEA choice)	ranked FCS uses the full list, no cutoff
Pre-selected list (module, screen hits, GWAS loci)	enrichWP ORA	no ranking available
Disease / drug pathways missing from KEGG/Reactome	WP as a complement, run alongside KEGG/Reactome	community content is genuinely additive where it exists
Maximum gene/process coverage, noise tolerable	PFOCR (separate resource), not enrichWP	figure-OCR sets are higher-recall, lower-precision
Non-model but WP-supported species (zebrafish, fly, worm, Arabidopsis)	enrichWP(entrez, '<scientific name>'), verify via get_wp_organisms()	WP covers ~30+ species
Compare up- vs down-regulated	compareCluster(geneClusters=list(up=..,down=..), fun='enrichWP', organism=)	one model, faceted dotplot
Genes are SYMBOL/ENSEMBL	convert to Entrez first (bitr)	the WP GMT is Entrez-keyed; other types overlap nothing

Over-Representation Analysis (enrichWP)

Goal: Find WikiPathways over-represented in a thresholded gene list, against a defensible background.

Approach: Convert significant genes to Entrez, pass the tested-gene set as universe, run enrichWP, then make the result readable. enrichWP downloads the current/ GMT - acceptable for exploration, but pin a date for anything reportable.

library(clusterProfiler)
library(org.Hs.eg.db)

# enrichWP downloads the current/ WP GMT over the network; symbols/Ensembl must be Entrez first
sig <- bitr(sig_symbols, fromType='SYMBOL', toType='ENTREZID', OrgDb=org.Hs.eg.db)$ENTREZID
all_entrez <- bitr(tested_symbols, fromType='SYMBOL', toType='ENTREZID', OrgDb=org.Hs.eg.db)$ENTREZID

wp <- enrichWP(gene=sig, organism='Homo sapiens', universe=all_entrez,
               pvalueCutoff=0.05, pAdjustMethod='BH', minGSSize=10, maxGSSize=500, qvalueCutoff=0.2)
wp <- setReadablewp OrgDborg.Hs.eg.db keyType   
as.data.framewp   

GSEA (gseWP)

Goal: Find WikiPathways whose genes shift coordinately across the full ranking, with no cutoff.

Approach: Build a NAMED Entrez vector sorted DECREASING by the ranking metric, fix the permutation seed, then run gseWP. There is no universe argument - FCS uses the whole ranked list.

gl <- sort(setNames(de$log2FoldChange, de$entrez), decreasing=TRUE)   # named, decreasing, Entrez names
set.seed(123)                                                          # fix permutation reproducibility
wp_gsea <- gseWP(geneList=gl, organism='Homo sapiens',
                 pvalueCutoff=0.05, pAdjustMethod='BH', minGSSize=10, maxGSSize=500)
as.data.frame(wp_gsea)   # NES, p.adjust, core_enrichment (the leading edge)

Reproducible Analysis with a Dated GMT (the correct pattern)

Goal: Make a WP analysis reproducible across re-runs by pinning a dated release instead of pulling current/.

Approach: Download a dated GMT (pass format='gmt' - the default is gpml), split the compound name%version%wpid%org term field into TERM2GENE/TERM2NAME, run enricher/GSEA on the pinned sets, and report the date in methods.

library(rWikiPathways)
library(tidyr)

# downloadPathwayArchive needs an organism to actually download a file (organism=NULL opens the index)
gmt <- downloadPathwayArchive(date='20240310', organism='Homo sapiens', format='gmt', destpath=tempdir())
wp2gene <- read.gmt(file.path(tempdir(), gmt))
wp2gene <- separate(wp2gene, term, c('name','version','wpid','org'), sep='%')   # term is a %-joined compound
t2g <- wp2gene[, c('wpid','gene')   
t2n  wp2gene    

wp_pinned  enrichersig universeall_entrez TERM2GENEt2g TERM2NAMEt2n   

gson_WP(organism) returns a GSON snapshot object, but it still pulls current/ - it freezes a session, NOT a chosen historical date. Only the dated downloadPathwayArchive GMT survives a re-run months later.

Query the Database Directly (rWikiPathways)

library(rWikiPathways)

listOrganisms()                          # supported species (full scientific names; ~30+)
listPathways('Homo sapiens')             # all WPIDs + names for a species
getPathwayInfo('WP554')                  # metadata incl. last-edit; check before trusting a single hit
getXrefList('WP554', 'L')                # genes by BridgeDb system code: 'L'=Entrez, 'H'=HGNC, 'En'=Ensembl
findPathwaysByText('cancer')             # text search (searchPathways() is NOT a current function)

Other Organisms

wp_mouse <- enrichWP(gene=mouse_entrez, organism='Mus musculus')
wp_zfish <- enrichWP(gene=zfish_entrez, organism='Danio rerio')
# verify the exact organism string before running:
get_wp_organisms()                       # plural accessor; the string must match exactly

Per-Method Failure Modes

Unpinned current/ release

Trigger: running enrichWP/gseWP/gson_WP without downloadPathwayArchive(date=). Mechanism: all three download data.wikipathways.org/current/, the latest monthly release. Symptom: the same script returns different pathways/p-values months apart, with no error. Fix: pin a dated GMT, run enricher/GSEA on it, and report the date.

Symbols or Ensembl into an Entrez GMT

Trigger: passing SYMBOL/ENSEMBL IDs to enrichWP/gseWP. Mechanism: the WP GMT is Entrez-keyed via BridgeDb, so non-Entrez IDs overlap nothing. Symptom: an empty or near-empty result, NO error. Fix: bitr to ENTREZID first; confirm the conversion rate before trusting the result.

Default universe inflates significance

Trigger: universe=NULL (the default). Mechanism: enricher then uses "all genes in the WP GMT" as background - a small, biased set, not the assayed genes. Symptom: implausibly strong p-values for tissue-specific or off-target pathways. Fix: pass the tested-gene Entrez vector as universe.

gson_WP mistaken for a reproducibility pin

Trigger: treating gson_WP() as "the snapshot" for a reproducible analysis. Mechanism: it snapshots current/ into an object - it freezes a session, not a historical date. Symptom: a re-run months later gives a different snapshot. Fix: use the dated downloadPathwayArchive GMT for cross-time reproducibility.

Unsplit GMT term field

Trigger: read.gmt on a WP GMT without splitting the term. Mechanism: the set-name field is a compound name%version%wpid%org joined by %. Symptom: WPIDs and clean names are buried in one column; TERM2GENE/TERM2NAME are wrong. Fix: separate(., term, c('name','version','wpid','org'), sep='%') (or use read.gmt.wp).

searchPathways() is gone

Trigger: calling searchPathways('cancer', 'Homo sapiens'). Mechanism: it is not a current rWikiPathways function. Symptom: an error. Fix: findPathwaysByText() / findPathwayIdsByText().

format defaults to gpml

Trigger: downloadPathwayArchive(date=, organism=) without format='gmt'. Mechanism: format defaults to gpml, which read.gmt cannot read. Symptom: a GPML file or a parse error. Fix: pass format='gmt'.

Quantitative Thresholds

Threshold	Source	Rationale
pvalueCutoff=0.05	enricher/GSEA default	filters on p.adjust (BH) by default; standard FDR gate
qvalueCutoff=0.2	clusterProfiler enricher default	secondary q-value gate on ORA
pAdjustMethod='BH'	clusterProfiler default	Benjamini-Hochberg FDR; not Bonferroni (too conservative for gene-set screens)
minGSSize=10	enricher/GSEA default	drop tiny WP pathways that overfit; many WP specialist sets fall below this and are never tested
maxGSSize=500	enricher/GSEA default	drop overly broad sets that always "enrich"
set.seed(123) for gseWP	reproducibility convention	permutation p-values drift across runs without a fixed seed (any fixed seed works)
Pin date='YYYYMMDD'	Martens 2021 NAR 49:D613	WP republishes monthly; current/ is not a version, so report the dated release

Common Errors

Error / symptom	Cause	Solution
enrichWP returns 0 terms	passed SYMBOL/ENSEMBL not Entrez	bitr to ENTREZID first
Implausibly significant pathways	universe=NULL (all-WP-genes background)	pass the tested-gene Entrez vector as universe
Different results each run	unpinned current/ release	downloadPathwayArchive(date=, format='gmt'); report the date
searchPathways error	function removed	use findPathwaysByText()
read.gmt term column is a %-compound	term field not split	separate(., term, c('name','version','wpid','org'), sep='%')
downloadPathwayArchive opens a browser / downloads nothing	organism=NULL	name the organism to actually download a file
GPML where a GMT was expected	format defaulted to gpml	pass format='gmt'
gseWP error about vector names	geneList not named or not sorted decreasing	build a named Entrez vector, sort(decreasing=TRUE)

References

• Pico AR, Kelder T, van Iersel MP, Hanspers K, Conklin BR, Evelo C. 2008. WikiPathways: pathway editing for the people. PLoS Biol 6(7):e184.
• Martens M, Ammar A, Riutta A, et al. 2021. WikiPathways: connecting communities. Nucleic Acids Res 49(D1):D613-D621.
• Agrawal A, Balci H, Hanspers K, et al. 2024. WikiPathways 2024: next generation pathway database. Nucleic Acids Res 52(D1):D679-D689.
• Hanspers K, Riutta A, Summer-Kutmon M, Pico AR. 2020. Pathway information extracted from 25 years of pathway figures. Genome Biol 21:273.
• Shin MG, Pico AR. 2023. Using published pathway figures in enrichment analysis and machine learning. BMC Genomics 24:713.
• Wu T, Hu E, Xu S, et al. 2021. clusterProfiler 4.0: A universal enrichment tool for interpreting omics data. The Innovation 2(3):100141.

Related Skills

• go-enrichment - GO over-representation alternative
• gsea - Ranked-list GSEA mechanics and the ranking metric
• kegg-pathways - KEGG pathway/module enrichment (the primary DB WP complements)
• reactome-pathways - Reactome curated-pathway enrichment (the primary DB WP complements)
• enrichment-visualization - Dot/bar/cnet/emap/GSEA plots of the enrichment result
• differential-expression/de-results - Source of the gene list and the ranking statistic
• workflows/expression-to-pathways - End-to-end DE-to-enrichment pipeline