harness-report

name	harness-report
description	Tag a friction encountered during real work. Activate the moment any recognition signal fires (user pushback, second-time tool surprise, sibling-skill workaround, etc.). The single canonical implementation of the friction-tagging protocol — all other skills point here.
license	Apache-2.0
allowed-tools	["Read"]
user-invocable	true
metadata	{"provenance":{"canonical":"https://github.com/hcross/crewrig","feedback":"https://github.com/hcross/crewrig","version":"1.2.0"}}

Harness Report

The skill every other skill invokes when a friction signal fires. The protocol contract (payload schema, wing routing, fixed categories, what NOT to tag) lives in config/TOOLS.md → Friction Reporting. This skill is the operational counterpart: how to recognise a signal, how to fill the payload correctly, and especially how to attribute the friction to the right offender even when you are not currently operating under that offender's skill.

When to activate

The moment any recognition signal fires. Listed in canonical form in config/TOOLS.md → Friction Reporting → Recognition signals; the short reminder list:

• User pushback — the user contests, corrects, or reverts the action you just took, or reformulates the same intent because your previous response was misaligned.
• Sibling-skill workaround — you find yourself contorting around a constraint set by another skill or agent, not the user's request.
• Tool surprise (second time) — a tool produced surprising or inconsistent behaviour for the second time in the same session. First time is bad luck; second time is a pattern.
• Process gap — a documented workflow step turned out to be missing, ambiguous, contradictory, or out of date.
• Safeguard friction — a rule or guard blocked a legitimate action and forced a workaround you had to explain explicitly to the user.

If a signal fires, tag the friction before resuming work. Not "consider tagging". Not "when convenient". Tagging takes seconds and costs nothing; failing to tag loses the signal forever.

Operating mode

1. Pause and identify the offender

The trickiest part of friction reporting is getting the attribution right. You are likely operating under some skill X when the friction manifests, but the offender might be:

• Skill X itself (its prompt led you astray).
• A different skill or agent you read earlier in the session.
• A document (AGENTS.md, a config/*.md file).
• A tool (gh, jq, yq, an MCP server).
• A process step in config/TOOLS.md or similar.

Before composing the payload, ask yourself: what specifically led to the contested action? Trace the chain backwards from the action to its closest source. That source is the offender, and its URL or path belongs in canonical: — never the path to this harness-report skill, which is just the orchestrator.

If you genuinely cannot pinpoint the offender, leave canonical: empty and let evidence: carry the trail. A routing failure (caught by the Curator at consumption time) is better than a wrong-target MR.

2. Pick the room

One of the 5 fixed categories per config/TOOLS.md:

• tool — an MCP tool, CLI, or script behaved unexpectedly.
• prompt — a skill/agent prompt was misleading or led you astray.
• format — an output format broke parsing or mixed concerns.
• behavior — an agent did something it should not have, or skipped something it should have done.
• process — a documented workflow step is missing or out of date.

When in doubt between prompt and behavior: ask whether the prompt told you to do the wrong thing (→ prompt) or whether you went off the prompt's rails on your own (→ behavior).

3. Fill the payload

Mandatory fields (the script will skip the drawer if either is missing or empty):

• writer_agent — your own identifier (claude-code, gemini-cli, …). Non-empty.
• ≥1 evidence: entry — at minimum a file path with line number; a commit hash + path + line is better (the file may move but the commit is permanent).

Strongly encouraged:

• subcategory — a free-form clustering anchor. Frictions sharing a subcategory get bundled into the same MR by the Curator.
• canonical — the canonical repo URL of the offending component's home, in the GitHub https://github.com/<owner>/<repo> form (as set in the component's provenance.canonical block at build time). NOT a file URL: the Curator's apply step routes the issue via gh issue create --repo <owner>/<repo> by stripping the https://github.com/ prefix (see community-config/skills/harness-curator/scripts/apply.py:23-36), so a /blob/<branch>/<path> URL produces a malformed --repo argument and the issue fails to land. Put the file path in evidence: instead.
• severity — low / med / high. Default med. Reserve high for blockers; it bypasses the cluster threshold and forces an MR. See Reactive trigger for severity: high below — high-severity reports SHOULD be surfaced immediately, not deferred to the weekly sweep.
• suggestion — what you think would fix it. The Curator weighs clusters with suggestions higher.

The full schema, including the inline evidence: <single-value> short form, lives in config/TOOLS.md → Payload schema. Do not re-derive it here; refer to it.

4. Tag

One MCP call. Fire and forget — do not wait for an acknowledgement, do not block, return to your task:

mempalace_add_drawer(
  wing="harness-friction",
  room="<one of the 5 categories>",
  content="""
FRICTION: <one-line title>

writer_agent: <you>
subcategory: <optional anchor>
canonical: <URL of offender, if known>
severity: <low|med|high — default med>
evidence:
  - <commit_hash>:<path>:<line>
  - <URL>
suggestion: <optional fix idea>
"""
)

5. Resume

Return to the task that was interrupted by the signal. The friction is now in the wing; the Curator will pick it up on its next run.

Reactive trigger for severity: high

When you file a FRICTION: payload with severity: high, you SHOULD surface it immediately rather than wait for the next scheduled curator sweep. After the mempalace_add_drawer call returns, run:

bash community-config/skills/harness-curator/scripts/curate.sh --apply --dedup --max-issues 5

Dedup is on, so re-running is safe — already-open clusters are skipped. The curator's high-severity bypass (cluster_qualifies in curate.py) promotes the singleton even before a second report arrives. Skip this step for low / med: those wait for the weekly sweep.

Output expectations

• A single mempalace_add_drawer MCP call to wing="harness-friction". Nothing else — no summary to the user, no inline narration. The point of fire-and-forget is to keep the flow.
• If the user explicitly asked you to tag a friction, briefly confirm it landed (one sentence). Otherwise stay silent.

Self-reporting bias

A known weakness: the agent who produced the contested action is the one being asked to tag the friction. Rationalisation is easier than self-correction. To counteract this:

• When in doubt, tag. Over-reporting is curatable; under-reporting is lost forever. Curation cost is cheap relative to the cost of an unflagged systemic friction.
• A user correction is always a recognition signal, even when you privately think "the user just changed their mind". The Curator will downgrade if the cluster proves to be preference rather than defect.

Friction reporting (recursive)

If harness-report itself led to a malformed payload, a wrong attribution, or made you skip a tag that should have happened — tag it like any other friction, with canonical pointing at this skill's own URL. The reporter is not exempt from the loop it serves.