implementation-review

name	Implementation Review
description	Compare implemented work to a plan and report only real completeness, verification, complexity, or regression findings.
requiredSources	["context7"]

Implementation Review

Use this skill after implementation to compare the actual result against an implementation plan.

Goal

Confirm whether the work is complete, correctly verified, and still simple enough to trust.

Process

1. Read the plan as a checklist
   • planned tasks
   • success conditions
   • verification methods
   • explicit non-goals
2. Load only the guidance that scopes the implemented area
3. Map each plan item to the actual code and connected surfaces
4. Use subagents in parallel if helpful:
   • plan coverage reviewer
   • runtime verifier
   • quality reviewer
   • regression reviewer
5. Verify real behavior with the narrowest meaningful checks
6. Review completeness, correctness, verification, consistency, simplicity, ambiguity, and regressions
7. Report only findings backed by direct evidence

Output

Return a findings report only. Start with one verdict:

• complete
• partial
• failed verification

Then list findings in this format:

• Finding: ...
• Why: ...
• Evidence: ...
• Solution: ...

End with a short verification summary.