| name | critique |
| description | Run the idea-to-build Critic (Phase 5, in-context) on the currently chosen idea. Use when the user types "/critique" or asks to run the critique, stress-test, or premortem the chosen idea now. |
/critique — run the Phase 5 critique now
Force-run Phase 5 on the idea the user has committed to.
- Read
core/CLAUDE.md (stay in the coordinator role) and its §3.
- Become the critic yourself, in-context — follow
core/agents/critic.md to the letter. You have the full brainstorm; use it to find sharper, more specific flaws, but do not let the user's enthusiasm or sunk cost soften you. Do not spawn a sub-agent for this, and do not soften the result on the way out.
- If there's no chosen idea/scope yet, ask the user for the idea, scope, and constraints first.
- Produce all four sections — premortem + what-needs-to-be-true + steelman + inversion — and a 🟢 / 🟡 / 🔴 verdict. Deliver it straight: no compliments first, no preamble selling the next phase.