agent-tools-patterns

name	agent-tools-patterns
description	Patterns for configuring agent tools correctly
allowed-tools	["Read"]

Agent Tools Configuration Patterns

Core Principle

tools: [] ≠ tools omission

Configuration	Meaning	Use Case
tools field omitted	Inherit ALL tools (including MCP)	Default, MCP-using agents
tools: [] (empty array)	NO tools	Pure reasoning agents only
tools: ["Read", "Grep"]	Specific tools only	Minimum privilege

---

Decision Tree

Does agent need MCP tools (Serena, Playwright, etc.)?
├─ YES → OMIT tools field (inherit all)
└─ NO
    ├─ Needs specific Claude Code tools → tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Bash"]
    ├─ External access only → tools: ["WebSearch", "WebFetch"]
    └─ Pure thinking, no tools → tools: []  # Add comment!

---

Pattern Catalog

Pattern 1: MCP Tool Inheritance (Default)

When: Agent uses Serena MCP, Playwright MCP, or other MCP tools Config: Omit tools field entirely Rationale: MCP tools cannot be listed explicitly; they're inherited

---

name: mcp-executor
description: Executes refactoring via Serena MCP
# tools field intentionally omitted - inherits all including MCP
---

Pattern 2: Read-Only Analysis

When: Agent only analyzes, never modifies Config: tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob"] Rationale: Minimum privilege for safety

Pattern 3: External Access Only

When: Agent fetches from external sources, no file access Config: tools: ["WebSearch", "WebFetch"] or tools: ["Bash"] Rationale: Restrict file system access

Pattern 4: Pure Reasoning (Rare)

When: Agent only generates text, no tool use Config: tools: [] with comment Rationale: Must be explicit and documented

---

name: pure-thinker
description: Generates creative ideas without tool access
tools: []  # Intentional: pure reasoning agent
---

---

Anti-patterns

Anti-pattern	Problem	Fix
tools: [] without comment	Unclear intent	Add comment or remove
tools: [] with MCP description	Agent is broken	Remove tools line
Listing MCP tools explicitly	MCP tools can't be listed	Omit tools field

---

Validation Codes

Code	Meaning	Action
W049	tools: [] but description implies tool usage	Remove tools line
W050	tools: [] without clear intent	Add comment or remove

---

Quick Reference

MCP agent → omit tools
Read-only → tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob"]
External → tools: ["WebSearch", "WebFetch"]
SDK only → tools: ["Bash"]
Thinking → tools: []  # Intentional