| name | 05-review |
| description | Review a diff read-only on three axes, code, behavior versus the plan, and relevancy, into one verdict report. Use before shipping a change. Not for fixing findings or auditing a codebase. |
| argument-hint | diff | plan |
| model | opus |
Skill: review
Read-only review of a diff along three axes, code quality, feature behavior, and relevancy, composed into one report.
Actions
| # | Action | Axis |
|---|
| 01 | review-code | Clean-code quality on the changed lines |
| 02 | review-functional | The diff against the plan's phases and their acceptance criteria |
| 03 | review-relevancy | Does the change belong: fit to the need, rule conformance, no rot |
Run all three by default, composing one report. Run a single axis only when the caller names it; if it is unclear whether they want all or one, ask. Before running an action, read its file in actions/, not only the table or assets.
Transversal rules
- Read-only: surface each finding with its fix described, never patch.
- Output: always write
review.md to disk; the file is the deliverable, never an inline-only verdict.
- Folder: write into the reviewed work's feature folder (
aidd_docs/tasks/<yyyy_mm>/<yyyy_mm_dd>_<slug>/, beside plan.md), or one resolved from the change when it has none.
- Report: fill
review.md from assets/review-template.md. One shared Findings table for every axis: functional writes the Phases boxes and the Verification table, and appends a functional row to Findings for each unmet criterion tagged fix; code and relevancy append rows to Findings under their Kind. Tables and boxes, no prose, no per-axis sections. The Phase column ties a finding to the plan when one is in scope, - otherwise.
- Sections: the report has exactly the sections in
assets/review-validator.yml. Before returning, verify against it and remove any section not listed.
- Not run: every required section always exists. The header
Axes run lists which axes ran, so a skipped code or relevancy axis is visible even though Findings is shared. An axis that did not run marks the sections it owns "Not run" (functional owns Phases and Verification); it never leaves a placeholder or invents data.
- Re-run: overwrite
review.md with the current review. It is a snapshot of the current diff, not a history; a later review of the same work replaces the earlier one.
- Verdict: one overall verdict, the strictest across the axes run, per
references/review-rubric.md.
References
references/review-rubric.md: the severity scale, the verdict rule, the code categories, and the relevancy lenses.
Assets
assets/review-template.md: the single report the three axes fill.assets/review-validator.yml: the closed set of report sections.
