vldt-validate

name	vldt - Validate
description	Systematic validation procedure. Defines criteria, runs checks, flags failures, and makes a pass/fail determination with reasoning.
output	{"format":"prose"}

Validate

Input: $ARGUMENTS

---

Step 1: State What's Being Validated

SUBJECT: [What is being validated — a claim, plan, output, design, code, etc.]
VALIDATION GOAL: [What "valid" means in this context]
STAKES: [What happens if this passes but shouldn't / fails but shouldn't]

---

Step 2: Define Validation Criteria

List every criterion that must be met. Be specific and testable.

CRITERIA:
1. [Criterion] — test: [how to check it]
2. [Criterion] — test: [how to check it]
3. [Criterion] — test: [how to check it]
4. [Criterion] — test: [how to check it]
5. [Criterion] — test: [how to check it]

For each criterion, it must be clear what a pass looks like and what a fail looks like.

---

Step 3: Run Each Check

Execute each validation test.

CHECK RESULTS:

1. [Criterion]: PASS / FAIL
   Evidence: [what was found]

2. [Criterion]: PASS / FAIL
   Evidence: [what was found]

3. [Criterion]: PASS / FAIL
   Evidence: [what was found]

4. [Criterion]: PASS / FAIL
   Evidence: [what was found]

5. [Criterion]: PASS / FAIL
   Evidence: [what was found]

---

Step 4: Flag and Classify Failures

FAILURES FOUND: [count]

CRITICAL FAILURES (must fix — blocks validity):
- [Criterion X]: [why it's critical]

MINOR FAILURES (should fix — doesn't block validity):
- [Criterion Y]: [why it's minor]

WARNINGS (not a failure but worth noting):
- [Observation]: [why it matters]

If there are no failures, state that clearly and move to Step 5.

---

Step 5: Determination

VERDICT: PASS / CONDITIONAL PASS / FAIL

REASONING: [1-3 sentences explaining the determination]

IF CONDITIONAL:
- Must fix before proceeding: [list]
- Can fix later: [list]

IF FAIL:
- Root cause: [the fundamental issue]
- To re-validate after fixing: [what to change and re-test]

---

Step 6: Validation Summary

VALIDATED: [subject]
RESULT: [PASS / CONDITIONAL / FAIL]
CRITICAL ISSUES: [count]
MINOR ISSUES: [count]
CONFIDENCE: [How confident are you in this validation: high/medium/low]
CONFIDENCE CAVEAT: [What could you have missed]

---

Integration

Use with:

• /plsk -> Validate a plan specifically
• /prsk -> Validate a product specifically
• /thnk -> Choose the right validation approach
• /bldk -> Validate at each build stage