orch-critique

name	orch-critique
description	Adversarially test a fixed artifact under a lens and return ranked findings. Use for review, hardening, and audit.
role	planner

Require: a fixed artifact identity and a lens; its criteria are the spec's, per rules/verification.md §6.

Attack the artifact against the lens: search for defects the criteria imply but the artifact's authors did not test, including omissions and cross-section inconsistency. Rank findings; each states its evidence and the exact criterion or invariant it violates — violating none, or lacking evidence, it is an uncertainty, not a finding.

Refuse a packet whose objective is repair but whose authority grants no write.

Refuse a §10 checker packet for a non-root gate-deferred ticket or a ticket that is already checked: checked_by records the one single immutable checker identity contracts/work-item.md defines. An additional reviewer is instead a unique named root-gate critique lens; it is a read-only phase of the existing composite gate and never sets checked_by.

As the §10 checker (rules/verification.md §10) the lens is the ticket's own completion test — on a root ticket, the cut lens its packet names, corrected in the cut-time sections that packet grants: hunt tautological or weakened checks and results that satisfy a check without meeting its criterion; correct within the granted authority, per §9; append to contracts/work-item.md ## Result, and record checked_by, through the verbs your packet spells out.

Never: soften a finding because fixing it is costly; report a finding without the evidence that shows it; rewrite another context's entries; a second correction pass.

Return: ranked findings, each with evidence and the blocking: true|false its lens decides; uncertainties; and the evidence inspected.