qa-bug-reporting

name	qa-bug-reporting
description	Bug report format and documentation for failed validations. Use when validation fails and status must be set to needs_fixes.
category	reporting

Bug Reporting Skill

"A good bug report is half the fix – be specific, be reproducible."

When to Use This Skill

Use when validation fails and status must be set to needs_fixes.

Quick Start

## Bug Report: {{TASK_ID}}

**Severity**: Critical / High / Medium / Low
**Found in**: Automated tests / Code review / Console inspection

### Summary

Brief one-line description of the issue.

### Steps to Reproduce

1. Step one
2. Step two
3. Step three

### Expected Behavior

What should happen.

### Actual Behavior

What actually happens.

### Evidence

- Console errors: {{error text}}
- Screenshot: {{path}}

Bug Report Template

# Bug Report: {{TASK_ID}} - {{BRIEF_TITLE}}

**Reported**: {{ISO_TIMESTAMP}}
**Reporter**: QA Agent
**Severity**: {{Critical | High | Medium | Low}}
**Category**: {{Build | TypeScript | Runtime | Visual | Performance}}

---

## Summary

{{One or two sentences describing the issue}}

## Environment

- **OS**: {{Windows / macOS / Linux}}
- **Node Version**: {{v20.x.x}}
- **Context**: {{Development server / Production / Browser console}}

## Steps to Reproduce

1. {{First step}}
2. {{Second step}}
3. {{Third step}}
4. {{...}}

## Expected Behavior

{{What should happen when following the steps}}

## Actual Behavior

{{What actually happens instead}}

## Console Errors

\`\`\`
{{Paste console errors here}}
\`\`\`

## Screenshots

{{Include paths to screenshots or describe what was captured}}

## Additional Context

{{Any other relevant information:

- Related code files
- Recent changes that might have caused this
- Workarounds attempted
- Similar issues seen before}}

## Acceptance Criteria Status

| Criterion       | Status            | Notes     |
| --------------- | ----------------- | --------- |
| {{Criterion 1}} | ✅ Pass / ❌ Fail | {{notes}} |
| {{Criterion 2}} | ✅ Pass / ❌ Fail | {{notes}} |
| {{Criterion 3}} | ✅ Pass / ❌ Fail | {{notes}} |

---

## For Developer

**Files likely involved**:

- {{file1.ts}}
- {{file2.tsx}}

**Suggested investigation**:

- {{Suggestion 1}}
- {{Suggestion 2}}

Severity Levels

Severity	Definition	Example
Critical	App crashes, data loss, blocks all testing	Build fails, app won't load
High	Major feature broken, no workaround	Player controls don't work
Medium	Feature partially works, has workaround	Physics jittery but functional
Low	Minor issue, cosmetic, edge case	Slight visual glitch on resize

Category Types

Category	Description	Automated Check
Build	Build or bundle fails	npm run build
TypeScript	Type errors	npm run type-check
Lint	Code style issues	npm run lint
Test	Unit test failure	npm run test
Runtime	Error during execution	Console inspection
Visual	Incorrect appearance	Visual inspection
Performance	FPS drops, lag, memory	Performance profiling

Anti-Patterns

❌ DON'T:

• Report bugs without reproduction steps
• Use vague descriptions ("it doesn't work")
• Omit error messages
• Skip severity classification
• Blame the developer in the report
• Report code issues without thorough code review - ALWAYS verify actual code flow before concluding there's a bug
• Confuse valid async patterns with "bypasses" - async functions with multiple calls may appear suspicious but can be correct
• Escalate without investigating - trace the code flow from entry point to execution before reporting

✅ DO:

• Include exact steps to reproduce
• Copy full error messages
• Attach screenshots
• Specify environment details
• Suggest where to investigate
• Perform thorough code review before reporting - trace actual code execution flow
• Verify suspected "bypasses" by testing the actual behavior - if you suspect code skips connection, verify by running the app
• Include observed vs. expected behavior - be specific about what you saw that was wrong, not just code that looked suspicious
• Code review BEFORE escalating - read the actual implementation files and understand the flow before filing a bug report

Code Review Before Bug Reporting

CRITICAL: Before reporting a code-related bug, you MUST:

1. Read the actual implementation files - Don't guess what code does based on a quick glance
2. Trace the execution flow - Follow the code from entry point to the suspected issue
3. Verify the actual behavior - Run the app and observe what actually happens
4. Compare expected vs. actual - Be specific about what should happen vs. what does happen

Example: Common Pitfall

A report claimed "code appears to skip connection" but tracing actual flow showed proper initialization:

• initializeConnection PROPERLY calls networkManager.connect() and joinRoom()
• Server logs showed "listening" and client connected successfully
• Root cause was a different issue (CORS configuration, not the suspected code)

Bug Report Message

When reporting a bug, send a bug_report message to PM with full bug details:

{
  "id": "msg-pm-{timestamp}-001",
  "from": "qa",
  "to": "pm",
  "type": "bug_report",
  "priority": "high",
  "payload": {
    "taskId": "{taskId}",
    "bugs": [{
      "file": "src/file.ts",
      "line": 42,
      "issue": "Type error: Type 'string' is not assignable...",
      "severity": "critical",
      "summary": "Build fails with TypeScript error",
      "steps": ["Run npm run build", "Observe error"],
      "expected": "Build succeeds",
      "actual": "TS2322 error"
    }]
  },
  "timestamp": "{ISO_TIMESTAMP}"
}

⚠️ IMPORTANT: QA does NOT update prd.json directly. PM syncs bug information from bug_report message.

Note: Commit format templates for failed validations are in qa-workflow skill.

---

Checklist

Before submitting bug report:

• Code review performed - Read and traced the actual implementation files
• Actual behavior verified - Ran the app and observed what actually happens
• Summary is clear and specific
• Reproduction steps are complete
• Expected vs actual clearly stated
• Console errors included
• Screenshots attached (if visual)
• Severity assigned
• Category assigned
• Environment specified
• bug_report message sent to PM

References

• ../../agents/qa/AGENT.md — Full QA instructions
• ../qa-validation-workflow/SKILL.md — Full workflow