| name | feedback-review |
| description | Aggregate feedback signals across all active loops. Reports health, trajectory, overdue checks, regression warnings, and Goodhart's Law violations. |
| instruction_budget | 55 |
Feedback Review
Single-place health check across all Mycelium feedback loops. Run periodically or when something feels off.
When to Use
- Weekly as part of regular practice
- When metrics aren't moving despite active work
- When the team feels busy but unproductive
- After a failed launch or unexpected regression
- When
/diamond-assess shows stale diamonds
Workflow
1. Check Loop 1 (Immediate) Health
- How many reflexion iterations are averaging? (1 = healthy, 3 = struggling)
- Any corrections logged this session? Are they new patterns or repeats?
- Is the preflight gate catching issues, or are issues slipping through?
2. Check Loop 2 (Incremental) Health
- Are diamond phases progressing? Or stalled?
- Are ICE confidence scores increasing with each GIST step?
- Is the delivery journal being updated? (Empty = no incremental learning)
- Are retrospectives happening after delivery increments?
3. Check Loop 3 (Strategic) Health
Read canvas trend data and check cadence:
- BVSSH: Last assessed when? Any dimension declining? (Check
bvssh-health.yml trend fields)
- North Star: Are input metrics moving? Flat for 2+ months = strategic concern.
- Delivery metrics: Any metric degrading? Check the product-type-appropriate canvas: (software), (content), (ai_tool), (service).
