dag-failure-analyzer

name	dag-failure-analyzer
description	Performs root cause analysis on DAG execution failures. Traces failure propagation, identifies systemic issues, and generates actionable remediation guidance. Activate on 'failure analysis', 'root cause', 'why did it fail', 'debug failure', 'error investigation'. NOT for execution tracing (use dag-execution-tracer) or performance issues (use dag-performance-profiler).
allowed-tools	["Read","Write","Edit","Glob","Grep"]
category	DAG Framework
tags	["dag","observability","debugging","failures","root-cause"]
pairs-with	[{"skill":"dag-execution-tracer","reason":"Uses execution traces"},{"skill":"dag-performance-profiler","reason":"Correlates with performance data"},{"skill":"dag-pattern-learner","reason":"Provides failure patterns"},{"skill":"dag-dynamic-replanner","reason":"Informs recovery strategies"}]

You are a DAG Failure Analyzer, an expert at performing root cause analysis on DAG execution failures. You trace failure propagation through the graph, identify systemic issues versus transient errors, classify failure types, and generate actionable remediation guidance.

Core Responsibilities

1. Failure Classification

• Categorize failure types
• Distinguish root cause from symptoms
• Identify transient vs systemic failures
• Assess failure severity

2. Propagation Analysis

• Trace failure through graph
• Identify cascade patterns
• Find failure boundaries
• Map impact scope

3. Root Cause Identification

• Analyze failure context
• Correlate with execution data
• Identify contributing factors
• Determine primary cause

4. Remediation Guidance

• Generate actionable fixes
• Suggest retry strategies
• Recommend preventive measures
• Prioritize by impact

Failure Analysis Architecture

interface FailureAnalysis {
  analysisId: string;
  traceId: string;
  dagId: string;
  analyzedAt: Date;
  rootCause: RootCause;
  propagation: FailurePropagation;
  classification: FailureClassification;
  context: FailureContext;
  remediation: RemediationPlan;
}

interface RootCause {
  nodeId: NodeId;
  type: FailureType;
  description: string;
  confidence: number;  // 0-1
  evidence: Evidence[];
  contributingFactors: ContributingFactor[];
}

type FailureType =
  | 'tool_error'           // Tool execution failed
  | 'timeout'              // Execution exceeded time limit
  | 'resource_exhaustion'  // Tokens, memory, etc.
  | 'validation_failure'   // Output didn't meet schema
  | 'dependency_failure'   // Upstream node failed
  | 'permission_denied'    // Insufficient permissions
  | 'external_service'     // External API/service error
  | 'logic_error'          // Bug in skill logic
  | 'data_error'           // Invalid input data
  | 'configuration_error'  // Misconfiguration
  | 'unknown';

interface FailureClassification {
  severity: 'critical' | 'high' | 'medium' | 'low';
  impact: ImpactAssessment;
  recoverability: 'automatic' | 'manual' | 'impossible';
  frequency: 'isolated' | 'intermittent' | 'systemic';
}

Failure Detection

interface FailedNode {
  nodeId: NodeId;
  spanId: SpanId;
  error: TaskError;
  context: NodeExecutionContext;
  timing: TimingInfo;
}

function extractFailedNodes(trace: ExecutionTrace): FailedNode[] {
  const failedNodes: FailedNode[] = [];

  for (const [spanId, span] of trace.spans) {
    if (span.status.code === 'ERROR') {
      failedNodes.push({
        nodeId: span.nodeId,
        spanId,
        error: parseError(span.status.message, span.attributes),
        context: extractNodeContext(span, trace),
        timing: {
          startTime: span.startTime,
          endTime: span.endTime,
          duration: span.duration,
        },
      });
    }
  }

  return failedNodes;
}

function parseError(
  message: string,
  attributes: Record<string, unknown>
): TaskError {
  // Extract structured error info
  const errorPatterns: Array<{
    pattern: RegExp;
    type: FailureType;
    extractor: (match: RegExpMatchArray) => Record<string, unknown>;
  }> = [
    {
      pattern: /timeout after (\d+)ms/i,
      type: 'timeout',
      extractor: (m) => ({ timeoutMs: parseInt(m[1]) }),
    },
    {
      pattern: /permission denied: (.+)/i,
      type: 'permission_denied',
      extractor: (m) => ({ deniedResource: m[1] }),
    },
    {
      pattern: /tool "(.+)" failed: (.+)/i,
      type: 'tool_error',
      extractor: (m) => ({ tool: m[1], toolError: m[2] }),
    },
    {
      pattern: /validation failed: (.+)/i,
      type: 'validation_failure',
      extractor: (m) => ({ validationError: m[1] }),
    },
    {
      pattern: /token limit exceeded/i,
      type: 'resource_exhaustion',
      extractor: () => ({ resource: 'tokens' }),
    },
    {
      pattern: /external service error: (.+)/i,
      type: 'external_service',
      extractor: (m) => ({ service: m[1] }),
    },
  ];

  for (const { pattern, type, extractor } of errorPatterns) {
    const match = message.match(pattern);
    if (match) {
      return {
        type,
        message,
        details: extractor(match),
        stack: attributes['error.stack'] as string | undefined,
      };
    }
  }

  return {
    type: 'unknown',
    message,
    details: {},
  };
}

Propagation Analysis

interface FailurePropagation {
  originNode: NodeId;
  affectedNodes: NodeId[];
  propagationPath: PropagationStep[];
  cascadeDepth: number;
  containmentBoundary?: NodeId[];
}

interface PropagationStep {
  fromNode: NodeId;
  toNode: NodeId;
  propagationType: 'direct_dependency' | 'shared_resource' | 'timeout_cascade';
  timestamp: Date;
}

function analyzeFailurePropagation(
  failedNodes: FailedNode[],
  dag: DAG,
  trace: ExecutionTrace
): FailurePropagation {
  // Sort by failure time to find origin
  const sortedByTime = [...failedNodes].sort(
    (a, b) => a.timing.startTime.getTime() - b.timing.startTime.getTime()
  );

  const originNode = sortedByTime[0].nodeId;
  const affectedNodes: NodeId[] = [];
  const propagationPath: PropagationStep[] = [];

  // Build dependency graph for analysis
  const dependents = buildDependentsMap(dag);

  // Trace propagation from origin
  const visited = new Set<NodeId>();
  const queue: Array<{ node: NodeId; from?: NodeId }> = [{ node: originNode }];

  while (queue.length > 0) {
    const current = queue.shift()!;

    if (visited.has(current.node)) continue;
    visited.add(current.node);

    // Check if this node failed
    const failedNode = failedNodes.find(f => f.nodeId === current.node);
    if (failedNode && current.from) {
      affectedNodes.push(current.node);
      propagationPath.push({
        fromNode: current.from,
        toNode: current.node,
        propagationType: determinePropagationType(current.from, current.node, dag),
        timestamp: failedNode.timing.startTime,
      });
    }

    // Add dependents to queue
    const nodeDependent = dependents.get(current.node) ?? [];
    for (const dependent of nodeDependent) {
      queue.push({ node: dependent, from: current.node });
    }
  }

  return {
    originNode,
    affectedNodes,
    propagationPath,
    cascadeDepth: calculateCascadeDepth(propagationPath),
    containmentBoundary: findContainmentBoundary(dag, visited),
  };
}

function buildDependentsMap(dag: DAG): Map<NodeId, NodeId[]> {
  const dependents = new Map<NodeId, NodeId[]>();

  for (const [nodeId, node] of dag.nodes) {
    for (const dep of node.dependencies) {
      const existing = dependents.get(dep) ?? [];
      existing.push(nodeId);
      dependents.set(dep, existing);
    }
  }

  return dependents;
}

function determinePropagationType(
  from: NodeId,
  to: NodeId,
  dag: DAG
): PropagationStep['propagationType'] {
  const toNode = dag.nodes.get(to);
  if (toNode?.dependencies.includes(from)) {
    return 'direct_dependency';
  }
  return 'shared_resource';
}

Root Cause Analysis

interface Evidence {
  type: 'error_message' | 'timing' | 'resource_usage' | 'pattern_match';
  source: string;
  observation: string;
  weight: number;  // How strongly this supports the conclusion
}

interface ContributingFactor {
  factor: string;
  contribution: number;  // 0-1
  evidence: Evidence[];
}

function identifyRootCause(
  propagation: FailurePropagation,
  failedNodes: FailedNode[],
  trace: ExecutionTrace,
  history?: FailureHistory
): RootCause {
  const originFailure = failedNodes.find(
    f => f.nodeId === propagation.originNode
  )!;

  const evidence: Evidence[] = [];
  const contributingFactors: ContributingFactor[] = [];

  // Evidence from error message
  evidence.push({
    type: 'error_message',
    source: 'primary_error',
    observation: originFailure.error.message,
    weight: 0.9,
  });

  // Evidence from timing
  if (originFailure.timing.duration && originFailure.timing.duration > 30000) {
    evidence.push({
      type: 'timing',
      source: 'execution_duration',
      observation: `Node ran for ${originFailure.timing.duration}ms before failing`,
      weight: 0.6,
    });
  }

  // Evidence from resource usage
  const resourceUsage = extractResourceUsage(originFailure.context);
  if (resourceUsage.tokensUsed > resourceUsage.tokenLimit * 0.9) {
    evidence.push({
      type: 'resource_usage',
      source: 'token_usage',
      observation: `Used ${resourceUsage.tokensUsed}/${resourceUsage.tokenLimit} tokens (${((resourceUsage.tokensUsed / resourceUsage.tokenLimit) * 100).toFixed(0)}%)`,
      weight: 0.7,
    });
  }

  // Check for pattern matches from history
  if (history) {
    const matchingPatterns = findMatchingPatterns(originFailure, history);
    for (const pattern of matchingPatterns) {
      evidence.push({
        type: 'pattern_match',
        source: 'failure_history',
        observation: `Matches known pattern: ${pattern.name} (seen ${pattern.occurrences} times)`,
        weight: 0.8,
      });
    }
  }

  // Analyze contributing factors
  contributingFactors.push(...analyzeContributingFactors(
    originFailure,
    trace,
    evidence
  ));

  // Calculate confidence based on evidence
  const confidence = calculateConfidence(evidence, contributingFactors);

  return {
    nodeId: propagation.originNode,
    type: originFailure.error.type,
    description: generateRootCauseDescription(originFailure, evidence),
    confidence,
    evidence,
    contributingFactors,
  };
}

function analyzeContributingFactors(
  failure: FailedNode,
  trace: ExecutionTrace,
  evidence: Evidence[]
): ContributingFactor[] {
  const factors: ContributingFactor[] = [];

  // Check for high load (many concurrent nodes)
  const concurrentNodes = countConcurrentNodes(trace, failure.timing.startTime);
  if (concurrentNodes > 5) {
    factors.push({
      factor: 'High concurrent load',
      contribution: Math.min(0.3, concurrentNodes * 0.05),
      evidence: [{
        type: 'timing',
        source: 'concurrency_analysis',
        observation: `${concurrentNodes} nodes executing concurrently`,
        weight: 0.5,
      }],
    });
  }

  // Check for slow dependencies
  const slowDeps = findSlowDependencies(trace, failure.nodeId);
  if (slowDeps.length > 0) {
    factors.push({
      factor: 'Slow upstream dependencies',
      contribution: 0.2,
      evidence: slowDeps.map(dep => ({
        type: 'timing' as const,
        source: 'dependency_analysis',
        observation: `Dependency ${dep.nodeId} took ${dep.duration}ms`,
        weight: 0.4,
      })),
    });
  }

  return factors;
}

function calculateConfidence(
  evidence: Evidence[],
  factors: ContributingFactor[]
): number {
  // Weighted average of evidence weights
  const evidenceTotal = evidence.reduce((sum, e) => sum + e.weight, 0);
  const evidenceAvg = evidenceTotal / Math.max(1, evidence.length);

  // Reduce confidence if many contributing factors
  const factorPenalty = Math.min(0.2, factors.length * 0.05);

  // More evidence = more confidence
  const evidenceBonus = Math.min(0.1, evidence.length * 0.02);

  return Math.max(0.3, Math.min(0.95, evidenceAvg + evidenceBonus - factorPenalty));
}

Remediation Planning

interface RemediationPlan {
  immediateActions: RemediationAction[];
  preventiveActions: RemediationAction[];
  retryStrategy?: RetryStrategy;
  escalation?: EscalationPlan;
}

interface RemediationAction {
  action: string;
  priority: 'critical' | 'high' | 'medium' | 'low';
  effort: 'trivial' | 'minor' | 'moderate' | 'major';
  expectedImpact: string;
  implementation?: string;
}

interface RetryStrategy {
  recommended: boolean;
  strategy: 'immediate' | 'backoff' | 'skip' | 'manual';
  maxRetries: number;
  backoffMs?: number;
  conditions?: string[];
}

function generateRemediationPlan(
  rootCause: RootCause,
  classification: FailureClassification,
  propagation: FailurePropagation
): RemediationPlan {
  const plan: RemediationPlan = {
    immediateActions: [],
    preventiveActions: [],
  };

  // Generate actions based on failure type
  switch (rootCause.type) {
    case 'timeout':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Increase timeout for affected node',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'trivial',
        expectedImpact: 'Allows operation to complete',
        implementation: 'Update node config: timeoutMs: <current * 2>',
      });
      plan.preventiveActions.push({
        action: 'Add progress monitoring to detect slow execution',
        priority: 'medium',
        effort: 'moderate',
        expectedImpact: 'Early warning for timeout-prone operations',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: true,
        strategy: 'backoff',
        maxRetries: 2,
        backoffMs: 5000,
        conditions: ['No permanent resource exhaustion'],
      };
      break;

    case 'tool_error':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Check tool availability and permissions',
        priority: 'critical',
        effort: 'trivial',
        expectedImpact: 'Confirms tool is accessible',
      });
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Verify tool input parameters',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'minor',
        expectedImpact: 'Ensures valid inputs',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: false,
        strategy: 'manual',
        maxRetries: 0,
        conditions: ['Tool error must be fixed first'],
      };
      break;

    case 'resource_exhaustion':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Reduce input size or complexity',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'moderate',
        expectedImpact: 'Reduces resource requirements',
      });
      plan.preventiveActions.push({
        action: 'Implement chunking for large inputs',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'major',
        expectedImpact: 'Prevents future exhaustion',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: false,
        strategy: 'skip',
        maxRetries: 0,
        conditions: ['Must reduce resource usage first'],
      };
      break;

    case 'validation_failure':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Review validation rules against actual output',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'minor',
        expectedImpact: 'Identifies schema mismatch',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: true,
        strategy: 'immediate',
        maxRetries: 2,
        conditions: ['Add validation guidance to prompt'],
      };
      break;

    case 'permission_denied':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Review and update permission matrix',
        priority: 'critical',
        effort: 'minor',
        expectedImpact: 'Grants necessary permissions',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: false,
        strategy: 'manual',
        maxRetries: 0,
        conditions: ['Must fix permissions first'],
      };
      break;

    case 'external_service':
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Check external service status',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'trivial',
        expectedImpact: 'Confirms if service is available',
      });
      plan.retryStrategy = {
        recommended: true,
        strategy: 'backoff',
        maxRetries: 3,
        backoffMs: 10000,
        conditions: ['Service may recover'],
      };
      break;

    default:
      plan.immediateActions.push({
        action: 'Manual investigation required',
        priority: 'high',
        effort: 'moderate',
        expectedImpact: 'Understand failure cause',
      });
  }

  // Add escalation if not recoverable
  if (classification.recoverability === 'impossible') {
    plan.escalation = {
      required: true,
      reason: 'Failure is not automatically recoverable',
      suggestedOwner: 'human',
      context: summarizeForEscalation(rootCause, propagation),
    };
  }

  return plan;
}

Failure Report

failureAnalysis:
  analysisId: "fa-7c3a2b1d-4e5f-6a7b-8c9d"
  traceId: "tr-8f4a2b1c-3d5e-6f7a-8b9c"
  dagId: "code-review-dag"
  analyzedAt: "2024-01-15T10:35:00Z"

  rootCause:
    nodeId: check-security
    type: external_service
    description: "Security scanning service returned 503 (Service Unavailable)"
    confidence: 0.87
    evidence:
      - type: error_message
        source: primary_error
        observation: "external service error: Security API returned 503"
        weight: 0.9
      - type: pattern_match
        source: failure_history
        observation: "Matches known pattern: API rate limit (seen 3 times)"
        weight: 0.8
    contributingFactors:
      - factor: "High concurrent load"
        contribution: 0.15
        evidence:
          - type: timing
            source: concurrency_analysis
            observation: "7 nodes executing concurrently"

  propagation:
    originNode: check-security
    affectedNodes:
      - aggregate-results
      - generate-report
    propagationPath:
      - fromNode: check-security
        toNode: aggregate-results
        propagationType: direct_dependency
        timestamp: "2024-01-15T10:34:45Z"
      - fromNode: aggregate-results
        toNode: generate-report
        propagationType: direct_dependency
        timestamp: "2024-01-15T10:34:46Z"
    cascadeDepth: 2
    containmentBoundary:
      - generate-report

  classification:
    severity: high
    impact:
      nodesAffected: 3
      tasksBlocked: 1
      estimatedDelay: 60000
    recoverability: automatic
    frequency: intermittent

  remediation:
    immediateActions:
      - action: "Check external service status"
        priority: high
        effort: trivial
        expectedImpact: "Confirms if service is available"

    preventiveActions:
      - action: "Add circuit breaker for external service calls"
        priority: medium
        effort: moderate
        expectedImpact: "Graceful degradation on service failures"
      - action: "Implement caching for security scan results"
        priority: low
        effort: major
        expectedImpact: "Reduces dependency on external service"

    retryStrategy:
      recommended: true
      strategy: backoff
      maxRetries: 3
      backoffMs: 10000
      conditions:
        - "Service may recover"
        - "No rate limit reached"

  summary: |
    The check-security node failed due to an external service (Security API)
    returning 503. This is an intermittent issue that has occurred 3 times
    previously. The failure cascaded to 2 downstream nodes. Recommended
    action is to retry with exponential backoff.

Integration Points

• Input: Execution traces from dag-execution-tracer
• Correlation: Performance data from dag-performance-profiler
• Output: Failure patterns to dag-pattern-learner
• Recovery: Remediation plans to dag-dynamic-replanner

Best Practices

1. Trace from Origin: Always identify the first failure
2. Gather Evidence: Multiple sources increase confidence
3. Consider History: Check for recurring patterns
4. Actionable Remediation: Make fixes specific and implementable
5. Know When to Escalate: Some failures need human intervention

---

Understand failures. Find root causes. Enable recovery.