mtskd-meta-skill-design

name	mtskd - Meta-Skill Design
description	Design skills that operate on other skills — improving, validating, combining, or routing them — with cross-skill compatibility.
output	{"format":"prose"}

MTSKD - Meta-Skill Design

Input: $ARGUMENTS

---

Step 1: Identify the Meta-Operation

META-OPERATION: [improve | validate | combine | route | transform | audit]
DESCRIPTION: [what this meta-skill does to other skills]
TARGET SKILLS: [which skills this operates on — "any" if universal]

A meta-skill's input is another skill's output (or the skill itself). Classify the operation:

Operation	What it does	Example
Improve	Makes a skill's output better	Refine, deepen, add rigor
Validate	Checks whether a skill was applied correctly	Audit, verify, test
Combine	Merges outputs from multiple skills	Synthesize, integrate
Route	Decides which skill to invoke	Classify, dispatch
Transform	Changes format or level of a skill's output	Summarize, expand, translate
Audit	Checks the skill design itself	Meta-analysis of the procedure

---

Step 2: Design the Input

INPUT SPECIFICATION:
  ACCEPTS: [what the meta-skill takes as input]
  FORMAT: [the expected structure — e.g., "output block from any analytical skill"]
  MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS: [what the input must contain for the meta-skill to work]
  EXAMPLE INPUT: [a concrete example of valid input]

COMPATIBILITY:
  WORKS WITH: [list of skill categories or specific skills]
  DOES NOT WORK WITH: [skills whose output format is incompatible]
  ADAPTATION NEEDED: [skills that work but need output reformatting]

The input is the critical design decision. Too specific means the meta-skill only works with one skill. Too generic means it can't do anything meaningful.

---

Step 3: Design What the Meta-Operation Adds

VALUE ADDED:
  BEFORE META-SKILL: [what the skill output looks like without this]
  AFTER META-SKILL: [what's different after applying it]
  SPECIFIC ADDITIONS:
    1. [what it adds or changes] — WHY: [what problem this solves]
    2. [addition] — WHY: [value]
    3. [addition] — WHY: [value]

MECHANISM:
  STEP 1: [what the meta-skill does first with the input]
  STEP 2: [next operation]
  STEP 3: [next operation]
  ...
  OUTPUT: [what the meta-skill produces]

The meta-skill must add value that the original skill cannot add itself. If a skill could do this internally, it should — no need for a meta-skill.

---

Step 4: Ensure Cross-Skill Compatibility

COMPATIBILITY TESTING:
  SKILL 1: /[skill-id]
    INPUT FROM: [what this skill outputs]
    META-SKILL APPLIES: [yes | with adaptation | no]
    ADAPTATION NEEDED: [if any]
    EXPECTED OUTPUT: [what the meta-skill produces from this skill's output]

  SKILL 2: /[skill-id]
    INPUT FROM: [output]
    META-SKILL APPLIES: [yes | with adaptation | no]
    ADAPTATION NEEDED: [if any]
    EXPECTED OUTPUT: [result]

  SKILL 3: /[skill-id]
    INPUT FROM: [output]
    META-SKILL APPLIES: [yes | with adaptation | no]
    ADAPTATION NEEDED: [if any]
    EXPECTED OUTPUT: [result]

Test on at least 3 different skills. If the meta-skill only works on one type, it's not really a meta-skill — it's an extension of that specific skill.

---

Step 5: Test on 3+ Different Skills

TEST RESULTS:
  TEST 1: /[skill] → /[meta-skill]
    SAMPLE INPUT: [abbreviated example]
    SAMPLE OUTPUT: [abbreviated example]
    VALUE ADDED: [what improved]
    ISSUES: [any problems encountered]

  TEST 2: /[skill] → /[meta-skill]
    SAMPLE INPUT: [example]
    SAMPLE OUTPUT: [example]
    VALUE ADDED: [improvement]
    ISSUES: [problems]

  TEST 3: /[skill] → /[meta-skill]
    SAMPLE INPUT: [example]
    SAMPLE OUTPUT: [example]
    VALUE ADDED: [improvement]
    ISSUES: [problems]

CROSS-SKILL VERDICT: [works universally | works with adaptations | limited compatibility]

---

Output Summary

META-SKILL DESIGN
=================
NAME: [proposed skill id and name]
OPERATION: [improve | validate | combine | route | transform | audit]
INPUT: [what it accepts]
OUTPUT: [what it produces]
VALUE: [one sentence on what it adds]

MECHANISM:
  1. [step]
  2. [step]
  3. [step]

COMPATIBILITY: [count] skills tested
  UNIVERSAL: [yes | no]
  WORKS WITH: [list]
  LIMITATIONS: [where it breaks]

RECOMMENDED PLACEMENT: [where in skill chains this fits]

---

Failure Modes

Failure	Signal	Fix
Not actually meta	Operates on raw user input, not skill output	Redesign to take skill output as input
Only works with one skill	Fails compatibility testing on 2+ skills	Generalize the input specification
Adds no value	Output is not meaningfully different from input	Identify what the original skill misses that this adds
Too generic	"Improve anything" with no specific mechanism	Define the exact operations performed
Circular	Meta-skill requires its own output as input	Break the circularity with a fixed starting point

---

Integration

• Use with: /skcl to position the meta-skill within a skill cluster
• Use with: /gflr to find gaps that a meta-skill could fill
• Use with: /cmpr to verify the meta-skill design is complete
• Use from: /create when designing new meta-level capabilities
• Differs from /skcl: mtskd designs individual meta-skills; skcl designs groups of related skills