Menu
Review a spec, plan, design, decomposition, architecture doc, pre-mortem, runbook, or acceptance report with metareview.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
Run metareview's deterministic epic-ready gate before closing or landing an epic; checks child review evidence, unresolved blockers, integration contradictions, and intent drift.
Run metareview's deterministic PR-ready gate before pushing or opening a PR; checks unresolved blockers, validation evidence, branch diff risks, generated PR evidence, and optional GitHub review context.
Run metareview's deterministic task-done code review gate before claiming a local task is complete; use for task closure, chunk review, or pre-PR local review when code changed.
Run metareview post-merge learning after a PR or local merge completes; curates reusable review knowledge, records discarded low-value candidates, and appends reviewer calibration.
Detect repository mode and prepare metareview review artifacts without overwriting metaswarm or Beads-owned files.
Show metareview repository mode, available integrations, and unresolved review state.
| name | review-artifact |
| description | Review a spec, plan, design, decomposition, architecture doc, pre-mortem, runbook, or acceptance report with metareview. |
Use when reviewing a Markdown artifact before implementation or before a gate is considered passed.
metareview review artifact <path> to create the review scaffold. The command exits nonzero while the review is still NOT_REVIEWED; this is expected and is blocking.rubrics/artifact-review-rubric.md.in-session-emulated when subagents are unavailable or the human explicitly requests no delegation. If falling back, state that the review is not independently adversarial and treat it as weaker evidence.NEEDS_REVISION and ESCALATE are valid review results when supported by findings.metareview review artifact <path> --previous-run <run-id> so the new run links to the prior attempt.Use metareview review artifact <path> --scaffold-only only when explicitly creating a scaffold without claiming the review is complete.
A review execution is incomplete while required reviewer rows are missing, any reviewer lacks a verdict, or the aggregate verdict is NOT_REVIEWED. Do not call an artifact implementation-ready while the verdict is ESCALATE or NEEDS_REVISION, required reviewer rows are missing, reviewer verdicts are missing, or blocking findings remain unresolved unless the human explicitly accepts the risk.