Deep analysis of an arXiv research paper for inclusion in news digest research deep-dives. Extracts key contributions, methodology, results, limitations, and generates a practitioner-focused summary with potential impacts.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
A direct command skips the review prompt. Inspect the source before running it.
Deep analysis of an arXiv research paper for inclusion in news digest research deep-dives. Extracts key contributions, methodology, results, limitations, and generates a practitioner-focused summary with potential impacts.
[{"name":"paper","type":"ArxivPaper","description":"Paper with arxiv_id, title, authors, abstract, categories, pdf_url"},{"name":"analysis_depth","type":"str","default":"standard","description":"\"standard\" for digest inclusion, \"deep\" for featured research spotlight"}]
output
[{"name":"analysis","type":"PaperAnalysis","description":"Comprehensive paper analysis with summary, key findings, and impact assessment"},{"name":"digest_worthy","type":"bool","description":"Whether paper is noteworthy enough for digest inclusion"},{"name":"spotlight_candidate","type":"bool","description":"Whether paper deserves a featured research deep-dive"}]
Analyze ArXiv Paper
Perform deep analysis of a research paper to determine its newsworthiness and generate a practitioner-focused summary.
When to Use
Evaluating papers for digest inclusion
Creating research deep-dive sections
Assessing impact and relevance of new research
Keywords: arxiv, research, paper analysis, academic, deep-dive
{"analysis":{"arxiv_id":"2601.12345","title":"Paper Title","authors":["Author One","Author Two"],"research_type":"new_method","main_claim":"We propose a new approach that...","key_innovation":"Unlike prior work, we...","results_summary":"Our method achieves X% improvement over...","practitioner_summary":"This paper introduces...","key_takeaways":["Main insight about the approach","Practical implication for developers","Important limitation to note"],"relevance_scores":{"practical_applicability":8,"timeliness":9,"novelty":7,"impact_potential":8,"overall":8},"potential_impacts":{"industry":"Could improve LLM inference efficiency by 2x","research":"Opens new direction for efficient training","open_source":"Likely implementation within 1 month","adoption_timeline":"6_months"},"topics":["efficiency","inference","llm"],"related_to":["LoRA","quantization","distillation"]},"digest_worthy":true,"spotlight_candidate":true}
Success Criteria
Research type correctly identified
Main claim extracted from abstract
Practitioner summary is accessible (no jargon without explanation)
Key takeaways are actionable
Relevance scores are justified
Digest/spotlight recommendations align with scores
Failure Handling
Error Type
Handling Strategy
Abstract too short
Use title-only analysis, lower confidence
LLM analysis fails
Return basic metadata with "analysis_failed" flag
Unknown research type
Default to "other" type
Examples
Example 1: High-Impact New Method
Input:
{"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2601.54321","title":"FlashAttention-3: Faster Attention with Better Hardware Utilization","authors":["Tri Dao","Daniel Fu"],"abstract":"We present FlashAttention-3, which achieves 2x speedup over FlashAttention-2 through improved memory access patterns and better GPU utilization. Our method reduces memory bandwidth bottlenecks and enables longer context windows with lower latency.","categories":["cs.LG","cs.AI"],"pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.54321.pdf"},"analysis_depth":"deep"}
Output:
{"analysis":{"arxiv_id":"2601.54321","title":"FlashAttention-3: Faster Attention with Better Hardware Utilization","authors":["Tri Dao","Daniel Fu"],"research_type":"new_method","main_claim":"FlashAttention-3 achieves 2x speedup over FlashAttention-2 through improved memory access patterns","key_innovation":"Better GPU memory bandwidth utilization and reduced overhead","results_summary":"2x speedup, longer context windows, lower latency","practitioner_summary":"FlashAttention-3 represents the next evolution in efficient attention mechanisms. For practitioners running LLM inference, this could mean serving twice as many requests with the same hardware, or supporting context windows twice as long. The improvements come from better understanding of GPU memory hierarchies, making this immediately applicable to any transformer-based model. However, adoption requires updating to the latest CUDA toolkit and may need model-specific tuning.","key_takeaways":["2x inference speedup for transformer attention layers","Enables longer context windows without proportional memory increase","Requires latest GPU drivers but no model architecture changes","Particularly impactful for production LLM serving"],"relevance_scores":{"practical_applicability":10,"timeliness":10,"novelty":8,"impact_potential":9,"overall":9},"potential_impacts":{"industry":"Immediate cost reduction for LLM inference providers","research":"New baseline for attention efficiency research","open_source":"Implementation expected within weeks","adoption_timeline":"immediate"},"topics":["attention","efficiency","inference","transformers"],"related_to":["FlashAttention-2","xFormers","memory-efficient attention"]},"digest_worthy":true,"spotlight_candidate":true}
Example 2: Niche Research Paper
Input:
{"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2601.99999","title":"Improved Convergence Bounds for Federated Learning with Non-IID Data","authors":["Academic Researcher"],"abstract":"We provide tighter convergence bounds for federated averaging under non-IID data distributions. Our theoretical analysis shows that...","categories":["cs.LG"],"pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.99999.pdf"},"analysis_depth":"standard"}
Output:
{"analysis":{"arxiv_id":"2601.99999","title":"Improved Convergence Bounds for Federated Learning with Non-IID Data","authors":["Academic Researcher"],"research_type":"theoretical","main_claim":"Tighter convergence bounds for federated learning","key_innovation":"Improved theoretical analysis of non-IID scenarios","results_summary":"Better mathematical bounds, limited empirical validation","practitioner_summary":"This paper improves our theoretical understanding of federated learning convergence, specifically for scenarios where data across clients is not identically distributed. While the results are mathematically interesting, the practical implications are limited - the bounds are still conservative and don't directly translate to better algorithms. Practitioners working on federated learning may find this useful for understanding worst-case scenarios.","key_takeaways":["Theoretical improvement, limited practical impact","Relevant only to federated learning researchers","No new algorithms or empirical improvements"],"relevance_scores":{"practical_applicability":3,"timeliness":5,"novelty":6,"impact_potential":4,"overall":4},"potential_impacts":{"industry":"Minimal direct impact","research":"Incremental contribution to FL theory","open_source":"No implementation expected","adoption_timeline":"not_applicable"},"topics":["federated learning","convergence","theory"],"related_to":["FedAvg","non-IID data"]},"digest_worthy":false,"spotlight_candidate":false}
{"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2601.54321","title":"FlashAttention-3: Faster Attention with Better Hardware Utilization","authors":["Tri Dao","Daniel Fu"],"abstract":"We present FlashAttention-3, which achieves 2x speedup over FlashAttention-2 through improved memory access patterns and better GPU utilization. Our method reduces memory bandwidth bottlenecks and enables longer context windows with lower latency.","categories":["cs.LG","cs.AI"],"pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.54321.pdf"},"analysis_depth":"deep"}
Expected Output:
{"analysis":{"arxiv_id":"2601.54321","title":"FlashAttention-3: Faster Attention with Better Hardware Utilization","authors":["Tri Dao","Daniel Fu"],"research_type":"new_method","main_claim":"FlashAttention-3 achieves 2x speedup over FlashAttention-2 through improved memory access patterns","key_innovation":"Better GPU memory bandwidth utilization and reduced overhead","results_summary":"2x speedup, longer context windows, lower latency","practitioner_summary":"FlashAttention-3 represents the next evolution in efficient attention mechanisms. For practitioners running LLM inference, this could mean serving twice as many requests with the same hardware, or supporting context windows twice as long. The improvements come from better understanding of GPU memory hierarchies, making this immediately applicable to any transformer-based model. However, adoption requires updating to the latest CUDA toolkit and may need model-specific tuning.","key_takeaways":["2x inference speedup for transformer attention layers","Enables longer context windows without proportional memory increase","Requires latest GPU drivers but no model architecture changes","Particularly impactful for production LLM serving"],"relevance_scores":{"practical_applicability":10,"timeliness":10,"novelty":8,"impact_potential":9,"overall":9},"potential_impacts":{"industry":"Immediate cost reduction for LLM inference providers","research":"New baseline for attention efficiency research","open_source":"Implementation expected within weeks","adoption_timeline":"immediate"},"topics":["attention","efficiency","inference","transformers"],"related_to":["FlashAttention-2","xFormers","memory-efficient attention"]},"digest_worthy":true,"spotlight_candidate":true}
Test Case 2: Niche Research Paper
Input:
{"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2601.99999","title":"Improved Convergence Bounds for Federated Learning with Non-IID Data","authors":["Academic Researcher"],"abstract":"We provide tighter convergence bounds for federated averaging under non-IID data distributions. Our theoretical analysis shows that...","categories":["cs.LG"],"pdf_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.99999.pdf"},"analysis_depth":"standard"}
Expected Output:
{"analysis":{"arxiv_id":"2601.99999","title":"Improved Convergence Bounds for Federated Learning with Non-IID Data","authors":["Academic Researcher"],"research_type":"theoretical","main_claim":"Tighter convergence bounds for federated learning","key_innovation":"Improved theoretical analysis of non-IID scenarios","results_summary":"Better mathematical bounds, limited empirical validation","practitioner_summary":"This paper improves our theoretical understanding of federated learning convergence, specifically for scenarios where data across clients is not identically distributed. While the results are mathematically interesting, the practical implications are limited - the bounds are still conservative and don't directly translate to better algorithms. Practitioners working on federated learning may find this useful for understanding worst-case scenarios.","key_takeaways":["Theoretical improvement, limited practical impact","Relevant only to federated learning researchers","No new algorithms or empirical improvements"],"relevance_scores":{"practical_applicability":3,"timeliness":5,"novelty":6,"impact_potential":4,"overall":4},"potential_impacts":{"industry":"Minimal direct impact","research":"Incremental contribution to FL theory","open_source":"No implementation expected","adoption_timeline":"not_applicable"},"topics":["federated learning","convergence","theory"],"related_to":["FedAvg","non-IID data"]},"digest_worthy":false,"spotlight_candidate":false}
