crossframe-debate

name	crossframe-debate
description	Use when CrossFrame Suite routes explicit Chinese proposition testing, debate analysis, hidden-premise review, rebuttal design, or withdrawal condition checks.
category	content
risk	safe
source	community
source_repo	xi-kari/crossframe-skill
source_type	community
date_added	"2026-06-16T00:00:00.000Z"
author	xi-kari
license	MIT
license_source	https://github.com/xi-kari/crossframe-skill/blob/main/LICENSE
tools	["Agent Skills","Codex","Claude"]
tags	["crossframe","chinese","debate","argument","proposition"]

CrossFrame Debate

When to Use This Skill

• Use when crossframe-suite routes an explicit CrossFrame task about propositions, debate, hidden premises, rebuttals, strongest opposing arguments, evidence requirements, or withdrawal conditions.
• Use to test claims before they become strong judgments.
• Do not use independently unless the user explicitly names this sibling skill.

Packaged Source Note

This AAS-ready copy preserves the original CrossFrame skill body below. Chinese remains the canonical semantic layer; English metadata is only for discovery, installation, and repository review.

Limitations

• The skill body is intentionally Chinese-canonical; English metadata is for discovery and does not replace the original Chinese terms.
• Use only after explicit CrossFrame invocation or crossframe-suite routing; do not apply it as a generic default reasoning layer.
• It structures analysis, drafting, and review, but does not replace source verification, domain expertise, or legal, medical, or financial judgment.

本 skill 不独立触发。 所有 CrossFrame 任务统一从 crossframe-suite 入口调度。用户无需直接调用本 skill；suite 根据路由规则在需要时自动加载。

如果命题论证之后要写文章、公共评论、读书笔记或案例沉淀，先读取 ../crossframe-suite/SKILL.md 做总调度；本 skill 只负责命题拆解、正反结构、证据要求和撤回条件。

crossframe-debate 是 crossframe 的平行轻入口，用于把一个命题拆成可检验论证，而不是帮助某一方赢辩论。

中文为权威语义；英文只用于 skill id、文件名和接口说明。遇到中英文理解冲突时，以中文术语和中文判断为准。

轻入口规则

每次触发后，先读取 canonical skill 和路由图，不复制 CrossFrame 全文：

1. 读取 ../crossframe/SKILL.md。
2. 读取 ../crossframe/references/read-routing-map.md。
3. 如果命题触发高责任、公共制度、亲密关系、长期演化、框架治理、AI 现实验证、弱信号/不透明、无法退出、工具化、隐喻/来源透明或文章输出，必须追加读取 ../crossframe/references/continuity-bundles.md，并按需使用 ../crossframe/worksheets/source-continuity-check.md；未完成联读时只能降档。
4. 复用 ../crossframe/templates/read-state-capsule.md 规定的 v5-read-state-capsule，并在高责任、公共、AI/过程性产物、生命周期、无法退出主体或文章输出场景执行 ../crossframe/worksheets/source-anchor-integrity-check.md。如果胶囊缺失，回到 ../crossframe/SKILL.md 补齐；本 skill 不重新发明源路由。
5. 读取本目录的 protocols/debate-protocol.md。
6. 读取 templates/debate-analysis-output.md。
7. 按需读取 references/debate-quality-gates.md 和 references/debate-failure-patterns.md。