Menu
Use when judging whether a technically valid candidate has hook, tension, authored taste, screenshot value, and series potential.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
Use when converting a gameplay/content intention into a structured asset brief before routing style kits, compiling prompts, running gacha, or scoring candidates.
Use when writing prompt, asset, review, provenance, score, and decision metadata for generated candidates and promoted assets.
Use when any asset skill needs the project art DNA, hard/soft anchors, style kits, tension dials, negative prompts, or forbidden drift rules.
Use when generating or iterating any game art asset prompt. Provides anchor-plus-aperture prompt templates for text-to-image, image-to-image, reconstruction input images, icons, UI, VFX, materials, rooms, enemies, bosses, weapons, gadgets, and asset gacha.
Use when compiling an image-to-image iteration prompt or reconstruction-ready source-image repair prompt that preserves selected strengths while mutating only chosen axes.
Use when compiling prompts for HUD icons, ability icons, cards, UI frames, panels, and small-size readable symbols.
| name | taste-critic-review |
| description | Use when judging whether a technically valid candidate has hook, tension, authored taste, screenshot value, and series potential. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| author | Project Agents |
| license | Project-internal |
| metadata | {"hermes":{"tags":["evaluation","asset-review"],"related_skills":["asset-prompt-core","asset-metadata-writer"]}} |
judging whether a technically valid candidate has hook, tension, authored taste, screenshot value, and series potential.
Score each 0–5: instant hook, emotional contrast, screenshot value, series potential, authored feeling, production taste.
Reject candidates that are technically valid but generic, samey, or AI-collage-like.
candidate_id:
score:
subscores: {}
keep_reasons: []
reject_reasons: []
required_mutations: []
promotion_decision: reject | iterate | shortlist | human_review