| name | third-pass-deep-read |
| description | Keshav's third pass — the heaviest of the three, a full sentence-by-sentence re-read including proofs/derivations, attempting a virtual re-implementation of the paper to surface implicit assumptions and concrete improvement points. Use this after second-pass-grasp, as the terminal step of the Keshav three-pass method, whenever genuine mastery of a paper (not just a summary) is needed. This is not a skippable recap — treat "nothing new to add" as suspicious, not a default outcome. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| category | paper-reading |
| type | sop |
| execution | subagent |
| prompt | ./prompt.md |
| input | source_path (string), meta_path (string), grasp_summary (string) |
| reads | full paper body including proofs and derivations |
| output | deep_read_notes (string) |
| dependencies | {"sops":["spawn-agent"]} |
Third Pass Deep Read
Keshav's third pass: sentence-by-sentence re-read with proofs/derivations included, attempting virtual re-implementation. The heaviest pass of the three — terminal step of the Keshav cascade.
Execution
Subagent — spawned via spawn-agent skill.
Why renamed from third-pass-verify (v1's name)
v1's version of this SOP (staged/wechat-article-v1/skills/third-pass-verify/) treated this as a "targeted re-check of uncertain_fields, no-op if none flagged" step — which, per the coverage audit's S2 finding, effectively deleted Keshav's real third pass (a 4-5+ hour re-implementation attempt) and replaced it with a cheap verification step serving v1's own pipeline. This v2 SOP restores the actual third pass; the rename to third-pass-deep-read marks that this is not the same behavior as the old third-pass-verify, even though both sit in the same cascade position.
Why Subagent
A genuine re-implementation attempt needs a context that can hold the full paper and reason through design alternatives without being anchored to how pass 2 already framed the contribution.
Available SOPs
Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.
| SOP | When to use |
|---|
| spawn-agent | Spawn a customized CC subagent with full MCP tool access. |
