speckit-architecture-guard-governed-tasks

name	speckit-architecture-guard-governed-tasks
description	Generate or validate implementation tasks with memory context, security constraints, and architecture refactor/migration awareness.
compatibility	Requires spec-kit project structure with .specify/ directory
metadata	{"author":"github-spec-kit","source":"architecture-guard:commands/governed-tasks.md"}

Governed Tasks Command

You are orchestrating the governed-tasks workflow for architecture-guard.

This command coordinates multiple extensions to ensure the task list respects architectural, historical, and security constraints before implementation begins. The orchestrator should be memory-first: reuse the current synthesis before reopening the full memory set, and only refresh the cache when the plan or feature scope changed. If flash-mem is available, use /speckit.memory-md.prepare-context or the MCP tools exposed by flash-mem; compatibility tool names such as speckit_memory_* are provided by flash-mem when the host still expects them.

Goal

Provide a single command that ensures:

1. Implementation tasks are historical-context aware (flash-mem).
2. A task list is generated or validated (/speckit.tasks).
3. Security requirements are represented in tasks (Security Review).
4. Architecture refactors or migrations are represented in tasks (Architecture Guard).

Orchestration Flow

Step 1 — Detect Optional Extensions

Check for the existence of:

• flash-mem
• spec-kit-security-review

Detection Logic:

1. Read .specify/extensions.yml and check the installed list. If an extension ID is present there, consider it available.
2. Fall back to checking for the extension directory in .specify/extensions/ only if the YAML is missing or the list is empty.
3. If they are missing from both, degrade gracefully by skipping their respective steps.

Step 2 — Memory Synthesis (Optional)

IF flash-mem is available:

SQLite / MCP Flow (Required for flash-mem)

Because flash-mem uses SQLite as its source of truth, you MUST use its MCP tools to retrieve context. Do not read the .md memory files directly, as they are only backups.

1. Prepare Context: Execute /speckit.memory-md.prepare-context --feature specs/<feature> --query "architecture decisions constraints boundaries <feature>".
2. Read Synthesis: Read specs/<feature>/memory-synthesis.md to identify constraints.
3. If flash-mem emits a token banner, keep it visible so the savings remain observable during normal task generation runs.
4. Token Report: Execute the speckit_memory_token_report MCP tool provided by flash-mem with feature: "<feature>" and display the token savings in the summary.

Markdown-Only Flow (Fallback)

If flash-mem is unavailable, use the standard synthesis command:

1. Execute Synthesis: Run /speckit.memory-md.plan-with-memory to synthesize and save specs/<feature>/memory-synthesis.md.

[OPTIONAL SUB-AGENT DELEGATION]

• If flash-mem has ≥ 20 decision documents: Consider sub-agent for synthesis
• Sub-agent command: /speckit.memory-md.plan-with-memory
• Sub-agent benefits: Faster traversal, better filtering, detailed synthesis
• LLM decides: Inline for quick decisions, sub-agent for complex memory

---

Step 3 — Orchestrate Spec Kit Tasks

You must orchestrate the /speckit.tasks workflow directly.

CRITICAL INSTRUCTION: You must NOT just advise the user or stop here. You must actually generate the tasks:

1. Execute Tasks: Run /speckit.tasks to generate and save specs/<feature>/tasks.md.

   If /speckit.tasks is not available as a registered command (i.e., the AI agent does not recognize it as a slash command), fall back to inline task generation:

   • Read specs/<feature>/plan.md (and spec.md if present).
   • Read all applicable constitution files (.specify/memory/constitution.md, .specify/memory/architecture_constitution.md, .specify/memory/security_constitution.md).
   • Read specs/<feature>/memory-synthesis.md and specs/<feature>/security-constraints.md if available.
   • Generate specs/<feature>/tasks.md directly, breaking down the plan into implementation-ready tasks with checkbox format.
   • Note in the Governance Summary that /speckit.tasks was unavailable and task generation was performed inline.

2. The generated tasks MUST use the Project Constitution documents and feature context. IMPORTANT: You MUST read these files explicitly using your file-reading tools (absolute or relative paths). Do not rely solely on workspace search or semantic indexers, as these files are often in .gitignore:

   • .specify/memory/constitution.md, .specify/memory/architecture_constitution.md, and .specify/memory/security_constitution.md.
   • Also use specs/<feature>/memory-synthesis.md, specs/<feature>/security-constraints.md (if available).

3. Prefer compact, feature-scoped task generation over broad restatements of the full memory set.

Step 4 — Security Review on Tasks

IF spec-kit-security-review is available:

1. Execute Review: Run /speckit.security-review.tasks to review the task list.
2. Check for missing tasks related to:
   • Validation, authorization, and trust boundaries.
   • Secure integration and audit/logging.
3. Update specs/<feature>/security-constraints.md with any new findings.

Step 5 — Architecture Refactor Generation

Run:

/speckit.architecture-guard.refactor-generator

It MUST convert architecture findings into:

• Explicit implementation, migration, or refactor tasks.
• Boundary-level or contract-level corrections.
• Prefer module-level tasks over broad system rewrites.

Step 6 — Proactive Durable Memory Preservation

If the task generation or security review identified new architectural lessons or reusable patterns:

1. Proactive Execution: You MUST automatically execute /speckit.memory-md.capture as the final part of this turn. Do not just recommend it; run the command.
2. Standard: Use the formal capture flow to propose entries and wait for user approval.

Step 7 — Task Governance Summary

Produce a final Governed Tasks Summary for the user.

Graceful Degradation

Without flash-mem:

• Skip Step 2 (Memory Synthesis)
• Continue to /speckit.tasks directly
• Assume no historical task constraints beyond Constitution

Without Security Review:

• Skip Step 4 (Security Review on Tasks)
• Continue to refactor-generator directly
• Flag missing security task validation in summary

If No Architecture Violations:

• Report "Architecture refactor tasks: None"
• Task list is complete

Minimal Viable Workflow (only Architecture Guard + Spec Kit):

• Generate tasks via core Spec Kit
• Validate against Constitution + architecture boundaries
• Produce summary

Output Structure

The command MUST return:

# Governed Tasks Summary

## Memory Context
- **Status**: [Synthesized / Skipped / Missing]
- **Relevant Decisions**: [List of historical constraints affecting these tasks]

## Security Task Review
- **Missing Security Tasks**: [List of missing auth/val/audit tasks]
- **Constraints**: [Key security boundaries to respect]

## Architecture Task Review
- **Refactor Tasks**: [Tasks generated by refactor-generator]
- **Migration Tasks**: [Specific steps for architectural migration]
- **Architecture Risks**: [Drift or conflicts detected in the task list]

## Recommended Next Step
- [e.g., Continue to /speckit.architecture-guard.governed-implement]
- [e.g., Revise tasks to address missing security items]
- [e.g., Update architecture constitution if standard is outdated]
- **Durable Memory Preservation**: (Proactively triggered) Review the proposed memory entries below.

Output Rules

• Separation: Clearly separate implementation tasks, security tasks, and architecture refactor tasks.
• Precision: Do NOT merge findings into vague task items.
• Non-Blocking: Findings are advisory by default.