| name | writing-outline-reviewer |
| description | Legacy-only conversion helper for archived master-outline episodes. It is never selected in a canonical writing episode. |
| user-invocable | false |
| disable-model-invocation | true |
| allowed-tools | Read, Grep, Glob, Agent |
Legacy Outline Conversion Reviewer
This helper inspects a legacy-only .planning/OUTLINE.md and any outlines/ deliverables only as conversion provenance. Canonical writing uses the receipt-selected generated plan’s document structure and claim-to-section map, then a whole-plan review. It never uses this helper to create a review marker or to authorize drafting.
Admission
Use the layout classifier first. Continue only for legacy-only conversion. For canonical state, dispatch the canonical whole-plan reviewer. For a mixed conflicting layout, fail closed rather than merging sources of authority.
Procedure
- Read the legacy master outline and detailed
outlines/ files as provenance.
- Dispatch a read-only reviewer to report claim coverage, section purposes, transitions, scope drift, evidence mapping, and incomplete detailed outlines.
- Return conversion findings to the caller. Do not modify the legacy files, create
.planning/OUTLINE_REVIEWED.md, or begin drafting.
- Carry valid structure into a new native writing plan’s
## Document Structure, ## Claim → Section Map, ## Section Outputs, and ## Review Surfaces.
- Require fresh native approval and the canonical independent whole-plan review before implementation. Detailed outlines remain normal
outlines/ project deliverables.
Return format
Legacy outline conversion findings
- Legacy inputs: [paths]
- Reusable structure and mappings: [findings]
- Gaps to resolve in the new plan or detailed outlines: [findings]
- Next action: author and approve a fresh canonical writing plan
Red flags
| About to | Stop because | Do instead |
|---|
| Invoke this for canonical writing | It promotes retired master-outline authority | Use canonical whole-plan review. |
| Write an outline review marker | It creates a retired gate artifact | Return findings to the converter. |
| Treat a legacy outline as implementation authorization | Only an approved canonical plan authorizes work | Convert and obtain fresh approval. |
