| name | debate-hall |
| description | Wind/Wall/Door debate orchestration router. Routes to focused skills based on task. |
| triggers | ["debate","wind wall door","dialectic","multi-perspective","run debate","resolve question"] |
| allowed-tools | ["Read","Skill"] |
===DEBATE_HALL===
META:
TYPE::SKILL[ROUTER]
VERSION::"4.0"
PURPOSE::"Route to focused debate skills based on task"
§1::CONCEPT
PATTERN::WIND[PATHOS]⇌WALL[ETHOS]→DOOR[LOGOS]
VALUE::"Multi-perspective decisions through structured dialectic"
TERMINOLOGY_CLARIFICATION::[
POSITIONS::"Wind/Wall/Door are debate POSITIONS (structural turn order)",
COGNITIONS::"PATHOS/ETHOS/LOGOS are COGNITION modes (thinking styles, mapped to positions)",
ROLES::"Agent roles (ideator, critical-engineer, etc.) are EXPERTISE identities configured in tiers.yaml"
]
NOTE::"Position determines WHO speaks, Cognition determines HOW they think, Role determines WHAT expertise they bring"
§2::ROUTING[MUST_load_appropriate_skill]
AUTO_DEBATES::[
TRIGGERS::["run debate","resolve question","automated debate","tier selection"],
ACTION::"MUST load /debate-hall-auto",
TOOLS::[run_debate,resolve_question,resume_debate]
]
MANUAL_CONTROL::[
TRIGGERS::["manual debate","turn by turn","init debate","add turn","custom orchestration"],
ACTION::"MUST load /debate-hall-manual",
TOOLS::[init_debate,add_turn,get_debate,close_debate,pick_next_speaker]
]
GITHUB_OPS::[
TRIGGERS::["github sync","ratify","adr pr","discussion sync"],
ACTION::"MUST load /debate-hall-github",
TOOLS::[github_sync_debate,ratify_rfc,human_interject]
]
ADMIN_OPS::[
TRIGGERS::["force close","tombstone","admin","safety override"],
ACTION::"MUST load /debate-hall-admin",
TOOLS::[force_close_debate,tombstone_turn]
]
§3::GRAVITY_MAPPING
LOW[<40]::fast[exploration,reversible]
MEDIUM[40-60]::standard[design,moderate_impact]
HIGH[>60]::premium[production,irreversible]
§4::RESOURCES
AGENTS::agents/README.md
TIERS::src/debate_hall/config/tiers.yaml
PATTERNS::docs/examples/multi-model-debate-patterns.md
ADR::docs/adr/adr-0005-skill-hierarchy-architecture.md
===END===
