eval-code-quality

name

eval-code-quality

description

Specialized code quality evaluator for the Evaluate-Loop. Use this for evaluating code implementation tracks where the deliverable is functional code — features, API routes, state management, utilities. Checks build integrity, type safety, code patterns, error handling, dead code, imports, test coverage, and naming conventions. Dispatched by loop-execution-evaluator when track type is 'feature', 'refactor', or 'infrastructure'. Triggered by: 'evaluate code', 'code review', 'quality check', 'build check'.

Code Quality Evaluator Agent

Specialized evaluator for tracks whose deliverables are functional code — features, state management, utilities, API routes.

When This Evaluator Is Used

Dispatched by loop-execution-evaluator when the track is one of:

• Feature implementation (e.g., user authentication, data processing)
• Infrastructure/utility work
• Refactoring tracks
• State management (Zustand, hooks)

Inputs Required

1. Track's spec.md and plan.md
2. Changed files (from plan.md task summaries or git diff)
3. tsconfig.json — TypeScript config
4. package.json — dependencies and scripts
5. Existing test files (if any)

Evaluation Passes (6 checks)

Pass 1: Build Integrity

npm run build    # Must exit 0
npx tsc --noEmit # Must exit 0 (no type errors)

### Build: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
- Build status: [success / X errors]
- Type check: [clean / X type errors]
- Errors: [list if any]

Pass 2: Type Safety

Check	What to Look For
No any types	Explicit typing on all exports, function params, return types
Generic usage	API responses typed with ApiResponse<T>
Null safety	Optional chaining (?.) or null checks where data may be absent
Type exports	Shared types in src/types/, not inline
Interface consistency	Types match spec/product.md schema

### Type Safety: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
- `any` usage: [count] — [list files:lines]
- Missing types: [list untyped exports]
- Null safety issues: [list]

Pass 3: Code Patterns & State Management

Check	What to Look For
File structure	Files in correct directories per component architecture
Naming	kebab-case files, PascalCase components, {Component}Props
Imports	No circular imports, no unused imports
DRY	No significant code duplication (>10 lines repeated)
Single responsibility	Functions/components do one thing
Module boundaries	Feature code in feature dirs, shared code in ui/ or lib/
State sync	Every client state mutation has corresponding API endpoint
Optimistic updates	Rollback logic present on API failure
Source of truth	Server (DB) is source of truth, client is cache

State Sync Anti-Patterns to Flag:

// ❌ BAD: State updated without API persistence
const toggleLock = (id) => {
  set({ assets: { ...assets, [id]: { locked: true } } });
  // No API call!
}

// ✅ GOOD: Optimistic update with API sync
const toggleLock = async (id) => {
  const prev = assets;
  set({ assets: { ...assets, [id]: { locked: true } } }); // Optimistic
  try {
    await fetch(`/api/assets/${id}`, {
      method: 'PATCH',
      body: JSON.stringify({ locked: true })
    });
  } catch (err) {
    set({ assets: prev }); // Rollback
    throw err;
  }
}

### Code Patterns & State Sync: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
- Naming violations: [list]
- Unused imports: [list files]
- Duplication found: [describe]
- **State mutations without API: [count] — [list]**
- **Missing rollback logic: [count] — [list]**
- **API endpoints without client updates: [count] — [list]**

Pass 4: Error Handling

Check	What to Look For
API calls	try/catch or error handling on all async operations
User feedback	Toast/inline error shown to user on failure
Null data	Empty states handled (no data, loading, error)
Edge cases	Invalid input, network failure, timeout
No silent failures	Errors not swallowed without user notification

### Error Handling: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
- Unhandled async: [list functions]
- Missing user feedback: [list scenarios]
- Silent failures: [list]

Pass 5: Dead Code & Cleanup

Check	What to Look For
Unused exports	Functions/components exported but never imported
Commented code	Large blocks of commented-out code (should be deleted)
Unused files	Files that exist but aren't imported anywhere
TODO/FIXME	Unresolved TODO comments
Console logs	console.log left in production code

### Dead Code: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
- Unused exports: [list]
- Console logs: [list files:lines]
- TODOs: [list]

Pass 6: Test Coverage (when applicable)

Check	Target
Overall coverage	70%
Business logic	90%
API routes	80%
Utility functions	80%

### Tests: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌ / ⚠️ NOT CONFIGURED
- Coverage: [X]% overall
- Business logic: [X]%
- Untested critical paths: [list]

Verdict Template

## Code Quality Evaluation Report

**Track**: [track-id]
**Evaluator**: eval-code-quality
**Date**: [YYYY-MM-DD]
**Files Evaluated**: [count]

### Results
| Pass | Status | Issues |
|------|--------|--------|
| 1. Build | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 2. Type Safety | PASS/FAIL | [count] issues |
| 3. Code Patterns | PASS/FAIL | [count] issues |
| 4. Error Handling | PASS/FAIL | [count] issues |
| 5. Dead Code | PASS/FAIL | [count] issues |
| 6. Tests | PASS/FAIL/N/A | [coverage] |

### Verdict: PASS ✅ / FAIL ❌
[If FAIL, list specific fix actions for loop-fixer]

Handoff

• PASS → Return to loop-execution-evaluator → the orchestrator marks complete
• FAIL → Return to loop-execution-evaluator → the orchestrator dispatches loop-fixer