Menü
Produces an independent critical review of the paper draft. Runs as a background agent.
Mit Codex oder Claude installieren Kopieren Sie diesen Prompt, fügen Sie ihn in Codex, Claude oder einen anderen Assistant ein und lassen Sie die Skill-Seite prüfen und installieren.
Basierend auf der SOC-Berufsklassifikation
Assesses citations in the paper draft against source papers in literature/. Runs as a background agent.
Identifies key references for the paper based on notebook summary and paper composition. Runs as a background agent.
Reshapes the paper draft to match the user's authentic prose style. Runs as a background agent.
Writes a full first draft of the paper based on the pipeline files. Runs as a background agent.
Interactive dialogue to define the paper's scholarly identity using the APFRQMC framework. Use when the user invokes /make-composition. Expects pipeline/notebook_summary.md to exist.
Interactive dialogue to work out the paper's argumentative structure. Use when the user invokes /make-structure. Expects pipeline files from steps 1 and 2 to exist.
| name | review-draft |
| description | Produces an independent critical review of the paper draft. Runs as a background agent. |
| context | fork |
| agent | critical-reviewer |
| disable-model-invocation | true |
When invoked, ALWAYS use the Agent tool to run the agent: '/critical-reviewer' Do NOT execute the agent's task inline.
The agent reads the paper draft and produces an independent peer review — assessing contribution clarity, argumentative coherence, use of literature, methodology, and writing quality. The result is written to pipeline/paper_review.md.
Before proceeding: is there anything specific I should know — particular concerns you have, areas you want scrutinized, or a target venue the review should calibrate to? If not, just say go.
