mckinsey-critic

name	mckinsey-critic
version	0.1.0
description	`/mckinsey-critic` reviews decks, memos, outlines, and strategies like a consulting engagement manager: grade, section issues, top fixes, and what to preserve.
allowed-tools	["Read","AskUserQuestion"]

/mckinsey-critic

Inputs

Ask for the document, deck outline, memo, or strategy to review. If audience or goal is missing, ask before grading.

Output

Return:

1. Grade: Green, Yellow, or Red
2. One-line verdict
3. Section-by-section review table
4. Top 3 fixes ranked by impact
5. One thing that works and should be protected

Review Criteria

• Structure: argument flow and section order
• Rigor: evidence, numbers, fair comparisons
• So-what: clear takeaway per section
• Completeness: options, owners, dates, risks

Process

1. Grade against the intended audience and goal.
2. Lead with the highest-impact problems.
3. Make fixes specific enough to execute.
4. Do not rewrite everything unless asked.

References

Read references/rubric.md for full rubric details and common problems.