kill-argument

name	kill-argument
description	为 reviewer 找茬准备反驳武器库。给一个 claim，agent 列出 5 种最可能的攻击角度 + 每个怎么反驳，附 evidence 链接。Use when user says "kill argument", "反驳武器", "reviewer 会怎么挑", "adversarial defense", "theory paper 防御".
argument-hint	[claim-text-or-paper] [--threats 5]
allowed-tools	Read, Write, Agent, WebSearch

/kill-argument — Adversarial Defense Toolkit

借鉴 ARIS /kill-argument。Theory paper 必备。

Overview

输入一个 paper claim，对每个 claim emit：

Claim: "Our method achieves SR 87% on MC10, beating SOTA by 5%."

5 potential attacks:
1. "How do you control for seed variance? +5% can be 1σ"
   → defense: 5 seeds, 95% CI [82, 92], baseline CI [76, 80] — non-overlapping
   → evidence: paper Tab 3
2. "Baseline is a weak comparison — newer SOTA exists"
   → defense: ...
3. ...

Workflow

1. Read claim
2. Spawn 5 adversarial sub-agents (each 1 angle)
3. Each emit attack + defense + evidence pointer
4. Merge → paper/defenses/<claim_id>.md

Output

• paper/defenses/<claim>.md
• 喂给 /rebuttal 当 ammunition

Composition

• /rebuttal 调本 skill 准备 reviewer 还没问的潜在追问
• Stage 8 paper drafting 时也可调，主动消除弱点