| name | forge:ask |
| hidden | true |
| description | Use whenever you need a decision, clarification, or approval from the user — covers how to ask with the question tool, and how to resolve the decision yourself when no user is available (question tool absent, or a [Never-Ask] response) |
Asking the User
The Rule
Every time you need the user to decide, clarify, or approve something, route it through the question tool. Never stop the loop with a natural-language question ("Does this look right?", "Should I proceed?", "Which would you prefer?"). A natural-language question ends your turn without finishing the task; a question tool call does not.
This means: the loop only ends when the task is actually complete — never because you paused to ask in prose.
How to Ask
- Structured options — when the decision has known choices, list them as
options (each with a short label and a description).
- Open-ended — when you can't enumerate good options, pass empty
options. An empty options list renders as a free-text prompt: the user types whatever they want. So anything you'd normally ask in prose can be asked through question instead.
- One question per concern — don't bundle unrelated decisions; ask them as separate questions (or separate calls).
- Don't repeat the question in prose — the tool already renders it. Just call the tool.
question({
questions: [{
question: "Which auth strategy should I use?",
header: "Auth",
options: [
{ label: "Session cookies", description: "Server-side sessions, simplest" },
{ label: "JWT", description: "Stateless, good for multiple services" },
],
}],
})
When No User Is Available
There are two situations where you won't get a human answer. The decision behavior is identical in both — you pick the best option for unattended/headless execution yourself and keep going. They differ only in whether the question tool is reached this turn:
- Question tool absent (e.g.
run/eval, where question is denied) — the tool isn't in your list. You never call it; decide and proceed directly.
[Never-Ask] response (never-ask is on) — you do call question, but instead of a user answer the tool returns a [Never-Ask] directive. Re-pick from the options you proposed, explicitly state your choice and reasoning in your response text, and continue.
How to decide autonomously
The best option for a human is often not the best option for headless execution. Re-evaluate your own options through this lens:
- Prefer text-only over visual/interactive paths (e.g. don't launch a GUI companion, don't open a browser — produce the same content as text).
- Prefer non-interactive over anything needing the user present.
- Prefer the minimal-scope path — don't expand the work to cover speculative edge cases just because no one is gating it.
- When approval is the only thing being requested, treat it as granted and proceed to implementation.
- Exception — destructive, irreversible actions (deleting a branch/commits, dropping data, force-pushing) never auto-approve. When you can't get explicit confirmation, choose the non-destructive path (keep things as-is) and continue with the rest of the task.
Only this turn — keep asking later
Autonomous resolution applies only to the current question. Do not infer "I should stop using the question tool from now on." never-ask can be turned off at any moment, and the question tool may reappear — at the next decision point, ask normally again. The user may have returned.
Why this skill exists
This is the single source of truth for asking and autonomous fallback. Other forge skills reference it at their decision points instead of repeating fallback text, so the rules stay consistent and the prompts stay small.
