sdd-propose

name	sdd-propose
description	Propose 2–3 solution approaches for a planned change, evaluating trade-offs and recommending one.
when_to_use	After sdd-explore completes. Reads context from memory, proposes approaches.
allowed-tools	["Read","mcp__invencible-memory__memory_recall","mcp__invencible-memory__memory_search","mcp__invencible-memory__memory_save"]
model	sonnet
effort	medium
user-invocable	false

Goal

Generate 2–3 concrete approaches to the planned change, evaluate trade-offs, and commit to one recommendation.

Steps

1. Load context: memory_recall(topic_key="sdd-<change_id>-context")
2. Generate 2–3 distinct approaches — include the obvious path and at least one alternative
3. For each approach evaluate: implementation complexity, reversibility, blast radius, testability
4. Select the recommended approach with a clear rationale
5. Save to memory:
   • title: SDD Proposal: <change_id>
   • topic_key: sdd-<change_id>-proposal
   • type: decision
   • content (structured):

     ## Approach A: <name>
     <description, pros, cons>
     
     ## Approach B: <name>
     <description, pros, cons>
     
     ## Approach C: <name> (if applicable)
     <description, pros, cons>
     
     ## Recommended: <Approach X>
     <rationale — why this one, why not the others>
     

Constraints

• No implementation code in this phase
• Each approach must be genuinely distinct (not variations of the same idea)
• The recommendation must be unambiguous — one winner