| name | research-claim-snapshot |
| description | 用于 P4 实验规划前先读项目材料,生成研究主张快照、资源边界、预计论文级别和 low-confidence 缺口。不用于拆 req 任务。 |
Research Claim Snapshot
Role
本 skill 负责把项目现有材料压缩成 P4 可用的研究主张快照。它先读已有调研和实验材料,再判断当前计划预计能支撑的论文级别。
Method-call
/research-claim-snapshot(
project_root,
materials?,
target_level?,
output_root = knowledge/experiment-plan/
) -> claim_snapshot
Step 1: Material Inventory
列出已读材料,按证据类型分组:
- research direction / requirement
- target journal or thesis requirement
- P2 benchmark deconstruction or synthesis
- P3 topic and innovation claims
- literature review or reference pool
- method notes / code / dataset / existing results
- screenshots / demo evidence / system artifacts
缺失项写 missing,不脑补。
Step 2: Research Claim Snapshot
把材料转成可验证主张:
| Field | Question |
|---|
| research_scene | 在哪个领域、场景、区域或约束下做贡献? |
| problem | 要解决什么问题? |
| method | 实际方法、系统或流程是什么? |
| contribution_candidates | 可能的贡献点有哪些? |
| measurable_effect | 贡献能通过什么指标或证据证明? |
| available_resources | 数据、代码、环境、算力、时间、人工资源有什么? |
| missing_inputs | 缺 P2/P3/结果/数据/期刊信息的哪一块? |
Step 3: Paper Level Assessment
输出当前实验计划预计支撑级别,不做发表保证:
current_support_level: coursework|bachelor-thesis|master-thesis|cn-general|cn-core|sci-low|sci-mid|sci-high
confidence: high|medium|low
why_this_level: <evidence-backed explanation>
upgrade_path: <what is needed for next level>
minimum_salvage_path: <lowest viable paper strategy>
判断依据:
- claim novelty and clarity
- baseline strength
- ablation completeness
- dataset / case / scenario breadth
- metric and verifier clarity
- target venue fit
- whether current evidence can support the claim without overclaiming
Step 4: Output Files
Write or update:
knowledge/experiment-plan/research-claim-snapshot.md
knowledge/experiment-plan/paper-level-assessment.md
Human-facing prose must stay readable. Put machine contracts in later skills, not in this snapshot.
本 skill 的 deletion-spec
- 触发删除条件:当 P4 orchestrator can reliably infer project claims and paper-level support without a dedicated snapshot pass, this skill can be removed.
- 禁用方式:删除
plugins/experiment-planning-suite/skills/research-claim-snapshot/,bump plugin 版本,刷新 marketplace/cache。
- 卸载清单:同步检查 orchestrator workflow、README、
feasibility-salvage-gate 和 req-experiment-handoff 对 snapshot 文件的引用。