promote

name	promote
description	Promote proven project instincts to global scope with lineage tracking
argument-hint	<instinct-id> | --scan [--project <slug>]
allowed-tools	["Read","Write","Bash","Grep","Glob"]

Elevate project-scoped instincts that have proven themselves reliable across many opportunities into the global instinct pool, generalizing their operational rules and maintaining a full lineage trail so the origin is traceable.

Instructions

You are promoting instincts from project scope to global scope. Promotion means the rule is now applied universally, not just in one project context. Be conservative — only promote instincts that are genuinely universal.

Promotion Eligibility Criteria

An instinct is eligible for promotion only if all of the following are true:

1. status == "proven"
2. confidence >= 0.85
3. evidence array length >= 15 (total opportunity count)
4. Project-specific token ratio < 30% — count tokens in the operational rule body that reference the project slug, project name, or project-specific file paths, divided by total tokens. If this ratio >= 0.30, the rule is too project-specific to generalize.

If any criterion fails, the instinct is ineligible and must appear in the "Ineligible" section of the report with the specific reason.

---

Mode Detection

Parse the arguments passed to this skill:

• Single ID mode: /promote INS-XXXXXXXX-XXXX — promote exactly one instinct.
• Scan mode: /promote --scan — find all eligible instincts across all project scopes and prompt before each.
• Scan with filter: /promote --scan --project <slug> — only scan ~/.claude/instincts/projects/<slug>/.

---

Step 1: Locate Source Instincts

Single ID mode:

find "$HOME/.claude/instincts/projects/" -name "<instinct-id>.md" 2>/dev/null

If found, read the file. If not found, check global scope (already promoted — skip with a note).

Scan mode:

# List all project-scoped instinct files
if [ -n "$PROJECT_SLUG" ]; then
  find "$HOME/.claude/instincts/projects/$PROJECT_SLUG/" -name "INS-*.md" 2>/dev/null
else
  find "$HOME/.claude/instincts/projects/" -name "INS-*.md" 2>/dev/null
fi

Read each file found. Parse the YAML frontmatter to extract:

• id, name, status, confidence, scope
• evidence (list)
• lineage.promoted_to (if set, already promoted — skip)
• The body text under ## Operational Rule

---

Step 2: Evaluate Eligibility

For each candidate, apply the four criteria:

Token specificity check — to measure project-specificity of the operational rule:

python3 -c "
import re, sys

rule_text = '''<PASTE_RULE_TEXT>'''
project_slug = '<PROJECT_SLUG>'

# Tokenize (split on whitespace + punctuation)
tokens = re.findall(r'[a-zA-Z0-9_\-/\.]+', rule_text)
total = len(tokens)
if total == 0:
    print('0.00')
    sys.exit()

# Count tokens that reference the project
project_terms = set()
project_terms.add(project_slug.lower())
# Also count path segments that contain the slug
specific = sum(1 for t in tokens if project_slug.lower() in t.lower())
ratio = specific / total
print(f'{ratio:.2f}')
"

Build a verdict for each instinct:

• ELIGIBLE — all four criteria pass
• INELIGIBLE: confidence too low
• INELIGIBLE: not enough evidence (need 15, have N)
• INELIGIBLE: too project-specific (N% specific tokens, threshold 30%)
• INELIGIBLE: status is not proven (current status: X)
• ALREADY GLOBAL — scope is already global or lineage.promoted_to is set

Scan mode: After computing verdicts, print the list and ask:

Found N eligible instincts for promotion:
  1. INS-XXX | "name" | confidence: 0.XX | evidence: N
  2. ...

Promote all? [y/N] or enter numbers (e.g. 1,3):

Wait for the user's response before proceeding.

---

Step 3: Promote Each Approved Instinct

For each instinct approved for promotion:

3a. Generate new global ID:

SUFFIX=$(python3 -c "import secrets; print(secrets.token_hex(2))")
NEW_ID="INS-$(date +%Y%m%d)-${SUFFIX}"
echo "$NEW_ID"

3b. Generalize the operational rule.

Read the ## Operational Rule body. Rewrite it to be project-agnostic:

• Remove explicit project slug references (e.g., mb-mgmt, backend, content-assistant)
• Replace specific file paths with generic descriptions (e.g., team_roster.json in this project → the project's team roster file)
• Replace project-specific tool invocations with generalized equivalents
• Keep the behavioral intent and the WHY unchanged — only remove identifying specifics
• Do NOT shrink the rule. It should be the same length or longer after generalization.

3c. Write the new global instinct file:

mkdir -p "$HOME/.claude/instincts/global"
DEST="$HOME/.claude/instincts/global/${NEW_ID}.md"

The new file uses this format (match exactly):

---
id: <NEW_ID>
name: "<same name>"
description: "<same description, generalized>"
type: feedback
scope: global
status: proven
confidence: <same confidence>
score:
  successes: <copy from source>
  failures: <copy from source>
  confirmations: <copy from source>
  corrections: <copy from source>
  last_applied_at: "<copy from source>"
  half_life_days: 21
  decay_floor: 0.30
signals:
  trigger_patterns:
    - "<copy from source>"
  anti_patterns: []
evidence:
<copy all evidence entries verbatim>
lineage:
  parent_ids: []
  cluster_id: null
  promoted_from: "<ORIGINAL_ID>"
  version: 1
created_at: "<ISO-8601 UTC now>"
updated_at: "<ISO-8601 UTC now>"
---
## Operational Rule
<generalized rule body>

3d. Update the source instinct file.

Add promoted_to: <NEW_GLOBAL_ID> inside the lineage: block. Use the confidence library's update_instinct_file helper, or use the Edit tool for targeted replacement:

python3 -c "
import sys
sys.path.insert(0, '$HOME/.claude/instincts/lib')
from confidence import update_instinct_file
update_instinct_file('SOURCE_PATH', {
    'lineage.promoted_to': 'NEW_GLOBAL_ID',
    'updated_at': 'ISO_NOW',
})
"

If the lineage block does not have a promoted_to field yet, add it manually after promoted_from:.

3e. Update the project INSTINCTS.md index.

Find the line for this instinct's ID and append → promoted to <NEW_GLOBAL_ID> to it. If the line does not exist, add it.

3f. Update the global INSTINCTS.md index.

File: ~/.claude/instincts/global/INSTINCTS.md

Append a new line under the ## Proven Instincts section:

- <NEW_ID> | proven | <confidence> | "<name>" | promoted <YYYY-MM-DD>

If the section does not exist yet, create it.

---

Step 4: Report

Output a structured promotion report:

## Promotion Report

### Promoted (N)
- INS-XXX (project/<slug>) → INS-YYY (global) | "<name>" | confidence: 0.XX
  → Lineage tracked, rule generalized

### Ineligible (N)
- INS-XXX | "<name>" | reason: <confidence too low (0.XX < 0.85) | not enough evidence (N < 15) | too project-specific (N% tokens)>

### Already Global (N)
- INS-XXX | "<name>" — already in global scope, skipped

If nothing was promoted, explain clearly. If there are no project-scope instincts at all, say so.

---

Important Constraints

• Never overwrite an existing global instinct file. If $HOME/.claude/instincts/global/${NEW_ID}.md already exists (collision), generate a new suffix and try again.
• Preserve all evidence entries. Copy the full evidence list verbatim to the promoted file.
• Generalize, do not delete. The operational rule after generalization must still be specific enough to be actionable. "Be careful" is not a rule.
• Lineage is mandatory. Always set promoted_from in the new global file and promoted_to in the source file. Without lineage, the promotion is incomplete.
• Ensure directories exist before writing (mkdir -p).
• Do not promote global instincts. If the source instinct already has scope: global, skip it with "Already Global" status.