writing-claude-md-files

name	writing-claude-md-files
description	Use when creating or updating CLAUDE.md / AGENTS.md files for a project or a subdirectory. Covers the split between top-level (how to work here) and domain-level (why this exists, what it promises), and the freshness date convention.
user-invocable	false

Writing CLAUDE.md / AGENTS.md Files

These files exist because agents start each session without context. They preserve the things you'd otherwise re-explain every time: how to build, what the conventions are, why a domain is shaped the way it is.

For directive-writing fundamentals (token economy, motivation framing, discovery), see writing-claude-directives.

Tools differ in which file they read — Claude Code reads CLAUDE.md (not AGENTS.md); most other agents read AGENTS.md. Keep one real file per repo and bridge with a symlink or an @AGENTS.md import line so every tool finds it.

Top-level vs. subdirectory

The two flavors do different jobs:

• Top-level (repo root): How to work in this codebase. Tech stack, build commands, project structure, conventions, edit boundaries. The "new engineer on day one" content.
• Subdirectory (domain or subdomain): Why this piece exists and what it promises. Purpose, contracts, invariants, gotchas. The "you're about to touch this — read this first" content.

Hierarchy: the root CLAUDE.md loads at session start; subdirectory files load lazily when the agent reads files in that directory (and aren't re-injected after compaction). So a file in src/domains/auth/ gets src/domains/auth/CLAUDE.md plus the root one — no need to repeat root content in domain files, but don't put session-critical rules only in a subdirectory file.

Depth heuristic: typically zero or one level of subdirectory CLAUDE.md files. Two levels (e.g. auth/oauth2/CLAUDE.md) is rare and only when the subdomain has its own non-obvious contracts.

Claude Code alternative: path-scoped rule files in .claude/rules/ with paths: frontmatter do the same job as subdirectory CLAUDE.md files and keep the source tree free of doc files. Prefer them in Claude Code-only repos; subdirectory CLAUDE.md files are the portable form.

Top-level template

# [Project Name]

Last verified: <run `date +%Y-%m-%d`>

## Tech Stack
- Language: TypeScript 5.x
- Framework: Next.js 14
- Database: PostgreSQL
- Testing: Vitest

## Commands
- `npm run dev` — start dev server
- `npm run test` — run tests
- `npm run build` — production build

## Project Structure
- `src/domains/` — domain modules (auth, billing, etc.)
- `src/shared/` — cross-cutting utilities
- `src/infrastructure/` — external adapters (DB, APIs)

## Conventions
- Functional core, imperative shell
- Domains are self-contained — no cross-domain imports
- Domain-specific guidance lives in each domain's CLAUDE.md

## Boundaries
- Safe to edit: `src/`
- Don't touch: `migrations/` (immutable history), `*.lock`

What to leave out of the top-level file:

• Style rules linters already enforce.
• Exhaustive command listings (point at package.json / justfile instead).
• Domain-specific content (push it down into the domain file).
• Secrets, credentials, or anything sensitive.

Subdirectory template

# [Domain Name]

Last verified: <run `date +%Y-%m-%d`>

## Purpose
[1-2 sentences: why this domain exists, what problem it owns.]

## Contracts
- **Exposes:** [public interface — what callers can use]
- **Guarantees:** [promises this domain keeps]
- **Expects:** [what callers must provide]

## Dependencies
- **Uses:** [domains/services this depends on]
- **Used by:** [what depends on this]
- **Boundary:** [what should NOT be imported here]

## Key Decisions
- [Decision]: [Rationale]

## Invariants
- [Things that must always be true]

## Key Files
- `index.ts` — public exports
- `service.ts` — main implementation

## Gotchas
- [Non-obvious thing that will bite you]

Worked example — auth domain:

# Auth Domain

Last verified: 2025-12-17

## Purpose
Verifies user identity once at the system edge. Downstream services trust
the token without re-validating.

## Contracts
- **Exposes:** `validateToken(token) → User | null`, `createSession(creds) → Token`
- **Guarantees:** Tokens expire after 24h. User objects always include roles.
- **Expects:** Valid JWT format. Database connection available.

## Dependencies
- **Uses:** Database (users), Redis (session cache)
- **Used by:** All API routes, billing (user identity only)
- **Boundary:** Don't import from billing, notifications, or other domains

## Key Decisions
- JWT over session cookies — stateless auth for horizontal scaling
- bcrypt cost 12 — legacy; argon2 migration tracked in ADR-007

## Invariants
- Every user has exactly one primary email
- Deleted users are soft-deleted (is_deleted), never hard deleted
- User IDs are UUIDs, never sequential

## Key Files
- `service.ts` — AuthService implementation
- `tokens.ts` — JWT creation/validation
- `types.ts` — User, Token, Session

## Gotchas
- `validateToken` returns null on invalid input, doesn't throw
- Never include raw password hashes in serialized User objects

Freshness dates

Every CLAUDE.md should have a Last verified date near the top. The date signals when the contracts were last confirmed against the code; without it, a six-month-old file looks identical to one written yesterday.

Get the actual date from the shell rather than guessing:

date +%Y-%m-%d

Stale CLAUDE.md is worse than missing CLAUDE.md — it's wrong with confidence. When you touch a domain whose contracts changed, update the date in the same change.

Honest vagueness over fake precision

The claim-level version of the freshness concern: a precise claim sourced from prose rather than primary evidence — version numbers, dates, counts, authorship, fork points — rots over time AND propagates forward, because downstream agents cite the number as authoritative without re-verifying. "A long time ago" beats "forked from 2.1.4" unless 2.1.4 is grounded in git log, release notes, or package metadata. Applies to all agent-facing prose: CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, team READMEs, PR descriptions.

When to add a subdirectory file

Add one when the domain has:

• Non-obvious contracts other parts of the system depend on.
• Architectural decisions that should constrain future edits.
• Invariants that aren't readable from the code alone.
• A pattern of new sessions needing the same context re-explained.

Skip it for:

• Trivial utility folders.
• Implementation details that change frequently (the file goes stale fast).
• Content that's better as a code comment next to the relevant function.

Updating

When you change a domain that has a CLAUDE.md:

1. Update Last verified to today.
2. Re-check the contracts — are they still accurate?
3. Cut anything that's no longer true. Short-and-correct beats long-and-wrong.
4. Keep it under ~100 lines for a subdirectory file, ~200 for top-level (official guidance: adherence drops past ~200).

Referencing files

Plain prose is enough — name the files inline:

## Key Files
- `index.ts` — public exports
- `service.ts` — main implementation

@file syntax force-loads the file into context at session start whether or not the agent needs it. Use it only when that's the point (e.g. @AGENTS.md as an interop shim); for everything else, naming the file lets the agent read it on demand.

Common mistakes

Mistake	Fix
Describing what code does	Focus on why it exists and what it promises
Missing or guessed freshness date	Use date +%Y-%m-%d from the shell
Casual @-file references	Force-load only deliberately (e.g. @AGENTS.md shim)
Subdirectory file > 100 lines	Push detail into code comments or split the file
Repeating top-level content in subdirs	Subdirectories inherit; don't duplicate
Docs unchanged after the domain changed	Update Last verified and check the contracts

Quick checks before committing

Top-level:

• Tech stack, commands, structure listed
• Freshness date present and accurate

Subdirectory:

• Purpose answers why, not what
• Contracts: exposes / guarantees / expects all filled in
• Dependencies and boundaries clear
• Invariants listed where they're non-obvious
• Freshness date present and under ~100 lines