| name | paper-qc-reviewer |
| description | Run a multi-dimensional pre-submission quality review of a research paper and prioritize actionable fixes. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| author | Zejun-W |
| license | MIT |
Paper QC Reviewer
Purpose
Perform a pre-submission review that combines domain, logic, mathematical, experimental, citation, and language checks.
Review dimensions
- Research question and novelty.
- Problem-to-method causal logic.
- Technical correctness and reproducibility.
- Notation uniqueness, equation validity, and definition order.
- Dataset, split, metric, baseline, and fairness consistency.
- Table and figure numbering, readability, and redundancy.
- Citation truthfulness, relevance, and formatting.
- Claim strength versus evidence.
- Language precision, concision, and consistency.
- Venue compliance and anonymization.
Severity
BLOCKER: invalidates submission or scientific credibility.MAJOR: likely reviewer concern or reproducibility failure.MINOR: clarity, formatting, or local consistency issue.OPTIONAL: improvement with limited submission risk.
Output
Provide an executive verdict, prioritized issue table, exact locations, proposed corrections, and a final pass/fail checklist. Do not rewrite the whole paper unless explicitly requested.
