| name | plan-review-seminar |
| description | Review SEMINAR track plans (HIST, BIO, ISTORIO, LIT, OES, RUTH) using Wikipedia + Literary RAG + VESUM. Finds factual errors, ghost sources, decolonization issues. |
| argument-hint | <track> [modules: all | 1 | 5-10 | slug-name] |
| effort | xhigh |
Plan Review (Seminar): $ARGUMENTS
Scope: HIST, BIO, ISTORIO, LIT (all subtracks), OES, RUTH only. For core levels (A1-C2, PRO), use /plan-review.
Parse Arguments
The user provides one of these argument patterns:
- Track + modules:
hist all, hist 1, hist 5-10, hist 1,3,5
- Track + slug:
hist volodymyr-khreshchennia
- Full path:
curriculum/l2-uk-en/plans/hist/volodymyr-khreshchennia.yaml
- Track only:
hist (defaults to all)
Parse the arguments:
- If
$ARGUMENTS contains a / and ends in .yaml, treat it as a full path to a single plan file. Extract the track from the path (the directory name under plans/).
- Otherwise,
$0 = track, $1 = module selector (default: all).
Plans directory: curriculum/l2-uk-en/plans/{track}/*.yaml
Valid tracks: hist, bio, istorio, lit, lit-drama, lit-essay, lit-doc, lit-crimea, lit-fantastika, lit-hist-fic, lit-humor, lit-war, lit-youth, oes, ruth
Module Selection
all -- process every .yaml file in the plans directory- Single number (e.g.,
1) -- find the plan with sequence: 1 in its YAML
- Range (e.g.,
5-10) -- find plans with sequence 5 through 10
- List (e.g.,
1,3,5) -- find plans with those specific sequences
- Slug (e.g.,
volodymyr-khreshchennia) -- find the plan file {slug}.yaml
To match sequence numbers, read each YAML and check the sequence: field.
Execute
Read and follow the full seminar plan review prompt at plan-review-seminar-prompt.md. It contains all checks, RAG tool usage, and the output format.
For review-tier reference, see the Tier 3 rubric at claude_extensions/skills/plan-review/review-tiers/tier-3-seminar.md.
Output path: Save each review to curriculum/l2-uk-en/{track}/audit/{slug}-plan-review.md
After all plans, produce a summary: PASS/FAIL counts, CRITICAL and HIGH issues grouped by pattern, suggested template fixes. Do NOT fix plans -- report only. Reference issue #729.
