deviate

name

deviate

description

Stop an in-flight assign-to-workforce run the moment execution must diverge from the confirmed plan, get explicit human approval for the divergence, and record it as a first-class, append-only deviation record via `devague deviate` before resuming — never fold a deviation silently into drift after the fact. Use when the user says "deviate from the plan", "we need to change the plan mid-run", "record a deviation", "this isn't matching the plan anymore", or when a task agent discovers the confirmed plan no longer matches reality partway through a workforce run. Authored and maintained in agentculture/devague (origin = devague); guildmaster pulls this skill from here and broadcasts it to the AgentCulture mesh — it is NOT vendored from guildmaster like the other skills here.

deviate — record an approved mid-run departure from the confirmed plan

The skill is named deviate; it is the execution-time leg of the devague method — the sixth leg, sitting between the two execution skills:

scope -> think -> spec-to-plan -> assign-to-workforce -> deviate -> summarize-delivery

Where /assign-to-workforce fans out a converged plan's waves and /summarize-delivery closes the loop afterward, /deviate runs during the fan-out, at the exact moment reality stops matching the plan the human approved at gate 2 (the implementation split plan). It is not a new standing gate — it is the human owner of gate 2 amending the approved split mid-flight, scoped to the one deviation in front of them.

The plan the user confirmed is a contract. Task agents hit constraints, discover a dependency was wrong, or find the acceptance criteria no longer make sense once code is in front of them. Until this skill existed, that reality either silently reshaped what got built (undocumented drift) or the run stalled with no recorded path forward. /deviate is that path: the departure is named, approved, and recorded before anyone keeps building against it.

The method

1. STOP the run. The moment a task agent (or the main agent) discovers the confirmed plan no longer matches what needs to happen, halt — do not keep implementing against the stale contract and do not let the fan-out continue past this task.
2. Present what, why, and what it affects. Lay out, for the human:
   • what is diverging — the specific change from the confirmed task(s);
   • why — the constraint or discovery that forced it;
   • what it affects — the plan item ref(s) involved (--task), any other task ids or coverage targets it touches (--affects), and which acceptance criteria are no longer accurate.
3. Get explicit human approval. This is the one non-negotiable step. A deviation is not real until a human says yes to this specific departure — not a standing blanket permission, not an inference from silence.
4. Record it via devague deviate. Once approved, record the deviation as a first-class ledger entry (never edit the plan itself — the plan stays the untouched historical contract; see devague/delivery.py). An --origin llm record lands proposed and still needs the user's --confirm — recording is not the same as approval landing as final.
5. Adjust the affected task briefs. Update the working instructions the task agent(s) are building against so they reflect the approved departure, not the stale plan text.
6. Resume. Only after the record exists (and, for an llm-origin record, only after it is confirmed) does the fan-out continue.

Deviations are never silently folded into drift after the fact — by the time /summarize-delivery runs, every departure from the plan already has a dN record with a reason, an approval, and an optional classification. The delivery summary quotes these records; it does not reconstruct drift from memory.

The shipped CLI surface

This skill invokes the CLI directly and stays self-contained (if devague isn't on your PATH: uv tool install devague). Deviation state persists under .devague/deliveries/<plan-slug>.json — a peer of the plan store, keyed by the plan slug, and never touches the plan JSON itself.

Move	What it does
devague deviate "<what>" --task <tN> --reason "<text>"	Record a deviation against plan item <tN>. User-origin (the default) auto-approves.
devague deviate "<what>" --task <tN> --reason "<text>" --affects <ref> [<ref> ...]	Same, also naming every other plan item ref or coverage target the deviation touches (repeatable).
devague deviate "<what>" --task <tN> --reason "<text>" --classification acceptable|risky|needs-follow-up	Same, tagging the deviation with the classification the drift-entry contract consumes downstream.
devague deviate "<what>" --task <tN> --reason "<text>" --origin llm	An LLM-proposed record; lands proposed, not approved.
devague deviate --confirm <dN>	User-only: approve a proposed deviation.
devague deviate --reject <dN>	User-only: reject a proposed (or any) deviation.
devague deviate --list [--json]	Read every recorded deviation back (also the default action with no positional/flag).
devague deviate ... --plan <slug>	Target a plan other than the current one.

--reason is required on every record — omitting it is refused with a hint. --task naming the plan item ref is likewise required.

Hard rules (do not violate)

• Never record a deviation the human did not approve. devague deviate without --origin llm auto-approves the instant it is run — so a user-origin record IS the approval. Only run it after the human has said yes to this specific departure, never preemptively "to be safe."
• Never continue past a refused approval. If the human does not approve, the run stays stopped on that task. Do not record the deviation anyway, do not quietly implement the diverging approach, and do not advance the wave.
• LLM-origin records stay proposed until the user confirms. --origin llm lands proposed; only devague deviate --confirm <dN> (user-only) makes it approved. Same anti-fabrication contract as every other origin in the method — an agent's own proposal never self-confirms.
• Deviations are never silently folded into drift after the fact. Every departure from the confirmed plan gets a dN record at the moment it happens — not reconstructed from memory when /summarize-delivery runs later.
• The CLI stays non-orchestrating (issue #20). devague deviate records a decision the human already made; it does not spawn agents, gate merges, mark tasks done, or make the approval decision itself. Recording is deterministic — no LLM calls inside the CLI.
• This is not a fourth standing gate. /assign-to-workforce's three human gates are the exported spec, the implementation split plan, and the final PR. /deviate does not add a fourth — it is the human owner of gate 2 amending the approved split for one scoped, in-flight decision.

Worked example

Mid-fan-out on task t4, the task agent discovers the acceptance criteria assumed a helper that task t2 never actually shipped:

# 1. STOP — the main agent halts t4's worktree before more code lands
#    against a criterion that can't be met as written.

# 2. Present what/why/what-it-affects to the human:
#    what:    t4's acceptance criterion 2 assumes a `--json` flag on a
#             helper that t2 shipped without one
#    why:     t2's scope was cut to land its wave on time
#    affects: t4 (this task), and coverage target c9 (the criterion in
#             question)

# --- HUMAN: approves dropping the --json assumption from t4's criterion ---

# 3. Record the approved deviation
devague deviate "drop the --json assumption from t4's acceptance criterion" \
  --task t4 --reason "t2 shipped its helper without --json to land its wave on time" \
  --affects t2 --affects c9 --classification acceptable

# 4. Adjust t4's working brief to match what was approved, then resume the
#    task agent against the corrected instruction.

# Read the ledger back at any point:
devague deviate --list
devague deviate --list --json

If the agent had proposed the record itself (--origin llm), the same record would land proposed and need an explicit devague deviate --confirm d1 from the user before /summarize-delivery could cite it as approved.

After recording — resume, then hand off to /summarize-delivery

Once the affected task briefs are adjusted and the fan-out resumes, nothing further is needed from this skill — the record already lives in the delivery store. When the run reaches /summarize-delivery, that skill's Drift From Plan and Mid-work Decisions sections quote these records by their dN id instead of reconstructing drift from memory, so the connective tissue between the confirmed plan and the delivery summary is the ledger this skill wrote, not anyone's recollection of the run.

Provenance

This is a first-party skill — its origin is agentculture/devague, the sixth in the outbound family after /scope, /think, /spec-to-plan, /assign-to-workforce, and /summarize-delivery, covering the execution-time leg that runs inside an /assign-to-workforce fan-out. guildmaster pulls it from here and broadcasts it to the AgentCulture mesh; because devague is upstream, it is never re-vendored back from guildmaster's re-broadcast copy. The cite, don't import policy still holds: downstream repos copy it, they don't symlink or depend on it. See docs/skill-sources.md.