audit-skill

name	audit-skill
description	Audits Agent Skills SKILL.md files against the protocol specification and best practices. Identifies issues across 10 categories: schema violations, naming, description quality, structure, progressive disclosure, file references, best practices, calibration, content quality, and optional directories. Produces a structured report with severity levels and actionable fixes.

Audit Skill

Audits Agent Skills SKILL.md files against the Agent Skills specification and best practices. Produces a structured report with severity levels and actionable fixes.

Note: This skill operates offline. Do not rely on external URLs for validation — use the spec constraints defined below.

Usage

Pass the path to the skill directory as the first argument in the delegation:

subAgent({
  delegation: "run audit-skill /path/to/skill-directory",
  cwd: "/path/to/parent"
})

The cwd is the parent directory containing the skill folder. The skill path is the first word after audit-skill in the delegation string.

Audit Categories

Each skill is checked against 10 categories. Every finding includes a severity level:

Severity	Meaning
ERROR	Protocol violation — will fail validation
WARN	Best practice violation — likely to cause problems
INFO	Suggestion — optional improvement

1. Schema Violations (ERROR)

Check frontmatter fields against spec constraints:

• name: Required. Max 64 characters. Non-empty.
• description: Required. Max 1024 characters. Non-empty.
• compatibility: Optional. Max 500 characters if provided.
• metadata: Optional. Must be a string-to-string map (no nested objects) per the standard spec. If the project uses an extended spec that allows nested metadata, skip this check.
• license: Optional. No length constraint, but keep it short.

Note: allowed-tools is NOT part of the standard agent skills spec. If present, log it as INFO (non-standard field) but do not flag as ERROR.

Parse the YAML frontmatter and validate each field. Report any constraint violations.

2. Naming Issues (ERROR)

Validate the name field against naming rules:

• Must be 1–64 characters
• Only lowercase alphanumeric (a-z, 0-9) and hyphens (-)
• Must not start or end with a hyphen
• Must not contain consecutive hyphens (--)
• Must match the parent directory name

Check both the frontmatter name field and the actual directory name. Report mismatches.

3. Description Quality (WARN)

Evaluate the description field for quality:

• Too short: Less than 20 characters — likely insufficient
• Too long (WARN): Over 800 characters — consider trimming for readability
• Too long (ERROR): Over 1024 characters — exceeds spec maximum
• Missing "when to use": Should describe both what the skill does AND when to use it. Look for phrases like "use when", "for", "handles", "processes". A description that only says what it does without triggering context is weak.
• Vague language: Contains generic phrases like "helps with", "deals with", "manages" without specific context
• Missing keywords: Should include specific domain keywords that help agents identify relevant tasks

Good description pattern: [Action] [domain]. Use when [triggering context].

4. Structure Issues (WARN)

Check the Markdown body organization:

• No heading: Body should start with a heading (# Title)
• No sections: Should have at least 2 subheadings (## Section) for navigability
• No examples: Should include at least one code example or usage example
• No step-by-step: Should have numbered steps or a clear workflow for non-trivial skills
• No edge cases: Should mention common edge cases or error conditions

A well-structured skill has: title, overview, steps/workflow, examples, edge cases/gotchas.

5. Progressive Disclosure (WARN)

Check for proper use of progressive disclosure:

• Too large: SKILL.md exceeds or equals 500 lines (>= 500) — should split into references
• Token-heavy: If body exceeds ~5000 tokens, recommend splitting
• Missing references: If the skill has detailed content (scripts, templates, schemas), check for references/ or assets/ directory usage
• No conditional loading: If using references, should tell the agent when to load them (e.g., "Read references/api-errors.md if the API returns a non-200 status")

A skill under 200 lines rarely needs progressive disclosure. Flag only when content is substantial but not properly split.

6. File Reference Issues (ERROR/WARN)

Check file references within the SKILL.md:

• Broken references (ERROR): References to files in references/, assets/, or scripts/ that don't exist
• Deep nesting (WARN): References more than one level deep (e.g., references/subdir/file.md) — spec recommends one level deep
• Relative paths: All references should be relative to the skill root
• Missing referenced files: If the body mentions a script or reference, verify it exists

Check for markdown link syntax [text](path) and code block references. Use ls to verify file existence.

7. Best Practices (WARN/INFO)

Check against best practices from the spec:

• Missing gotchas: Non-trivial skills should have a "Gotchas" or "Common pitfalls" section
• Missing templates: If the skill produces structured output, should include a format template
• Missing checklists: Multi-step workflows should have a checklist
• Missing validation: Complex skills should include a validation step
• No scripts for repeated logic: If the skill describes the same logic repeatedly, consider bundling a script in scripts/
• No defaults: When multiple approaches exist, should pick a default and mention alternatives briefly

8. Calibration Issues (WARN)

Check instruction specificity:

• Too vague: Instructions like "handle errors appropriately", "follow best practices", "use good judgment" without specifics. Flag if > 10% of instructions are vague.
• Too prescriptive: Overly rigid instructions for tasks that tolerate variation (e.g., "always use X" when Y is equally valid)
• No why explanations: Flexible instructions should explain why, not just what. Flag if > 20% of instructions lack rationale.
• Menus instead of defaults: Lists multiple tools/approaches as equal options without a recommended default
• Procedure vs declaration: Skill teaches what to produce for a specific instance instead of how to approach a class of problems

Concrete example of vague instruction: "Make sure the code is good" → Should specify: "Follow AGENTS.md §3.3 error handling rules and §3.5 testing conventions."

9. Content Quality (WARN)

Check for domain-specific expertise:

• Generic instructions: Relies on general knowledge instead of project-specific or domain-specific context. Flag if > 30% of content is generic.
• Missing domain context: Doesn't include API patterns, edge cases, or project conventions
• Explains the obvious: Describes basic concepts the agent already knows (e.g., "PDF files are a common file format"). Flag if > 15% of content explains obvious concepts.
• No real-world examples: Lacks concrete examples from actual usage

A good skill adds what the agent lacks and omits what it already knows. Concrete example: Instead of "Handle errors", say "Catch ENOENT when reading config files and fall back to defaults."

10. Optional Directories (INFO)

Check usage of optional directories:

• scripts/ present: Verify scripts are self-contained, executable, and documented. Flag if scripts reference files outside the skill directory.
• references/ present: Verify reference files are focused (under 200 lines each) and not too large. Flag if any reference exceeds 500 lines.
• assets/ present: Verify assets are templates, images, or data files (not code). Flag if assets contain executable code.
• Missing opportunities: If the skill has large templates or repeated logic, suggest scripts/ or assets/
• Empty directories: Flag if scripts/, references/, or assets/ exist but are empty — remove them or populate them.

Execution

1. Read the SKILL.md from the provided skill directory:

   cat "$SKILL_PATH/SKILL.md"
   

2. Parse the YAML frontmatter — extract all fields using a YAML parser:

   # Extract frontmatter (between first and second ---)
   sed -n '1,/^---$/p' "$SKILL_PATH/SKILL.md" | tail -n +2 | head -n -1
   

   Parse the YAML frontmatter to extract fields. If no YAML parser is available, parse manually with grep/sed.
3. Read the Markdown body — analyze structure and content:

   # Count lines in body (after frontmatter)
   wc -l < <(sed '1,/^---$/d' "$SKILL_PATH/SKILL.md")
   # Count subheadings
   grep -c '^## ' "$SKILL_PATH/SKILL.md"
   # Count examples (code blocks)
   grep -c '^```' "$SKILL_PATH/SKILL.md" | awk '{print int($1/2)}'
   

4. Check for optional directories — list scripts/, references/, assets/ if they exist:

   ls -la "$SKILL_PATH/scripts/" "$SKILL_PATH/references/" "$SKILL_PATH/assets/" 2>&1
   

5. Validate file references — check that referenced files exist:

   # Extract file paths from markdown links and code references
   grep -oE '\[[^]]*\]\([^)]*\)'  | sed  |   ref; 
      [ ! -f  ]; 
        
     
   
   

Output Format

Produce a structured report in this format:

## Skill Audit: <skill-name>
- **Path:** <path-to-skill>
- **Status:** <pass | warnings | errors>
- **Findings:** <N> total (<E> errors, <W> warnings, <I> info)

### Schema Violations
- [ERROR] description exceeds 1024 characters (found: 1203)

### Naming Issues
- [WARN] name contains consecutive hyphens: "my--skill"

### Description Quality
- [WARN] description is only 12 characters — consider expanding
- [INFO] missing "when to use" context

### Structure Issues
- [WARN] no examples found — add at least one usage example

### Progressive Disclosure
- [INFO] skill is 45 lines — no splitting needed

### File References
- [ERROR] references `scripts/extract.py` but file does not exist

### Best Practices
- [WARN] no gotchas section — consider adding common pitfalls

### Calibration
- [WARN] vague instruction: "handle errors appropriately"

### Content Quality
- [INFO] explains basic concepts the agent likely already knows

### Optional Directories
- [INFO] no scripts/ directory — consider bundling repeated logic

### Summary
- **Severity breakdown:** 2 errors, 4 warnings, 3 info
- **Top priority fixes:** [list top 3 actionable items]

Note: Skip categories with no findings. Only include sections that have at least one finding.

Heuristics Reference

Use these concrete thresholds:

Check	Threshold	Severity
Name length	> 64 chars	ERROR
Description length	< 20 chars	WARN
Description length	> 800 chars	WARN
Description length	> 1024 chars	ERROR
Compatibility length	> 500 chars	ERROR
SKILL.md lines	> 500 lines	WARN
Subheadings	< 2	WARN
Examples	0 found	WARN
File references	Broken	ERROR
Reference depth	> 1 level	WARN

Error Handling

• SKILL.md not found: Report the error and stop. No audit possible.
• Invalid YAML frontmatter: Report the parse error and stop.
• Directory not found: Report the error and stop.
• Permission denied: Report the specific file/directory and stop. Do not attempt to bypass permissions.
• Partial audit: If some checks fail but others succeed, report what was accomplished. Never leave the audit half-done.

Example

User: audit-skill /home/jason/Projects/madz/skills/my-skill

Agent: Auditing skill "my-skill"...

## Skill Audit: my-skill
- **Path:** /home/jason/Projects/madz/skills/my-skill
- **Status:** warnings
- **Findings:** 5 total (0 errors, 4 warnings, 1 info)

### Description Quality
- [WARN] description is only 15 characters — consider expanding
- [INFO] missing "when to use" context

### Structure Issues
- [WARN] no examples found — add at least one usage example
- [WARN] only 1 subheading — add more sections for navigability

### Best Practices
- [WARN] no gotchas section — consider adding common pitfalls

### Progressive Disclosure
- [INFO] skill is 30 lines — no splitting needed

### Summary
- **Severity breakdown:** 0 errors, 4 warnings, 1 info
- **Top priority fixes:**
  1. Expand description to at least 20 characters with "when to use" context
  2. Add at least one usage example
  3. Add a gotchas section for common pitfalls

Error Case Example

User: audit-skill /home/jason/Projects/madz/skills/nonexistent-skill

Agent: Auditing skill "nonexistent-skill"...

## Skill Audit: nonexistent-skill
- **Path:** /home/jason/Projects/madz/skills/nonexistent-skill
- **Status:** error
- **Findings:** 1 total (1 errors, 0 warnings, 0 info)

### Schema Violations
- [ERROR] SKILL.md not found at /home/jason/Projects/madz/skills/nonexistent-skill/SKILL.md

### Summary
- **Severity breakdown:** 1 errors, 0 warnings, 0 info
- **Top priority fixes:**
  1. Verify the skill path is correct and the SKILL.md file exists