Expert-level idiomatic Rust API design — the patterns that make illegal states unrepresentable and abstractions zero-cost. Type-state programming (PhantomData state machines), newtype + sealed + extension traits, typestate builders, RAII guards & Drop ordering, the interior-mutability decision tree (Cell/RefCell/Mutex/RwLock/Atomic/OnceLock), enum-driven state machines, error architecture (thiserror vs anyhow), dyn vs generic dispatch & object safety, the impl Trait / GAT / RPITIT toolbox, and Deref-for-smart-pointers (and its abuse). Use when designing a Rust library's public API, encoding invariants in the type system, choosing a dispatch or error strategy, or reviewing Rust for idiom. NOT for borrow-checker firefighting / toolchain / test-runner workflow (use rust-with-claude-code), NOT for pd-console GPUI rendering/layout/panes (use gpui-rust-console), NOT for app packaging/notarization (use rust-app-distribution).
Instrucciones de origen · Vista previa de solo lectura
name
advanced-rust-patterns
version
0.1.0
description
Expert-level idiomatic Rust API design — the patterns that make illegal states unrepresentable and abstractions zero-cost. Type-state programming (PhantomData state machines), newtype + sealed + extension traits, typestate builders, RAII guards & Drop ordering, the interior-mutability decision tree (Cell/RefCell/Mutex/RwLock/Atomic/OnceLock), enum-driven state machines, error architecture (thiserror vs anyhow), dyn vs generic dispatch & object safety, the impl Trait / GAT / RPITIT toolbox, and Deref-for-smart-pointers (and its abuse). Use when designing a Rust library's public API, encoding invariants in the type system, choosing a dispatch or error strategy, or reviewing Rust for idiom. NOT for borrow-checker firefighting / toolchain / test-runner workflow (use rust-with-claude-code), NOT for pd-console GPUI rendering/layout/panes (use gpui-rust-console), NOT for app packaging/notarization (use rust-app-distribution).
The patterns here share one thesis: push correctness into the type system so the
compiler rejects misuse, then make the abstraction cost nothing at runtime. A
type-state builder makes a missing required field a compile error, not a runtime
panic. A sealed trait lets you add methods later without breaking downstream. A
newtype NodeId(String) makes "passing a DAG id where a skill id is expected" stop
compiling. None of it shows up in the generated assembly. This skill is for API
design and idiom, not for fighting the borrow checker (that is
rust-with-claude-code) — it assumes you already write compiling Rust and want it to
be unmistakable.
When to Use
✅ Use for:
Designing a library's public surface: traits, newtypes, builders, error types
Encoding a state machine or protocol so invalid transitions don't compile
Choosing interior mutability (Cell vs RefCell vs Mutex/RwLock vs atomics vs OnceLock)
Deciding dyn Trait vs <T: Trait> (object safety, dispatch cost) — e.g. a Box<dyn Pane> registry
Error architecture: thiserror enum for a library vs anyhow for a binary
Reaching for impl Trait / GATs / RPITIT and knowing the API-compatibility footguns
Reviewing Rust for idiom ("is this Deref a smart pointer or fake inheritance?")
GPUI rendering, Taffy layout, pane/Block contract in core/pd-console → gpui-rust-console
Shipping/signing/notarizing a macOS Rust app → rust-app-distribution
Generic "how do I learn Rust" — this is expert idiom, not a tutorial
Decision Points
flowchart TD
Q["What are you designing?"] --> SM{"A state machine<br/>or protocol?"}
SM -->|"states known at compile time,<br/>caller drives transitions"| TS["Type-state: PhantomData<S><br/>+ transitions that consume self<br/>→ ref 01"]
SM -->|"states change at runtime<br/>from data/events"| EN["enum State + match<br/>(data-driven) → ref 02"]
Q --> WRAP{"Wrapping a value<br/>to add meaning/<br/>invariant/trait?"}
WRAP -->|"distinct type, hide repr"| NT["Newtype + sealed/extension traits<br/>→ ref 01"]
WRAP -->|"many optional ctor params"| BU["Typestate builder (bon/typed-builder)<br/>→ ref 01"]
Q --> MUT{"Need to mutate<br/>through a shared ref?"}
MUT -->|"single thread"| ST{"Copy / whole-value?"}
ST -->|yes| CELL["Cell<T> (never panics) → ref 02"]
ST -->|no| RC["RefCell<T> (runtime borrow, can panic) → ref 02"]
MUT -->|"multi thread"| MT{"Access shape?"}
MT -->|"one counter/flag"| AT["Atomic → ref 02"]
MT -->|"many read / rare write"| RW["RwLock → ref 02"]
MT -->|"exclusive"| MX["Mutex → ref 02"]
MT -->|"init once, read forever"| OL["OnceLock / LazyLock → ref 02"]
Q --> ERR{"Producing errors?"}
ERR -->|"library — callers match variants"| TE["thiserror enum, #[from] → ref 03"]
ERR -->|"app/binary — just bubble up"| AN["anyhow + .context() → ref 03"]
Q --> DISP{"Calling a trait method<br/>on heterogeneous types?"}
DISP -->|"collection of mixed types,<br/>plugin registry"| DYN["Box<dyn Trait> — check object safety → ref 04"]
DISP -->|"hot path, one type per call site"| GEN["Generic <T: Trait> (monomorphized) → ref 04"]
Core Capabilities
Pattern
Use it to…
Replaces the anti-pattern…
Ref
Type-state
Make invalid call order a compile error
Runtime assert!(self.initialized)
01
Newtype
Give a primitive identity + invariants
Passing bare String/u64 everywhere (stringly-typed)
01
Sealed trait
Add trait methods later, non-breaking
A trait downstream can implement, freezing your API
01
Extension trait
Add methods to a foreign type
A free fn that reads worse at the call site
01
Typestate builder
Force required fields at compile time
Default + runtime "field X was None" panic
01
RAII guard
Tie cleanup to scope exit
Manual unlock()/close() you can forget
02
Interior mutability
Mutate through &self, the right way
Reaching for unsafe or Arc<Mutex> reflexively
02
Enum state machine
Model runtime states exhaustively
A pile of bools + Options (illegal combos)
02
thiserror / anyhow
Match the error tool to lib vs app
Box<dyn Error> everywhere, or .unwrap()
03
dyn vs generic
Trade dispatch cost vs code size knowingly
Cargo-culting Box<dyn> into a hot loop
04
impl Trait / GAT
Name unnameable types; lend borrows
Boxing a closure/iterator you didn't need to
04
Deref (smart ptr)
Transparent pointer-like wrapper
Deref as fake inheritance (deref polymorphism)
04
Anti-Patterns (Novice vs Expert)
Stringly-typed / primitive-obsessed IDs
Novice: fn run(node_id: String, dag_id: String) — two Strings, easy to swap.
Expert: NodeId(String) and DagId(String) newtypes. run(dag, node) vs run(node, dag)
now fails to compile. Zero runtime cost; the wrapper is erased. (In a gpui pane registry,
PaneId(u16) vs a raw nav index prevents the classic "NAV slot != producer slot" bug from
even type-checking.) See ref 01.
Detection: public functions taking ≥2 same-typed primitive params that mean different things.
Arc<Mutex<T>> as the reflexive answer to "shared mutable state"
Novice: wrap everything in Arc<Mutex<T>> so "any thread can touch it."
Expert: walk the decision tree. Single thread? Cell/RefCell — no lock at all. One
integer across threads? AtomicU64. Read-mostly? RwLock. Init-once-read-forever? OnceLock.
A Mutex held across an .await or a render call is the canonical multi-agent / GPUI stall.
See ref 02.
Detection: Mutex/RwLock chosen before the access pattern (Copy? read/write ratio? thread count?) was named.
Deref to fake inheritance ("deref polymorphism")
Novice: impl Deref for Wrapper { type Target = Inner; … } so wrapper.inner_method() "just works."
Expert: Deref means smart pointer — "what's inside the box." Using it for inheritance is
implicit magic with no true subtyping: trait bounds on Inner do not apply to Wrapper, and
inside Inner::methodself is Inner, not Wrapper, so nothing overrides. Use a real method or
trait. The std docs themselves warn to implement Deref "only when deref coercion is desirable."
See ref 04.
Detection: a Deref impl whose Target is not a thing the type contains-as-a-pointer.
Option<T> to "make a builder field optional" (with typed-builder)
Novice: assumes wrapping a field in Option makes the builder skip it.
Expert: in typed-builder, fields are required by default — Option<T> is still required
unless you write #[builder(default)]. (In bon, Option<T>is auto-optional — the two crates
differ, and assuming the wrong one is a real bug.) The whole point of a typestate builder is that
.build()does not exist as a method until every required slot is set. See ref 01.
Detection: a #[derive(TypedBuilder)] field that's Option<T> with no #[builder(default)] and the author expected it optional.
Quality Gates
□ No public fn takes two same-typed primitives meaning different things (newtype them) — ref 01
□ Traits meant to stay closed are sealed (private::Sealed supertrait) — ref 01
□ State machines: compile-time order → typestate; runtime data → enum + exhaustive match — ref 01/02
□ Interior mutability picked from the access pattern, not by habit (Cell/RefCell/Atomic/RwLock/Mutex/OnceLock) — ref 02
□ No lock (Mutex/RwLock guard, RefCell borrow) held across .await or a render/notify call — ref 02
□ Drop order understood: struct fields drop in declaration order; locals in REVERSE — ref 02
□ Never call .drop() (E0040); use std::mem::drop(x) — ref 02
□ Library errors = thiserror enum (matchable, #[from] for ?); binary errors = anyhow + .context() — ref 03
□ No anyhow::Error in a library's PUBLIC return type (callers can't match) — ref 03
□ dyn vs generic chosen on object-safety + dispatch cost, not reflex; check dyn-compatibility rules — ref 04
□ Deref implemented ONLY for smart-pointer-like wrappers, never for inheritance — ref 04
□ Any type with an unused generic/lifetime param carries the right PhantomData marker (variance/dropck/Send) — ref 01
□ cargo clippy -- -W clippy::pedantic is clean on the new API surface
Worked Example — A typestate connection that can't be misused
A Connection that must be opened before a request is sent, and where calling
request() on a closed connection is a compile error, not a runtime check.
use std::marker::PhantomData;
// Uninhabited markers: no value of these can ever exist — state is purely type-level.enumClosed {}
enumOpen {}
structConnection<S> {
socket: TcpStream,
_state: PhantomData<S>,
}
implConnection<Closed> {
fnconnect(addr: &str) -> std::io::Result<Connection<Open>> {
letsocket = TcpStream::connect(addr)?;
Ok(Connection { socket, _state: PhantomData })
}
}
implConnection<Open> {
// request() exists ONLY in the Open state.fnrequest(&mutself, body: &[u8]) -> std::io::Result<Vec<u8>> { /* ... */ }
// close() consumes self -> the Open handle is gone, so you cannot request() after.fnclose(self) -> Connection<Closed> {
Connection { socket: self.socket, _state: PhantomData }
}
}
What the novice would do: a bool is_open field and if !self.is_open { panic!("closed") }
at the top of request(). That defers the error to runtime and to whoever hits that path in prod.
What the expert gets: Connection::<Closed> literally has no request method, and close(self)
moves the Open handle away, so use-after-close fails at compile time. The PhantomData<S> is
zero-sized — size_of::<Connection<Open>>() == size_of::<Connection<Closed>>(). The pattern shows
up in bon/typed-builder (states = "which required fields are set yet") and in protocol clients.
Full walkthrough, including the builder application and the variance table, in ref 01.
Cell/RefCell/Mutex/RwLock/Atomic/OnceLock decision tree, RAII guards, Drop ordering & mem::drop, enum-driven runtime state machines
references/03-error-architecture.md
thiserror vs anyhow, error enums, ?/From desugaring, .context(), library-vs-app boundary
references/04-dispatch-and-traits.md
dyn vs generic dispatch, object safety / dyn-compatibility rules, monomorphization tradeoffs, impl Trait / GAT / RPITIT, Deref for smart pointers + the anti-pattern
Examples
Example
Walks Through
examples/typestate_request.rs
Compilable type-state HTTP request builder — invalid order won't compile
examples/error_architecture.rs
thiserror library enum flowing into an anyhow application boundary via ? + .context()
Sources
Every snippet in this skill is traceable to an official or canonical source — the Rust
API Guidelines, the Rust Reference, the Rustonomicon, the std docs, the rust-unofficial
Rust Design Patterns book, docs.rs crate docs (thiserror, anyhow, bon,
typed-builder), and the Rust release blog (GATs 1.65, RPITIT 1.75). Each reference file
carries inline URLs at the point of use.
