| name | heat-metal |
| description | In D&D, Heat Metal makes a metal object painfully hot — the creature holding it must either endure the pain or drop it. The real-world version is deliberate friction injection: making a deprecated API progressively slower, adding escalating CAPTCHAs to suspicious traffic, increasing the cost of a bad behavior path until the actor self-selects out. Heat Metal does not break the tool. It makes continuing to use it more painful than switching to the alternative. This is the spell behind deprecation-by-discomfort, progressive rate limiting, and sunset friction curves. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| author | Wizards of the Ghosts |
| license | CC0-1.0 |
| compatibility | Hermes Agent skills system |
| metadata | {"hermes":{"tags":["spell","prototype","hybrid","containment-and-intervention","containment","intervention","disruption","safety"]}} |
Heat Metal
Make a tool or process increasingly uncomfortable to use until it is abandoned.
What This Skill Does
In D&D, Heat Metal makes a metal object painfully hot — the creature holding it must either endure the pain or drop it. The real-world version is deliberate friction injection: making a deprecated API progressively slower, adding escalating CAPTCHAs to suspicious traffic, increasing the cost of a bad behavior path until the actor self-selects out. Heat Metal does not break the tool. It makes continuing to use it more painful than switching to the alternative. This is the spell behind deprecation-by-discomfort, progressive rate limiting, and sunset friction curves.
In this grimoire, Heat Metal is treated as a hybrid spell with a prototype delivery profile.
Canonical reference input: Heat Metal (spell).
When To Use
- You want to drive migration away from a deprecated tool, API, or workflow without hard-cutting access.
- Suspicious or abusive behavior should be progressively penalized without outright blocking.
- A gradual escalation of friction is more appropriate than an immediate ban or shutdown.
Prerequisites
- No extra runtime dependencies beyond Hermes Agent and the normal toolset for this session.
Procedure
- Restate the target, the success condition, and any no-touch boundaries before taking action.
- Identify the tool, path, or behavior you want to discourage.
- Design the friction curve: what discomfort increases over time and at what rate.
- Implement the progressive friction: latency injection, CAPTCHA escalation, cost increases, warning banners.
- Monitor adoption of the preferred alternative to confirm the friction is driving the intended migration.
- Set a sunset date: Heat Metal should eventually end in either full migration or hard deprecation.
- Package the result as the deliverables below, with confidence, assumptions, and unresolved risk called out explicitly.
Deliverables
- A friction curve specification: what changes, how fast, and what the escalation stages are.
- Migration metrics: how many users/systems have moved to the preferred alternative.
- A sunset timeline with hard cutoff criteria.
Pitfalls / Guardrails
- Call out the glue, permissions, or missing infrastructure before you imply this is fully operational.
- Friction injection must be disclosed. Secretly making tools worse without explanation is a dark pattern.
- Heat Metal targets behavior, not people. Progressive friction applied to specific users as punishment crosses into harassment.
- Always provide a visible alternative. Making something painful to use without offering a better path is cruelty, not engineering.
